Here's a way to get your competition to quit the biz. - 08.12.10
Today's Poll: Do you think seller paid DAP's are worse than VA or USDA?
Yes
No
Rate this Program
loanhack: (August 13, 2010 5:46pm)
Sorry boys you've missed it on this one. At least in SoCal the only ones who can take advantage of Seller paid DAP are the new home builders. I'm pretty sure the banks on short sales and REOS are going to pony up an additional 3.5%. With appraisals still being tight increasing the sales price is less likely to happen now.
CoolCathy: (August 13, 2010 10:08am)
The DAP model makes sense in our market. AVG Buyer: Has good income, currently rents for more than the PITI of starter home they want to buy. Can't save up down payment, because rents are high. They don't mind being at 100% because they are getting more for less, pride of ownership, freedom to decorate-have a dog, raise kids in a home not an apt. and tax benefits which renting doesn't do. Over the long haul it will also build equity. What's so different than a VA no-no?
cpappraiser: (August 12, 2010 4:07pm)
"Owner incentives" plop on top of the sales price and increase it to a new higher "sales price" that get used without subtracting the incentives in future appraisals. It adds 2-3% each time cumulatively. Shouldn't work that way? Well that is what it does. Bubble trouble with minimal downs and an underwater swim the day the loan closes that increases depth in a declining market. Tomorrow's foreclosures seeded today. Have we not had enough? Guess not. We are doing it again and again and again. We sank Freddie and Fannie and FHA is holding its breath for its dunking. You think this market is weak? Watch it get weaker with more inadequately structured loans being steadily written into the system.
SGreek: (August 12, 2010 2:37pm)
5pence: and here I thought Samuel Adams was just a great brewmaster! LOL...I like the way you think, the passion you display, and the quotes you make! I hope and pray to God (not godlike mind you!) that things turn around for you...and all us others. What area are you in?
SGreek: (August 12, 2010 2:33pm)
You really DO have the wisdom of The Holy One godlike! I agree completely...what the heck are we missing here Brian, Frank, Dirk (hey, send me that paper too...asked for it earlier today)et al??
GODLIKE: (August 12, 2010 2:30pm)
KISS it! A 100% loan also means fewer people between the borrower and a loan approval. When you have to add a second layer of approval or application then you are just making more work for more people. This 2nd layer is where the fraud originated in the old programs and is why we no longer have them. Keep It Simple Stupid!
GODLIKE: (August 12, 2010 2:13pm)
I don't understand this fixation on DPA. If a 100% loan makes sense just offer that instead of adding a layer of complexity that invites fraud, abuse and appraisal issues. Then make a 100% loan that makes sense and is likely to keep late pays and foreclosure to a minimum.
dirk2290: (August 12, 2010 2:10pm)
I sent it to them today......
dirk2290: (August 12, 2010 2:09pm)
We sould reform SFDAP's, not keep them dead. Risk Tiers/levels according to credit score. There are plenty of level headed make sense resolutions on how to reform this, but why ask people that have the answers, just let Frank, Dodd and Geitner tell you how to manage finances. Oxymoron! What the hell do Congressmen know about SFDAP's amd how to reform them? Nothing, someone who had a hard on for them because the middle men were making to much money off of them, so they need to be outlawed. SO off with their head they went. Ludicrous. This could have been fixed over a year ago. I sent TBWS my proposals when this was in comment period almost 2 years ago.
5pence: (August 12, 2010 1:38pm)
Thanks for the link SGreek, I read that before and a few others that try to trace that quote- great link. The Scottish guy, I read, wrote it about Athenia but I believe they were a democracy, 1 of the first-so it directly relates to us imo. Thanks, but no, I'm not brilliant because I can quote great ideas & ideologies, I'm just a pissed off out of work appraiser trying to figure out how we got in this mess and what we can do to fix it. Seeking dialogue, seeking great ideas, seeking change in all our best interests before this great country falls off a cliff. We need a great awakening, this country has been asleep too long, so long the administration thinks they can just say "We're recovered" and people will believe it and keep on dreaming. Clueless. SGreek - the more posters the better! A great quote: "It does not require a majority to prevail, but rather an irate, tireless minority keen to set brush fires in people's minds." Samuel Adams (The "Father" of the American Revolution)
Bono Vox: (August 12, 2010 1:33pm)
Fellas - the market will settle out in two years or so when business owners know the impact of healthcare reform, tax increases and high government debt loads and feel comfy hiring again. It will literally take two years or so to have the FinReg rules written. Once that happens, folks from farmers to financiers will feel better about investing in their businesses.
Bono Vox: (August 12, 2010 1:29pm)
Frank, going clubbing later? Cool shirt. You guys are asking about various programs and DAPs. Check out the derog payments on each of those types of loans and let me know what you find. HUD internal numbers showed DAP came in dead last. Fis those facts and you have a case. Good luck, I'd like to have these deals, but the numbers aren't good.
dirk2290: (August 12, 2010 1:23pm)
I meant regain the loss from today, in the next days to come?
dirk2290: (August 12, 2010 1:22pm)
Bonds are still tanking today, down 53 bps now. WTF? Will we reagin this loss today?
SGreek: (August 12, 2010 1:19pm)
Dang...what's a guy gotta do to at least get a smiley face, or LOL??? Crap...I just can't help myself!
ShackDiva: (August 12, 2010 12:59pm)
AMEN! I miss seller assisted DPA and our NV bond DPA has stringent requirements so you walk an extremely fine line for being able to qualify for an FHA loan (income wise) and be able to qualify for bond DPA. Didn't see too many HUD homes in the day of seller assisted DPA and I see more now but not as many as the 80/20 stated that go into foreclosure. OH and they go into foreclosure more often than not for strategic default reasons - not because they couldn't afford the home in the first place. I think they should bring it back so sellers can subsidize incentives to buy - not the government. We saw three major purchasing frenzies here in the last two years: the first when seller assisted DPA was going away, the second when the tax credit was expiring last October and the third when the tax credit expired in April. Now the crickets are chirping on the first time buyer front again! Great post! (FYI, I am a Las Vegas Realtor)
dirk2290: (August 12, 2010 12:05pm)
I know that possibly the majority of Congressmen/women are somehow influenced heavily by lobbyists or special interests groups, but not all...or at least at first. Politics is not cut and dry, never was and never will be. There has always been back scratching, and always will. There will always be compromising for the greater good, ends justifying the means, and not always getting your way to accomplish your agenda. It may be the peoples agenda, but when a politican takes it on, it becomes a personal agenda, and will do somehthings perhps the people wouldn't approve to get the agenda completed, and this is where the politics goes sideways. The politicans take it upon themselves to make those back door deals. The lobbists only have the idea of the bill, and the politicans staff writers write the proposal. IE: If you pass the zoning change on this Commerical park, we will fund the building of the homeless shelter that is on your Agenda. Small example......
SGreek: (August 12, 2010 11:54am)
W.R. Buchanan - sorry, but Godlike has the position of Divine Ruler apparently locked down 5pence - you are one brilliant dude...are you the one the end of each day's video is talking about?? You were close on Tytler...and I promise you I wasn't setting you up (I'm the Clint Eastwood character whos says to Renee Russo character in "In the Line of Fire"..."Really? I had to look it up..." Anyway, check out the following link for some interesting, seemingly unbiased history: http://www.lorencollins.net/tytler.html All of ya'll: how THE HELL do you get any work done with all this blog posting & intellectual/political posturing? LOL!!! Have you TRULY managed to "Think Big...And Work Small". If so, I need HELP!! I'm outta here...been fun, but I'm gonna do my best to stay away...at least for awhile!
5pence: (August 12, 2010 11:51am)
That's just it dirk2290, consider that Congressmen/women doesn't even write those bills, the lobbyists do-so what do we need them in there for? Any idiot could let a lobbyist write a bill. But if you choose correctly the candidate just might go to sources outside of the usual suspects for advice-like real economists or real bankers that are impartial and that know things are screwed up. As far as randomly voting someone in without experience, as has been shown experience doesn't matter. How about this, vote out everybody that voted for TARP and voted to not break up the TBTF's. We've got to get a message across to the elites and the only way they listen is through votes. I don't care if the candidate is dumb, as long as their loyalties are in the right place. The system is screwed the way it's set up-screwed for us. We get the the worst in 2 choices only because "they paid their dues" which usually means they're in corporate pockets. I'm rambling, distracted with a few things goin on.
dirk2290: (August 12, 2010 10:53am)
@ 5pence-I hear what you are saying. That is common sense, but that would take forever to accomplish that sort of precedence. However, it's not as hard as some people beleive it is. To start out low in politics and run for your States Congress, which could consist of a saml District with hardly any runners at all. Seriously, checksome of your Districts and some of the opposing party there won't even be anyone on the Primary ticket at all. What I am saying, is that I don't think that is entirely true. You can't think you are going to vote someone in randomly for US Congress. You have to get your experience, pay your time, and move up the chain. In some States this is very feasible. If you have a chance, listen to some interviews from some candidates that are running for some ST Congress positions. They are certainly note the brightest bulbs in the pack nor are they high rollers or big players. They are simply evry day people that say they are tired of the same thing we are all tired of
5pence: (August 12, 2010 10:46am)
Calif.dreaming. Check out the Frank and Brian video on the FDIC and why it's more profitable for the banks to foreclose than do a short sale. http://www.thinkbigworksmall.com/mypage/archive/1/32274
5pence: (August 12, 2010 10:39am)
dirk2290: Sad part is, the choices they're offering a no choices at all. Dylan Ratigan said Instead of just voting for someone on the ballot, there should be a place to vote against someone. Take that a step further and the votes against should be subtracted from the votes for. What if both candidates ended up with negative votes because they are really no choice at all? They'd have to reconsider how things are done. Sounds fair to me. In Ct recently, less than 20% of the people turned out for the primaries compared to over 40% 2 yrs ago. It's because there's no real choices. Check out inverted totalitarianism at wiki. Here's an excerpt : Inverted totalitarianism aims for the mass of the population to be in a persistent state of political apathy. The only type of political activity expected or desired from the citizenry is voting. Low electoral turnouts are favorably received as an indication that the bulk of the population has given up hope that the government will ever help them."
5pence: (August 12, 2010 10:29am)
There are many considerations and unintended consequences of DAP's. Godlike made some very good points about vets getting 1 shot to get a home through VA and if they screw it up they can't ever do it again. That is skin the game. Also, VA appraisers follow a different set of rules in valuations. I don't know what they are, I'm not on the VA panel. But they seem to work. DAP is ok if the appraisers reflect them accurately in the valuation. Most don't or don't know how to. So, DAP will lead to higher values unless the DAP is adjusted out first and other rules need to be in place for flipping investors. Lets face it, the banks are not doing any real quality underwriting as far as the appraiser valuations, since they know they're hiring the bottom of the barrel appraisers, so anything that affects sales price will have consequences in the market. If the banks aren't doing their jobs righteously & correctly, how can they expect us to function efficiently. More regulation? lol
Calif.dreaming: (August 12, 2010 10:22am)
OK here is what I have to say about the 1 X 53 Fraud Short Sales with flips as the litmus test. How does that compare to the fact that the banks are ignoring higher offers that are conventional owner occupied offers for $30,000-$50,000 (less) cash offers or not even accepting the conventional owner occupied offer to then foreclose and it sell at auction for $50,000-$60,000 less to an investor who flips. I have personally seen 25 of these in the last 18 months!!!!
pazookie: (August 12, 2010 10:21am)
it shows up on the left from time to time.. "Fight Against the dollar decline" "protect your hard earned money"... "Gold wealth management".... What a sales pitch... "the dollar sucks, please send it to us & we'll give you gold"...
dirk2290: (August 12, 2010 10:13am)
Put the horse before the cart. This is all blah blah blah, until these folks getout and vote for the Primary's and the Mid terms. How many people that are ranting don't even know which District they live in? Probably 90%+. How in the hell can we expect Congress or the Senate to represent us correctly, when most of us don't even know what a Primary is, let alone which District you live in and who represents you in that District. EDUCATION is key, and these assanin laws get passed through because we the people don't have the foggiest clue.
tbwbrian: (August 12, 2010 10:13am)
me neither! where is it?
5pence: (August 12, 2010 10:12am)
From recollection, SGreek, it was claimed to be written by Alexander Tytler. But, scholars have researched it and found it's actually 2 authors, a Scottish author (can't remember the names right now) wrote part of it in 1700, and an English author wrote the other part around 1760. Now these guys saw this 300 years ago. Haven't we learned??!! Or do the powers that be bury tenets that threaten their plans for domination. Did you know that the Dupont and JP Morgan Chase hired a general and an army of 500,000 to overthrow our government and install a fascist regime because FDR wanted to take from the wealthy and give to the poor? It only got busted up because the general told Congress of their plans. Great Depression and the New Deal. We are at war, Obama won't admit it, with the banks. Thomas Jefferson 3rd president of the US (1743-1826) "I believe that banking institutions are more dangerous to our liberties than standing armies." But I digress...
pazookie: (August 12, 2010 10:10am)
I can't believe you guys have "gold" advertisement on the left... GAWWWDDD!!!
W.R.Buchanan: (August 12, 2010 10:07am)
5pence. You got the cycle of evolution exactly right. But what we need is a benign ruler to straiten everything out, clean out congress, set up new ethics rules and an independent body to administer them. Close the border, fix immigration, and put the banks in their place, and every other problem we've got. And then hand it all back to a new government without all of the lifers! Sounds like ME! Yes,,, ME for divine ruler! You'd love ME! Right up until I stepped of YOUR toes, then You'd snivel and your media would bring ME down, just to sell newspapers. Yes guys there needs to be some fundimental changes made to our country, OOPS That's what de Bamas was a sellin' HOW' s that workin' out? All you can do is have faith in the 2 party system which will work, but the "Corruption" part has got to go! or else we will fall. Randy
SGreek: (August 12, 2010 9:59am)
5pence, you took the words (at least most of the inital ones anyway) right out of my mouth. Don't think it was FlaMoneyMan's intentions to say it that way, when you look at the rest of his comments, but...point well taken. Take it a step further though...not sure it should even be the will of the people now at this juncture, since the majority of them seem to be voting themselves the largesse your quote refers to. Ahh, but that is NOT actually what is happening anyway...we are a republic/representative gov't in which our reps are "supposedly" representing the will of their corresponding constituents. Instead, the system seems to have morphed into something that is self-perpetuating & auto-corrupting...to the benefit of those in office, and those who are in bondage. NOT what the founding fathers invisioned for sure. In an ideal world, the representatives would be doing what is best for the country and the people as a WHOLE. Can you remind me who that great quote is attributed to?
SGreek: (August 12, 2010 9:36am)
dirk2290: (August 12, 2010 9:35am)
look, we are the people that vote for these guys, and unfortunately most people do not vote in the primary's nor the mid terms, and as a result of that we have knuckle heads running the govt making decisions for the so called legislative district you live in. Most people only vote once every 4 years, and then vote based upon emotions, and know no facts about the candidates, thus the situation we are in now, because so many people hated Bush at the end, Now we have a Pres who will arguably we close to Woodrow Wilson or FDR as far as the worst presidents ever. Really, 146 days of experience and he gets the job. Why is it, that huge issues that garbage Health Care wasn't voted on a ballot??? Because the Aeican People would have not passed it, only 37% wanted it. Perfect example! So, we must go to the polls for the primary's and mid terms, or we have no one to blame for idiots like Maxine Waters being 2nd in command in the financial services committee! Really? WTF?
Flamoneyman: (August 12, 2010 9:24am)
Godlike, that is my point. How in the heck is it possible that darn near every representative and senator that opposes or approves has the same letter behind their name? That tell a story of loyalty to their party and the contempt of their constituents! They need to think of who votes them in. That is OUR voice. Here in Fla. we have a govenor who left his party because the party absolutly rejected any bipartisen interaction.He called them out on it. Kudos to him and to any other politician who recognises that what is good is good and what is bad is bad, regardless of the sponsor. Thanks for subscribing to my theory
5pence: (August 12, 2010 9:21am)
Flamoneyman: How about not "the candidate that will benefit me", but the one that will benefit us all! Selfishness needs to get out of the American psyche & politics! Vote for the one that will do the will of the people. "A democracy cannot exist as a permanent form of government. It can only exist until the voters discover that they can vote themselves largesse from the public treasury. From that moment on, the majority always votes for the candidates promising the most benefits from the public treasury with the result that a democracy always collapses over loose fiscal policy, always followed by a dictatorship. The average age of the world's greatest civilizations has been 200 yrs. Great nations rise & fall. The people go from bondage to spiritual truth, to great courage, from courage to liberty, from liberty to abundance, from abundance to selfishness, from selfishness to complacency, from complacency to apathy, from apathy to dependence, from dependence back again into bondage."
W.R.Buchanan: (August 12, 2010 9:21am)
Flamoneyman: So that means get rid of everyone right? Randy
W.R.Buchanan: (August 12, 2010 9:20am)
Flamoneyman: So that means get rid of everyone right? Randy
W.R.Buchanan: (August 12, 2010 9:17am)
The reason why there are so many short sales is because the banks are getting reimbursed for a significant portion of the loss. DUH. Why refi when you can make way more killing the market! I have a house down the street which has been in foreclosure for almost 2 years now. The bank lets the owners stay. The house was purchased for $1.289 mil. it has $1.160 on it. it just fell out of escrow for the umteenth time for $700K. The banks involved, B of A/Wells are not willing to to refi the porperty for $700K to the owners, but they are willing to sell it short for $700K? Gosh, maybe it's because the back side of the deal is, the Fed will give them $260K in bailout if they sell short, but nothing if they refi the owners. WTF? Boy,, that's some consumer beneficial program they got there! All of the people in control of this are so GD corrupt it makes me sick, I sayto all "Death by Bonga!!!" Randy
GODLIKE: (August 12, 2010 9:07am)
FLAMONEYMAN now you're sounding like a crusader. If you're voting based upon their voting record since almost every vote on the key issues were straight down the party lines then you must vote party this time. I'm with you in theory
Flamoneyman: (August 12, 2010 8:58am)
Here is the reality. If you are gonna vote for a candidate based on his/her party affilation, and "poo poo" any opposing party sponsored bills, YOU are also part of the problem. Get up and open your eyes people. We are witnessing the begining of a change in American politics from the 2 party system. I'm not promoting or dissuading any party including the Tea party. I'm just saying to fix the problem we need to get the people out of office who put their party affiation and personal campaign before their constituents desires. Think "what candidate will benefit me", not "What letter is behind their name." We can help fix the problem if WE are not stupid....just takes time.
frankgaray: (August 12, 2010 8:52am)
GODLIKE: (August 12, 2010 8:42am)
FLAMOMEYMAN you hit the nail on the head. We can talk all we want the odds of getting more than one person in Congress, especially now, to listen and be able to carry something thru that resembles how it began is absolutely NIL.
Flamoneyman: (August 12, 2010 8:37am)
I have read all the interesting and valid comments. All make good points. One problem still is the root of getting this mess repaired. The people in charge and making the rules have no good, practical, "feet in the trenches" experiance or knowledge of what they are looking at. They throw solutions at problem like a robber throwing a dog a slab of meat hopping it will go away. Until we get people in place who trully know what they are doing we are destined to sit back and laugh, cry, and pull our hair out. My best teacher at any level told me, "You can't sove a problem until you know what the problem is." These clowns are guessing!
dirk2290: (August 12, 2010 8:35am)
@ jthe drummer: Don't know what Market you are in, but for Phoenix, and most of the CA Market, if somehting is listyed for 100K, it is going for 105K. Even in the demographincally challenged areas it would at least go for list price of 100K. Not every where is like Topeka, Kansas
Rob in AZ: (August 12, 2010 8:34am)
jthed, That's a good point. I agree, one deal doesn't inflate from $100 to $150. But (again IMHO) the effects compound. SO this house is $101.5, the next one is $102.5, then $105, etc. We had cities here in AZ that quadrupled in 2 years (doubled in back-to-back years). So, I personally have seen it where people paid $8 for their $2 eggs. I think, yes, fraud was a factor in the run-up. But I also think the ability to get infinite leverage--by Investment Banks especially, but by buyers as well--was the single greatest contibuting factor. Thanks, Rob
dirk2290: (August 12, 2010 8:29am)
Hey guys, I have a a nice lengthy Word DOC I put together well over a year ago when HR 600 was in comment period that breaks down reasons/examples that I got "kudos" on from my colleagues. Would you like me to send it to you? Where do I send it.
jthedrummer: (August 12, 2010 8:17am)
Sorry Rob, I could see where DAPs are a problem with the level of inflation you suggesting but in reality the argument doesn't hold. A 50% increase in the price of eggs is no good and inflating a 100K home to 150K (same % as your egg example) to make the deal work would be awful. However every negotiates the price of a home. Properties listed for 100K and worth 100K usually sell for ~95K after negotiations. Why not allow more buyers into the market by keeping the price at 100K and offering DAP to complete with other buyers who intend to make a down-payment? I think there should be a limit on % allowed of contributions from a DAP to help prevent inflation but is that really a concern? I mean we have HVCC right, lol?
carloslsutter: (August 12, 2010 8:11am)
At this point in time, during this recesion, where RENT is higher than most PITI Mortgage payments, that would be ENOUGH incentive for most people to stick with the mortgage, not to mention future EQUITY build up. "Skin in the game" is second to a cheaper house payment elsewhere. Think about it. Turn it around. What if you had skin in the game in your residence, but rent outside was $500 cheaper for a house just like yours (and your equity, or your skin in the game, is eroding, or worse, negative-underwater, as it is happening now). Would you not care or see that any skin in the game is worthless or pointless, when there is a cheaper and better alternative? Why not make 100% loans instead to people whose PITI payment would be cheaper than rent for an equivalent house? We would be out of the Recesion in 1 year.
SGreek: (August 12, 2010 8:05am)
Agree completely with Crodent. With the underwriting standards now in place, the risk of default is so much lower. Demand needs to be created for housing in order to stabilize prices. Best way to do that in this economic environment is allow more QUALIFIED buyers to purchase a home at 100%. Most of them will be 1st time homebuyers...probably be wise to put some add'l DTI, credit score & reserve criteria in there. Responsible borrowers aren't going to walk away from a property unless values continue to plummet. But, even then, they'll be less inclined to do so if the payment is affordable to begin with. BTW, completely different tangent but, wouldn't HUD get a much greater needed cash infusion by increasing the upfront MIP &keeping the monthly MIP same or lowering it slightly? The pmt impact to the borrower would be so much less that way and the proverbial "win/win" is accomplished. Can we create our own new sovereign nation somewhere and have folks with common sense rule?? ;-)
GODLIKE: (August 12, 2010 8:00am)
DPA programs reek of scams and con artists. If we do 100% programs let's make them reward programs like VA. Make people earn the right to 100% financing by requiring them to have maintained a better than minimum credit score & show their ability to manage their money by showing savings of $X or X%. Then we'll get good buyers and only then will we have a 100% that performs. 100% isn't a RIGHT, it's a REWARD.
jthedrummer: (August 12, 2010 7:59am)
Or better yet, let's take an anecdotal approach. I have a borrower with a credit score in the high 600s, been on her job 15+ years, DTI is ~40%, good assets in a 401K, and ~$10,000 in savings. Wants to buy a ~200K house, BUT the home misses being in a USDA eligible location by ~1 mile. She did not want to deplete her savings with the 3.5% down required so she kept looking...didn't really like the homes that were USDA eligible, so she decided to sign a 6 month lease and save up more $$ for a down-payment...qualified buyer sits on the sidelines and one more home sits on the market...sure wish we could offer her DAP, but congress is much more concerned that she has 3 days to think-over a potential transaction if the APR improves 0.25%...unbelievable!
sansonj: (August 12, 2010 7:56am)
AZ does not have the $100 HUD DOWN, and nor do we have any USDA money as of yet. The is from NEGAMs/ I/O, and 40 years loans. 0 down 30 years fix rates PITI are not the issue.
Rob in AZ: (August 12, 2010 7:55am)
jthedrunner: I agree with your analysis that increased demand = higher prices. I am not sure my elementary understanding of economics allows me to think paying $3 for a dozen eggs is better than paying $2. We do not need to be propping up prices, which you are suggesting is the benefit of this program. As Frank says, IMHO. :-)
GODLIKE: (August 12, 2010 7:54am)
You've mentioned USDA loans as a performing 100% loan but don't expect that to continue. Like VA the USDA loans used to be for areas where financing was limited and therefore a borrower better not mess it up or he wouldn't get another. Now USDA is just another program that's out there. Yes, there are limited areas but there's also multiple other loan options. The borrower doesn't need to "preserve" their USDA eligibility. I too have a problem with the income limitations because they just dropped significantly for our area when median income rose. What's with that?
GODLIKE: (August 12, 2010 7:50am)
The $100 down HUD homes are homes that have already been offered up under other programs and they are either in too bad of a shape or in strange locations and they can't be sold any other way so they aren't germane to any discussion of DPA or 100% loans
Rob in AZ: (August 12, 2010 7:48am)
Frank: call a spade a spade on $100 down HUD homes, please. That is not to benefit the buyer. It is to benefit HUD by getting someone to take an REO asset off the books.
GODLIKE: (August 12, 2010 7:48am)
FYI I went thru my FHA training yesterday with Security National Mortgage now I'm eligible for their Broker sponsored FHA program. Any other lenders out there sponsoring brokers? One thing I did not understand. I have an active RE license, even tho I don't really use it anymore, and there was an active Realtor in the class who also does loans. How can they get by with that when FHA specifically says you can't have a RE, Ins, or securities license and do FHA loans. I'm willing and expecting to go inactive on my RE license.
Rob in AZ: (August 12, 2010 7:47am)
Thanks, Frank. You're right about 100% financing: it's Junk. Tax Credits are Junk. We shouldn't have done any of this. But DPAs have the additional added fun of being a "nod and a wink" at down payment requirements. Which sets up the borrower to think our whole business is a fraud: no wonder the public thinks we're a bunch of thieves--we come up with con jobs to sidestep our own rules. VA is the exception. BTW--if VA loans don't perform, I advocate changing their guidelines as well. For now, they do perform.
frankgaray: (August 12, 2010 7:46am)
Oh, and let's not forget that you can buy a HUD home with only $100 down. If $100 qualifies as skin in the game then fine, make the minimum down $100 for all FHA loans. But Uncle Sam gets to have it both ways. They can tell me that if a seller helps with my down it's bad, but if you buy MY home you only need $100 down? Bull. SDPA's were around long before sub-prime and there was no big SDPA scandal in the news. All they've done since the sub-prime bust is change where the money is coming from - Uncle Sam vs. Seller. We don't have to spend billions of dollars to move real estate - make wise adjustments to existing programs and save a ton of money.
jthedrummer: (August 12, 2010 7:40am)
Okay guys, I truly hope that the few posts I've read are from the 2-3 people who have a problem with DAPs and everyone else who watches TBWS understands the obvious benefits of allowing DAPs back into the FHA arena and therefore see no reason to comment further. (Or maybe it should just be a shout-out to Frank and Brian for clearly stating the obvious benefits of DAPs to where additional comments are not necessary.) Let's go through the benefits: DAPs would 1) cost the tax payers absolutely nothing, and 2) increase the potential pool of buyers and increase demand in today's market. An elementary understanding of economics shows that increased demand leads to increased prices which is exactly what the market needs. Sure, FHA guidelines were looser than USDA or VA but that's not the case now. Nearly every lender has adopted min credit scores, aggregate collection limits, etc. DAPs would only be beneficial to the market.
frankgaray: (August 12, 2010 7:39am)
Awesome discussion today! Here's my opinion - I'm calling bull on this. I'm a vet, and my service has no bearing on my attitude when it comes to "skin in the game" so - bull. There is NO difference if it's a government 100% financing deal or if there is seller assisted DP's, as long as we adjust the guidelines for a loan with SDPA. Come on. We give billions away in tax credits, which.. uh.. remove the "skin in the game" and now you're going to tell me that if I get my money from the seller vs. uncle Sam that I have some moral revelation and I'll do whatever I can to stay in my house? - Bull. Seller DPA can be made to work if we tweak the guidelines, and it would be no worse than other government 100%/credit programs! Again - IMHO. :)
Ray: (August 12, 2010 7:37am)
I agree with Ron in AZ except I will go a little further to say that Veterans are the only group of people who if they have only a 580 score and no down payment deserve to be able to qualify for a home.
GODLIKE: (August 12, 2010 7:36am)
Bottom line is DAP are giveaways. VA is earned. People don't appreciate giveaways. There actually is skin in the game with a VA. If they don't perform now they won't ever get to have another VA loan. The DAP carries no such downside. Plus DAP carries an inflated price. And then wasn't there the issues of fraud in the people administering the DAPs that finally did them in?
Rob in AZ: (August 12, 2010 7:26am)
Frank & Brian, please ENOUGH already with DPA. VA loans are not "no skin in the game" products. Veterans EARN that eligibility &--ask a Vet--will fight HARD to keep it. Their "skin in the game" is literally their skin (ever heard of a war zone?). Why is DPA worse than standard 100% financing? Because everybody knows it is a sham, a "paper" transaction. SO your borrower knows in his heart he used some shady loophole to get his house: how committed is he to paying back that mortgage to a complicit bank? The real deal is: we need to base lending decisions on the likelihood of repayment. Period. Anything else is political pandering. Respectfully, Rob.
Danielle: (August 12, 2010 7:26am)
So, if the majority of the posts say that we shouldn't encourage/continue the DPA's, then how are the results of the poll question showing 70% of those participating think that DPA's are NOT WORSE than RD and VA? Do the same people that don't want/like DPA's also not like/want RD and VA?
crodent: (August 12, 2010 7:07am)
Stop with the gimmicks already! Why for the love of God can't our government realize that gimmicks do not work long term. DPA in essence gives a buyer 100% & still no skin in the game right? So, why not go back to 100% loans with the tougher underwriting & let's all get back to selling houses. It doesn't take an unemployed rocket scientist to see that if we keep focusing on a buyer instead of both sides things will continue downward. Sellers who are underwater then asked to pay closing cost, possibly DPA then short sale & wreck their credit will not be a buyer for 2 years. Why not give both sides a fighting chance. Bring back 100% loans & stop already with the gimmicks. Even the sellers who break even still can't buy because they don't have down payment after helping a buyer. Who then helps them, the next seller? This is wrong, very very wrong. No one side should be given a benefit to the detriment of the other by our government. Win win for all parties.
Daggone: (August 12, 2010 7:01am)
I agree with all these posts! The real estate market is perfectly awful now, we really do need buyers with skin in the game or we run the risk of not ever getting out of this quicksand we are in. Sorry guys, we do. There was a good post about RHS and VA - they do have an important place as zero down programs.
GaryP: (August 12, 2010 6:42am)
OK, so one more thing. I'm willing tobet that Barney and the other powers that be will point out that there is plenty of money available for DPA through public agencies like state and local housing authorities and there is no need for "charity" based DPA programs like Nehemiah. Of course the actual degree to which these "charities" are charitable is a whole 'nother issue that will be brought up if HR-600 actually gets to the point where there is any serious debate on it. The IRS has already shut down several "charities" before the DPA ban by HUD went into effect. I just think that this discussion is just a lot of wishful thinking. I just don't see a lot of appetite for this kind of program in Congress or HUD. We almost got an increase in down payment on FHA as apart of the Financial Reform Bill. It was in one of the earlier amendments. There seemed to be support for increased "skin in the game." Decreasing skin in the game through DPA seems to run contrary to that mood.
GaryP: (August 12, 2010 6:33am)
One more thing. I said yesterday that HR-600 is a gift to builders. They would probably benefit the most from ths because they have the most flexibility in pricing. That was the case when we had DPA in the past too, at least in my market. From a policy perspective, would it even be a good idea to give builders the tools to increae new construction sale while we still have a huge inventory of homes on the secondary market? We have to work through this backlog before markets can begin to return to some degree of normalcy. On top of the existing inventory, we also have a new surge of foreclosures on the way that will eventually hit the market. If that wasn't enough, we also have what is called te "shadow inventory." Sellers waiting for the markets to turn around so that they can list their homes. I'll throw this out to the agents and appraisers out there and ask you, how do you think this is going to work out for values and the flexibility of sellers?
GaryP: (August 12, 2010 6:26am)
As I said in my post yesterday, I do feel that DPA (not DAP) does lead to value appreciation. At least it did in the past, especially with builders that were using their own appraisers. Obviously, this was easier to do with the appreciating market of years gone by. The question is whether that can occur in today's market with FHA "blind" appraisals and current UW guidelines. My sense is that these deals simply wouldn't get done, to any great extent, without the ability to inflate prices. Many sellers, unless extremely motivated, won't be willing to come off their price by that much. Many simply can't because that would leave them upside down unless they have a lot of equity. That scenario is bad enough right now, without throwing in the funds for DPA into the equation. Like I said earlier, an appreciating market was a pre-requisite for making DPA deals work. Even if markets are showing some rebound now, the past years of depreciation have taken their toll.
DavidC: (August 12, 2010 6:20am)
DAPs make it far too easy for a borrower to walk away from the house. They stand to lose nothing but credit scores. Even a gift they have to fear their family members. VA loans never had this 'pseudo-sub-prime' image to them as FHA loans do. I think there are far better ways to spark the market: fix HVCC, jumbo money, low CLTV seconds, less paperwork, and bring back Interest Only loans for example.
NJ Esq.: (August 12, 2010 6:11am)
"Egregious flip" – deemed risky does not equal fraud. I am an attorney in New Jersey and New York and I would love to come on your show and set you guys straight. Paying off the BPO Agent = Fraud. Offering the bank 80% of the BPO, buying the property and reselling it for a profit is not. The assumption that any party is financially damaged is reliant upon a bunch of other very shaky assumptions. You guys have my office phone number, I would be glad to do a phone interview and educate your viewers.
Danielle: (August 12, 2010 5:04am)
The problem with DAP, in my opinion, has always been that it circumvents the intended borrower contribution of the program of the loan. In RD, yes, it is 100%, but the Guarantee Fee and credit requirements are both higher than FHA and the money is earmarked for a certain portion of the population that is buying in a less populated community. (Don't get me started on the income limit, because that I do have a problem with.) VA, same thing, it has its own requirements (hoops) that the borrower must jump through to get it. FHA requires more money down, BUT it's guidelines are much looser and its min FICO's are much lower. So, if you undermine the down payment required by FHA by laundering the equity from the seller as a 'grant', then you weaken the stop gap of the down payment requirement for someone with a weaker score. Just call it what it is, it's a seller concession. Put your cards on the table and play the game by the rules. Removing the contribution of the buyer will get more F/C's.
Mortgagerock: (August 12, 2010 4:28am)
I never encouraged the DAP loans in the past. The main difference in buyers using DAP vs VA & USDA programs is integrity. I saw more fraud being committed using the the DAP programs than VA or USDA programs. However, if you start requiring borrowers using the DAP program to start requiring them to participate in NFP homeowner training programs. (i.e. Nehemiah) Then, it may be worthwhile.
1st in Michigan: (August 12, 2010 4:25am)
In my years of RE sales, I've put together many SABP deals. Experience shows that the seller gets the attitude of "If I'm giving them a down payment, I want the most I can get too". More so than with 3-6% seller concessions, the seller trys to negotiate a higher net, and then we're inflating values and in this market not appraising. I say no seller assisted down Pmt, cut FHA to 3% concessions with the 3.5% buyer's down pmt, and leave VA alone. (Yes, I'm a Vet!)