Government Stated Refi the Answer? 10.14.10
Today's Poll: Would you support H.R. 6218?
Yes
No
Rate this Program
rita: (October 16, 2010 12:02am)
If it's like the MHA (Making Homes Affordable) program, it will not benefit the independewnt loan officers who are with brokers or correspondent lenders. The banks will have their in-house people who are probably underpaid and overworked as it is doing these loans for existing customers. We won't get to help these people is my guess. What do you think?
elaineb: (October 15, 2010 11:58am)
Something is Rotten is going on. Did you know in April 2011, the OTS, OCC, FED, HUD, FDIC, FTC and NCUA are all going to be comingled into a new "Bureau of Consumer Financial Protection". All this chaos is schemed to cause a preemtive strike by Obama admin and take over what is left of our housing industry. Watch as they make MERS a government agency! The electronic market will being forced upon us. All the lenders are ONE. Notice how Countrywide was called "AMERICAS Wholesale Choice" Funny how Bank of AMERICA took them over! There are NO lenders. They are all broke. The FDIC is currently running the show behind the scenes. Onewest maintains "Indymac Mortgage Services, a division of Onewest Bank". Quit crying about your paychecks that are shrinking. They got us used to "easy money-toxic loan products", made us loan junkies so that we would want it always. There is so much more going on. We are victims of the boiling frog syndrome.
Fl Mortg Lady : (October 15, 2010 11:12am)
G2Realtor: BINGO!!! Nonni and PayProse: real scenarios, good people, often with equity they may never see again. The number of those in this position in Florida is epidemic. The ultimate solution take by many here is to short sell, which destroys mortgage buying credit for min. of 2 yrs.
G2Realtor: (October 15, 2010 10:48am)
rayprose: It is our belief that not until three major pressures are taken out of the equation, will the US economy truly begin to make a meaningful recovery. Those three major pressures are, job creations, meaningful foreclosure prevention and finally a mechanism to repair and address the extraordinary negative equity in residential real estate. According to PR News Wire http://www.prnewswire.com/ SEATTLE, Aug. 9, real estate values continue to fall, reporting that nationally, home owners are suffering with an average of 21% value decline, since the beginning of the economic crisis we are digging out of. The hardest hit areas report more dramatic negative equity conditions. Areas such as Bakersfield CA at 44.6% negative equity, El Centro CA at 57.5% negative equity, Fresno CA at 38.5% negative equity, Sacramento CA at 58.1% negative equity, Las Vegas NV @ 73.9% negative equity, Reno NV at 61.9% negative equity. Who's fault is this, the homeowners? I think not!
rayprose: (October 15, 2010 10:25am)
G2Realtor How about this scenario: My customer built their house in 2005. Equity position when financed was 31% or $201,000 equity in a $650,000 property, $450,000 note and Mortgage. Part of value of the property was 10 acres valued than at $450,000 House value $200,000. House and acreage value now in 2010 $219,000 chance of breaking even on property in the next 10 years, ZERO. Do they ask the bank to write down their loan from $450,000 to $219,000 (they probably won't do that) or mail in the keys and start over, or try to short sell the property and have a $231,000 short sales debt hanging over their heads. And.....who's fault is it that they are in this position. Some righteous individuals that read this will say they should not have over extended themselves like that. However, THEY HAD A 30%+ EQUITY POSITION TO START, they weren't highly leveraged! What do you tell these homeowners to do??? How is this situation their fault in any manner??? Even conservative investors are falling!
G2Realtor: (October 15, 2010 9:14am)
nonni: What do you think? Example: Purchased home for $300,000 with 30% down & financed $210,000 @ 6.5% - Current PI is $1,327 Three scenarios: Refi at current balance of $196,844 at today's rate of 4.6% = PI of $997 Equity Recovery Time: not counting inflationary spirals which will occur, is just under a decade. Refi at current value of $150,000 at current rate of 6.5% = PI of $948 Equity Recovery Time: NONE unless the bottom falls out of the real estate market again! Refi at current value of $150,000 at today's rates of 4.5% = PI of $760 Equity Recovery Time: NONE unless the bottom falls out of the real estate market again! So, which plan seems the most fair to all mortgage holders in America. Those folks, just like you and me who played by all the rules, have done nothing wrong and yet who are, at the moment, stuck in their homes for decades? Your thoughs?
nonni: (October 15, 2010 8:27am)
I'm not asking for an exit strategy. I'm simply asking to be allowed to refinance my full loan amount at the current interest rates, but since my loan amount is about 35% above the value of my house (even though I put down 30% downpayment when I bought my house), I cannot take part in the current historic low interest rates. That seems like a crime. The only alternative I have is to walk away from my house (not saying I would). I would rather stay in my house for the next 20 years and enjoy 4.5% interest rather than my current 6.5% interest. This type of situation is going to force more and more homeowners to walk away.
G2Realtor: (October 15, 2010 8:16am)
nonni: Currently, there is NO exit strategy available to any homeowner who is suffering with negative equity. In over ½ the country, homeowners who are suffering with negative equity have no way to sell their home in the next 10 to 20 years. Does the current congress and administration truly feel that it is appropriate to allow this financial injustice to be suffered upon homeowners who have played by the rules? Is it appropriate that the economic meltdown, caused primarily by the failure of the sub-prime mortgage industry, law makers and major players on Wall Street, should strap a homeowner to his home for the next decade, two decades or in some areas of the country as much as three decades? Does it seem JUST to you that homeowners, who have done nothing wrong, played by all the rules, acted responsible with their finances, should NOT be provided a mechanism to exit their home without being required to write a check to their lien holder to cover the negative equity?
nonni: (October 15, 2010 8:09am)
If I understand this bill correctly, this is exactly what I've been saying for two years should happen. Take me for example...I bought my house in 2006 during the peak of the market at 6.5% interest on my mortgage. I put 30% down on my house, but my home value dropped by 50% so I am still underwater by 20% more than my original downpayment. I can make my payment, but hate making this huge payment on a house that is worth half of what I paid for it. I don't want anyone to reduce my debt! I simply want to refinance my current mortgage at today's rates which are under 5%. That would make a huge difference in my monthly mortgage payment. It would make it possible for me to justify staying in my house. And it would give me more spending money to spend on other things and help with the economy. It would also reduce my interest deduction on my tax return and thus cause me to pay more taxes which would help the government deficit. When will someone hear me??
rayprose: (October 15, 2010 7:15am)
I like what CindyH has to say, but realistically, there will be no criminals prosecuted from the banking industry because there was no wrong doing by those in authority in banking. It was just all those greedy Mortgage Brokers, those greedy Developers and those greedy Realtors. Several of them have had their lives turned upside down and have been prosecuted but not a single one has been brought to task from the banking industry......GET THE MESSAGE??? When the Masters change the rules the serfs and plebeians have no say in the game. If you haven't felt like a serf or plebeian before welcome to the NEW game. They HAVE to find fault with some one so welcome to ground zero. YES, thats right they WILL be looking into YOUR FINANCES and looking into YOUR RECORDS to find that transaction that you slid sideways on! And when they find it, if you are a juicy enough target THEY WILL PROSECUTE YOU! Unless of course if you work directly for a bank. In that case you have done nothing wrong!
Mike8307: (October 15, 2010 7:06am)
FL MortgLady -- The mods being done are being written down against current working capital of the bank. Which is why it is a slow process. It isn't something that can be done en-mass across the board. The problem is many fold. The gov't has taught the public not to make big purchases without gov't subsidies. Cash for clunkers, subsidies for energy efficient appliances, $7500 15 yr loan for home buyers, then the straight $8000 home buyer credit. After the end of each program everyone is surprised to see a big drop in each activity. People are on the sidelines waiting for the next "big fix" from Uncle Sam. The gov't needs to once and for all get out of the way and let the market do what it must. There will be pain. But the pain will be much shorter lived than it would be with all kinds of government "fixes" that never fix anything. FDRs programs didn't solve the Great Depression, it exasperated it. Europe recovered years earlier.
Fl Mortg Lady : (October 15, 2010 5:15am)
Mike 8307: Banks are ALREADY doing these refis in Florida. Don't know how they are selling on secondary, but I presume it is to keep their good paying portfolio of clients. No, LO's do not get paid on these refis originated by servicers. BUT, it is calming the angry homeowners that are mad that banks are helping short sellers and not them. Jobs are a major part of the puzzle, that's a given. And, we can wait until our industry hits bottom, which looks to be 2-5 years. Can we wait until then to get back to business? I can't. We need to be actively involved in a solution.
Broker in RIC: (October 15, 2010 4:48am)
GZ Realtor: good points, and I agree with almost everything that you say (except I believe that law makers were not asleep at the switch, but rather were the ones actively flipping the switch). I believe that the free market is always the best solution. and to the people who don't understand what I mean by free market (and argue that the free market is what got us into this problem) let's not forget just how much government intervention has been injected in the "free market". subprime loans were born out of government intervention (they said that more people should own homes and then artificially manipulated the homeownership rate with their policies). more government intervention is NOT the answer. time and market shift (back to where it should have been the whole time) will fix this huge problem that we have created. we need to get back to common sense... not further intervention that defies logic. negative equity relief. does that sound logical or like another hail mary?
G2Realtor: (October 14, 2010 10:00pm)
Broker in RIC: Our country did not make this mess all by itself. "Our Country" had help from law makers how were asleep at the switch and who fashioned and then allowed goofy loan policies to play out in "Our Country". Congress, Wall Street, The Mortgage Industry and the Real Estate industry created this mess. We allowed the consumer to believe that the loans they took out would "be ok". I can't blame today’s consumers with this debacle. They played by the rules. The sub-prime mess caused this disaster and they are all gone. The fat cats have all headed out of town with their pockets stuffed to the gill. Today's consumer is left holding the bag. We need meaningful negative equity relief. That is the best fix to this mess.
cindyh: (October 14, 2010 9:52pm)
Regarding your Feb 2009 video and it's staggering implications/and current headline news:shocking claims of fraudulent&criminal foreclosure loan practices against BoA..I have to wonder:Are there any powerful consumer "watch dog" group(s)public/private,that are looking at this? Lawsuits must be mounting,how many? Aqainst who? Title insurers? Is there a case for that?? Owner's title holders suing lender's title holders...but its the same insurance company?? I expect title insurance companies will be the next casuality of the financial greed wars? MORE taxpayer $$ for their survival next? What a bottomless pit!! I think its time for the Obama admin to make good on its #1 and ONLY important campaign promise, which was to produce jobs!And here's what I propose: Jobs, lots of jobs! for people to restore and convert gov't-owned commercial property into WHITE.COLLAR.PRISONS!!No Billion $$ Bailouts! Billion $$ Bail Postings from thous'nds of Billionaire Criminals. Depression Solved. JOBS!
Broker in RIC: (October 14, 2010 7:58pm)
HR6218 is a HORRIBLE idea. why do we continue to try to find a "quick fix"? we need to get back to conservative, common sense lending. more money down and more solid buyer profiles. others can rent. this is the only solution. it may not be quick, but it will be stable and we can rebuild upon it. anything else is a band-aid. we need to face facts... it's going to be a tough economy for years to come... but we (our country) made this bed and now we must sleep in it.
5pence: (October 14, 2010 5:18pm)
Grace is better than luck and that will be the next judgement
5pence: (October 14, 2010 5:16pm)
My intellect never cuts any corners when it comes to the public trust.
Chuck@HRC: (October 14, 2010 5:06pm)
Elaineb: You are absolutely correct about the servicing agreement. Some relatively proactive servicers tried to amend their agreements to allow consideration of modification requests and here shot-down. The deal struck by the FDIC with OneWest couldn't have been better negotiated to pass all of IndyMac's losses on to taxpayers. Let me recall, didn't the "run" on IndyMac start with a letter leaked by Sen. Schumer (D-NY)?
elaineb: (October 14, 2010 4:46pm)
Read a pooling and servicing agmt. It states loan servicers cannot modify a loan. Why invest in a trust if the notes could be modified? PLUS, the Shared Loss Agreements the FDIC made with new banks that bought servicing rights to BK'd or seized lenders toxic loans make it in their best interest to foreclose-- they make way more money foreclosing, than if they modify. They only modify if they can get money from HAMP in doing it. Mike Dell and George Soros (Onewest investors) are getting fat while American homeowners die on the vine. Onewest Bank posted a 1.6 Billion profit in first 9 months of business. Why? It sure wasn't from bank fees and credit card business. The FDIC made a Shared Loss Agreement with them. Although the FDIC denies any part of the fraud, when I asked them why they assigned my Indymac mtg to Onewest 1 yr after the Indymac/asset sale to Onewest was final-FDIC said it was done to show there was NO FDIC Interest in the mtg. Ponder that one..........
ATLMTGMAN: (October 14, 2010 4:30pm)
What possible incentive would any lender have to lower the interest rate for any of their customers that are "boxed in"?. Logically speaking, the borrower is paying on time and has either lost their job or is under water and cannot refinance. So for the lenders to agree to this would amount to charity on their part and I have yet to see a charitable bank. The fed may pass this, but not without subsidizing the banks, or just to look good to the average voter that has no clue that it is not realistic with costing the taxpayer, much like the other "programs" this administration has put forth.
James H: (October 14, 2010 3:30pm)
Hi Yvonne, I'm a RE broker that has been on the front lines with this mess from day one. I have many clients who have equity, 750 FICO, never been late and cannot refinance out of their adjustable loan. Why? They own a business where they wright off most of their expenses. They did not use their home like a credit card. They are responsible people. When they requested a loan mod from their lender/bank after their payments went up over a $1,000 a month. The lender/bank sent them a letter saying. The invertor has review your request and has determined it is not in their best interest to help you. The home owner wiped out their 401k, savings, cut all spending to keep up with their payments. When the interest rates went down this gave relief to these owners. So there is still a major problem that has yet to be really addressed. If this problem is left uncorrected it could collapse what's left of our economy. The number of people on these kind of loans are in the millions.
elaineb: (October 14, 2010 3:28pm)
Why not give EVERYONE a 2% interest rate, 30 yr fixed (or whatever amortization they have left) mortgage--for new homeowners and delinquent ones and current ones. Use the current appraised value averaged with assessed value as value. Deduct 10% from that value and reduce principal to that for underwater victims. We all deserve a little equity. It's the Banksters and their Ponzi securitization scheme that has caused all our values to tank. Make them pay back the bonuses and incentives they took during the last 10 years.
Clulessdad: (October 14, 2010 3:24pm)
OH OH! This is a rumor, but GMAC may be pulling out of lending at the moment, because of this foreclosure mess. If they don't have the ability to foreclose, then why lend? Anyone else hear anything? This could bring everything to a halt.
G2Realtor: (October 14, 2010 3:16pm)
kafprocessing, Yvonne and Modification Specialist, a refi of an underwater mortgage is of little use to anyone. We also need meaningful assistance for homeowners who are stuck in mortgages that are buried in negative equity. Please take a look at the video BLOG I have published at http://tinyurl.com/27no296. A copy of the substantive text can also be found at http://tinyurl.com/39ex9x6. The “Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act” does NOTHING to address the millions of homeowners who are suffering with EXTREME negative equity of their homes. A meaningful and useful solution to the negative equity in residential real estate is one major component that the administration and the treasure refuses to address. To add fuel to this fire, is it not interesting that the latest “hot dog” bill from Barney Frank and Chris Dodd (Dodd-Frank Act) specifically signals out and distances itself from helping folks in the hardest hit areas of the country.
Yvonne: (October 14, 2010 3:00pm)
JamesH, Sorry never read your comment. I understand what you are saying. My oppinion is for ALL performing loans adjustable or otherwise. If they are payment worthy give them a 30 year fixed loan at the lower amount. I agree with you it will find a bottom to a bottomless market. And these people will be the catalyst to start the economy again. If they cannot prove income/credit though it's just another bandaid to a never ending problem.
Modification Specialist: (October 14, 2010 2:54pm)
Your program is not going to work... Your example is like a seesaw, weighted too much in your direction. You need to understand how banks make their money. The mortgage industry is the Bellwether to our economy. Banks make money with mortgages after they are pooled with other similar loans, noting each MBS pool is rated from a ratings agency (S&P, Moodys,...) They also make money through CMO's and MMB's. Do you recall the mortgage collapse of 2007 - it started when Fannie and Freddy brought CCC rated pools and sold it as AAA. When homeowners missed payments caused fluctuation in payments to investors. The investors started selling their shares which ultimately caused the collapse of Wall Street. What you are purposing is going take to away the way loans are rated and how big money is made. The Government is not going to let that happen.
kafprocessing: (October 14, 2010 2:52pm)
There's just no way they would approve this. Here in Florida values are down 50% for SFR and 75% for condos. The loss to the lenders would be in the TRILLIONS.
SteveH: (October 14, 2010 2:49pm)
Hey boys. I'm the old fat guy who bought you drinks at CAR last tuesday....worth every penny. Cardoza may have the beginnings (it needs tweeking) of something good, a way to help strapped borrowers modify a jumbo loan in a non jumbo neighborhood! (that would be someone like me) Lots of people out there with good equity in a non Freddy/Fanny high loan balance area who could use a piece of relief.
James H: (October 14, 2010 2:46pm)
Hi Yvonne, please read my whole post. The folks I'm speaking about are the PERFORMING loans! These folks are small business owners who have never been late on their payments, are current on their payments and still have good FICO. What you don't understand is these people cannot refinance out of their adjustable loan into a fixed loan. So as soon as the interest rates go up these people will also start default. These people are the major engine of our economy. We lose them, game over for everyone except the supper rich.
leilasellhouses: (October 14, 2010 2:37pm)
H.R 6218 will help the economy because the occupant pays for taxes and we do not have to make up the defficiency.
cgappraisals: (October 14, 2010 2:32pm)
Californian's, if its Brown flush it down! We need Business's to come back to Ca. Unions and regulations have destroyed this beautiful state.
Yvonne: (October 14, 2010 2:28pm)
So of all the people mentions in the fight...you forgot the one's really paying for it...The PERFORMING loans. All of these salvation ideas are for the non-performing loans that shouldn't exist to start. Why hasn't anyone said hmmm... lets take the performing loans that qualify with credit and income worthiness and give them a straight across the board 3.5-4% refi with no appraisal required. Then watch how jobs start getting created and consumer money gets put back into the system the correct way. Let the rest who aren't making payments strategically or otherwise become renters again and learn how to budget their money. The American Dream was never defined as "you are owed it"! You have to EARN it!
rsteenrod: (October 14, 2010 12:56pm)
I think the bill is a good way to take some of the steam out of the foreclosure wave. Too many people can't refi because of reduced income, or reduced proeprty value. Lowering payments will allow more people to keep it together. They should also bring back the FHA Streamline w/o appraisal
G2Realtor: (October 14, 2010 12:56pm)
If you review the list of eligible states, you will not see, CA, NV, FL, AZ or MI, five of the most heavily devastated areas of the country, where homeowners are suffering with record depreciated home values and negative equity. However you do see Massachusetts and Connecticut in the list. Keep in mind that Massachusetts is one of the states beset with certain areas that have suffered with negative equity figures near that of CA, NV, FL, AZ and MI. Areas such as Worchester Ma where negative equity hovers just over 20%. Compare the list of states suffering with NEGATIVE EQUITY http://tinyurl.com/2exzzl8 to the list of states slated to received foreclosure mortgage assistance in the (Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act) http://tinyurl.com/24ygb7x .
G2Realtor: (October 14, 2010 12:55pm)
We also need meaningful assistance for homeowners who are stuck in mortgages that are buried in negative equity. Please take a look at the video BLOG I have published at http://tinyurl.com/27no296. A copy of the substantive text can also be found at http://tinyurl.com/39ex9x6. Additionally, the “Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act” does NOTHING to address the millions of homeowners who are suffering with EXTREME negative equity of their homes. To that point it is our belief that a meaningful and useful solution to the negative equity in residential real estate is one major component that the administration and the treasure refuses to address. To add fuel to this fire, is it not interesting that the latest “hot dog” bill from Barney Frank and Chris Dodd (Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act) specifically signals out and distances itself from helping folks in the hardest hit areas of the country.
James H: (October 14, 2010 11:51am)
About the government program. Here is something everyone has to consider! There are millions of people whom have well over 750 Fico score that cannot get refinance (business owners). They are all in an interest only loan that has reset. The only thing keeping these people in their property is the fact their interest rate is currently at 3 to 3.5%. They can afford the new payment currently however, once interest rates go up so do their payments. Their payments will reach a point where they cannot afford to make the newly adjusted payment and we are sent into another major tail spin. Most of these people income has been cut in half due to the economy and most likely will not see any increases with their income for a long time. So, if this problem is not addressed we will have another crash in the market once we see interest rates go up. The government advisors are fully aware of this hidden problem and are trying to come up with a way to solve it.
Chuck@HRC: (October 14, 2010 11:50am)
Daggone: Yes, you're reading this correctly! You can thank Sen. Feinstein (D-CA) for inserting this into FinReg in the eleventh-an-half hour when this part was being "negotiated" in conference committee. Everyone should find and listen carefully to the interview of the CEO at TGF Financial talking about the legal theories of his company's lawsuit against the Fed for their discriminatory regulations(interchange fee limitations). If a court of competent jurisidiction agrees, there's hope ALL the broker fee limitations set in FinReg could be deemed unconstitutional (on the same theories). Understand, LO compensation will be everything from the borrower OR nothing from the borrower... no blend to reduce closing costs or improve a borrower's rate. Isn't one-size-fits-all just a wonderful thing? This is also already adversely affecting bank LO compensation (just look at the rats fleeing the sinking ships around the country).
andystills: (October 14, 2010 11:47am)
It probably goes without saying, HR 6218 needs some work. Qualified mortgages must be held for primary residences. Although seemingly good, this sets up investors as the fall guys (read: next round of foreclosures) because falling property values stifle any selling option, this program gives home owners a competitive advantage by allowing for lower payments thus creating easier qualification, lower rental rates, and the possibility of a future move into a bigger house at a lower price. This should be available to everyone if it moves forward. Also, not sure brokers will be able to participate due to the types of incentives being offered.
Alabama Country Boy: (October 14, 2010 11:41am)
Ever wonder how the bankster folks make those "stupd" decisions. Well, they don't, at least not now. They make the decisions that are in their (the bank's) best interest. They do not care who picks up the tab. All decisions that may look stupid from the outside looking in are done to be in the bank's interest. Tax considerations, pass through loss to the Fed Reserve, cleaning up the books of problem classed assets, etc. are all considerations that those of us on the outside know nothing of. These folks that are still working for the bank better understand the CMA principles for themselves and their employer.
Traveler2: (October 14, 2010 11:37am)
76% thinks this is good? 76% did not read the bill
elaineb: (October 14, 2010 11:36am)
JPMorgan Chase just stopped using MERS. The big Wall Street/Fed Ponzi game is dirtier than Madoff and Lehman Bro. Hopefully it won't take down America. WAKE UP. It's not just a paperwork snafu. How can "loan servicer" foreclose when they are not legally in title to the note and deed--By making a false assignment! If the promissory note must (per SEC offering documents) be assigned to the trust w/in 90 days- then the trust should be foreclosing. If the note was paid in full by AIG the trust doesn't care anymore, they are whole. The FDIC sold the toxic assets of failed thrifts for pennies on the $1 to servicers and agreed to Share Losses if the loan went sour. But the servicer has to figure out a way to get "title" to the house to show loss. They have to forge assignments and recreate notes (use MERS)to foreclose. Would you pick and sell poisonous fruit just to make money? Get mad as hell that Banksters & Feds poisoned our crops and attempted to make us look like the crooks. (HVCC
anders02: (October 14, 2010 11:30am)
http://www.change.org/petitions/view/usa_national_foreclosure_moratorium_now# That is a link to sign a petition. Once signed it automatically sends a letter (as seen in the petition) to the local congressman and reps. Just thought I would share.
Daggone: (October 14, 2010 11:25am)
Whole new discussion - rec'd an email from a lender this week stating major changes in compensation coming April 2011. "the amount of compensation will be a pre determined set amount for all loans agreed to by lender and broker". It goes on to say my earning power is not regulated, only the comp practice that varies by loan. WHAT? These guys writing the rules have to be certifiable. Does that mean we don't need rate sheets anymore. Is there just one rate for everyone? Will the lenders just offer brokers a flat fee no matter what the loan size? At the moment this is boggling my mind.
Ikandi: (October 14, 2010 11:18am)
Analyst 1, forgive me I should of said it was PART of the problem, obviously not the only problem, just the one that directly affects the loan industry & what is similar to what is being repeated now to be PART of what is causing a similar outcome was the point...History is repeating itself, was the main point. Maybe not exactly, but too close for comfort obviously.
elaineb: (October 14, 2010 11:11am)
It seems like all you are concerned about is how not to loose your LO income! Securitization is illegal. All the mortgage loans you originate are being securitized. The promissory notes must be assigned into the trust (SPE) w/in 90 days of purchase, in order to be legal and take tax credits as an investor. ALL those trusts created over the last 10 years did not have the notes legally assigned within the 90 day time limit. The $175 billion AIG TARP funding was due to AIG paying out $175 billion to investors who put in claims of loses from toxic loans--yet their trust was illegal--the notes were never assigned. The entire securitization mortgage game is illegal. Hasn't anyone watched the Brooksley Born video "The Warning" published by Frontline where she attempted to warn congress 10 years ago? Every single American should stop making their securitized mortgage payment in solidarity against this fraud. If you are victim of fraud, you are not legally bound to repay.
Ikandi: (October 14, 2010 11:02am)
"The People" of America seem to sooner trust banks vs LO now, to do their loans - probably as a rule...I would love to see statics on that. Point being, that "The People" keep wanting to go back to the department of our government (banks) that pushed product that was bad for the people (Subprime, Alt-A, etc.) & have them solve the problem they created. Isn't that letting the fox guard the hen house??? Many will never learn. Some will become their own banks doing cash & carry, & hiding their $ &/or appreciating precious metals in a hole somewhere. The savvy ones have had it! They know what is happening. The banks are just trying to generate fees again & this time they don't care if they add to loan brokers to the joblessness that is rampant to try & save their own butts! Human screwing over their fellow Human again. So what if the economy gets worse, THEY will survive! Socialism taking advantage of the ignorance - have a drink of Kool-aid! Vote out incumbents in November folks!
Lincky: (October 14, 2010 11:02am)
Just wanted to say my refund from Follow My Clients and Marketing Animals has been resolved. Thank You.
Analyst 1: (October 14, 2010 10:30am)
Ikandi, I'm not sure where you have been getting your misinformation but I would suggest a better reading list. Smoot-Hawley tariff actions are universely accepted as the precipitating cause of The Depression. Mortgage lending was far more conservative in the 1920's than anything we have seen in the last 60 years. The lending to which you refer is associated with stock market speculation with very small margin requirements. When the tariffs caused a near shut down in trade the resulting plunge in equity markets wiped out paper fortunes and caused a bank run. Mortgage practices were never part of the problem.
Chuck@HRC: (October 14, 2010 10:24am)
Gsuarez1: You're on point... this is why HARP has been so ineffective. Understanding that servicers earn 25-44bps in fee on every loan in servicing, why would a servicer, considering that they're also banks, self-impair their servicing book? For those unaware, FASB rules would require these banks to take charges against both the value of their affected assets and their servicing (the capitalized cashflow value is held on their balance sheets as another asset class) triggering another round of capital-raises. Have you wondered why most wholesale lenders offer the Fannie DU Refi Plus but not the Freddie Home Affordable Refi? Simple: Freddie has 2 pricing schemes- Open Access, supposedly "open" to brokers, requires a fee to Freddie 3 times the fee compared to the Servicer Originated variation. As long as the city-center banks continue to dictate the mechanics of these programs, no one other than those banks will see any benefit... not the homeowner and, cetrtainly, not brokers.
Ikandi: (October 14, 2010 10:05am)
STATED, STATED, STATED - I think everyone should study the roaring 20's loan practices which brought on the Great Depression of the 30's, before anything else is done. What you will see is that a shoe shine boy could get a loan...shocking! That is the same practice that is bringing about this fiasco Greater Depression mess!!! Now this new bill will exclude jobs other than banking jobs from doing loans - so more joblessness. That is a real solution...Please stop treating everyone like they are stupid & only the Bank Mafia is smart! It will make a few happy for awhile, while America will continue to fail financially with no $ to function forward - wonderful! Maybe a solution lies in offering Purchases at an irresistible low to get the $ hoarders to divvy up & contribute to the property tax base, so we can continue to have teachers, school, firemen, roads, etc. - before we are driving on cobblestone & everything burns down, & stop trying to exclude LO jobs on top of the joblessness now!
sansonj: (October 14, 2010 9:58am)
Anything like this will cause class act lawsuits to come from the people who did not get the hook up- Mers to mount. People would say give me back my home and refi me too since you illegally took it.
gsuarez1: (October 14, 2010 9:57am)
Folks you all need to read the bill well. It would NOT put many people back to work because, as it's written, it clearly allows only the servicer to do the refi. Furthermore the servicer is prohibited from charging any fee, but the GSE would pay them a flat $1k per deal. Someone else may have mentioned this (sorry no time to read thru 80+ comments) but with a few changes, this bill really could make some sense and go a long way to fixing our industry. Look for more on this...
Chuck@HRC: (October 14, 2010 9:55am)
SoldInOregon: You're partially correct that the city-center banks only wholely-own a small portion of their books however, as part of the securitization process, these same banks "sold" their rights and replaced them with Rep's & Warranties. It doesn't appear to have ever been contemplated that the servicer would need to take an action not authorized in its servicing agreement. How on earth is a servicer to acquire ANY further authority from the pool's participants? There could be hundreds or thousands of participatory-shares outstanding in any single pool. Some of these shares have conflicting interests in the same pool. If the servicer's authority doesn't already exist, there isn't much of a chance a servicer to actually obtain it.
ConsultingFTW: (October 14, 2010 9:37am)
People paying their mortgage don't need a bailout! Let's give them a hand up by providing 100+ LTV Loans ONLY TO 720 FICO CLIENTS. We should have let these banks burn in the ashes of free market capitalism and I think the consumers, including myself, should be held accountable for their choices. People in this country need to grow a backbone and stand up for themselves. Our nation never would have been founded if we had the culture of playing the victim like we do today.
Maui Madness: (October 14, 2010 9:35am)
The Cardoza Bill may be our only hope....
arunarya: (October 14, 2010 9:32am)
I agree with the Govt. doing stated income refis. We all need this.
tz hawg: (October 14, 2010 9:30am)
The concept is a good idea and a way to benefit the people who did things right. The problem is that it might only hide the problem. What happens when the homeowners who benefit from this go to sell their homes and are still underwater. Unless there is some sort of program that will include principal reduction, it is only delaying the inevitable. I suggest that current lien holders allow principal reduction with perhaps taking a junior lien position on the new loan. That way they have the opportunity to recover some of their loss. There has to be a caveat on these that junior lien holder will waive their lien upon a sale based on certain factors. One of the factors I believe that should determine how much the junior lien holder can recover is the amount of their loss compared to the homeowners. In other words, if the homeowner put 30% down and the bank is out 10% because then LTV is 60% of the original price, I think the homeowner who did right should not have to suffer as much.
SoldinOregon: (October 14, 2010 9:30am)
Let's not forget that the loans were sold via Wall Street to investors. These investors have the final say on the loans and tell the service companies what they can and can't do with the loans. Perfect Example: Bank of America which Services 1 in 3 loans in the USA only owns 10% of their mortgages, the rest are owned by investors. I do think refinancing to market rate should be allowed, regardless of equity homeowners may decide to ride out the equity losses given they have a great interest rate. The problem then becomes one of instant reductions on pretty much all mortgage backed securities now held in portfolios. My guess is the losses they are taking now are more appealing than an across the board interest rate cut that hits their portfolios even harder than short sales and foreclosures. I prefer the rate cuts over foreclosure and short sale but number crunchers somewhere must not agree.
Realist 1: (October 14, 2010 9:29am)
I strongly encourage everyone to watch this video that fully explains the foreclosure fraud situation. We have true lawlessness in our country right now Are you sitting down? http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AqnHLDeedVg
newbie52: (October 14, 2010 9:29am)
It seems the answer is to have the lenders convince the investors that it would be in their best interest to allow principle reductions rather than interest reduction. That would eliminate the majority of the foreclosure activity I would think and the strategic defaults. Obviously lenders are not interested or incapable of doing this.
W.R.Buchanan: (October 14, 2010 9:23am)
This bill is the first thing I have seen during this mortgage mess, THAT WE HAVE ALREADY BEEN PAYING THRU THE ARSE FOR ANYWAY, That might actually help me out. The mantra seems to be "oh the taxpayer will get stuck again and our kids,,," Well,guess what?, We already got stuck!!!! With this, we might get some tangable personal benefit. The difference with this program is that the only ones not reaping the benefits will be the banks, or so it seems at this point. This is the first proposed deal that has come down the line that might help the little guy, and not end up being another windfall for the banksters. I say bring it on, and I am going to demand that my Republican Congressman vote in favor of this bill. I'll tell you what, refiing my $700K stated income loan to 4?% would save me a bunch of money, and the only back side is the bank won't get as much interest. And if the fed pays their loss, so what? THEY ALREADY ARE!!! Don't you think it's about time we got something back
Evil Genius: (October 14, 2010 9:21am)
@ Chuck@HRC Texas (4 words) No Cash Out Refi's
lrenteria: (October 14, 2010 9:21am)
LMAO!!! What happened to Short-Refi? LMOA!!!
Nuke 'em Until They Glow and Shoot them In the Dark: (October 14, 2010 9:19am)
100% 580 Stated loans. What?! There were lenders doing that at 540 stated W2's Totally insane! Remember the old 500 FIKO (actual spelling) for 5% down?
anders02: (October 14, 2010 9:14am)
Ok, I have read the bill and I am confused. How would that help this foreclosure mess? That has to do with the secretary of energy and greenhouse issues. Please provide further explanation. Also, this bill is dead!! It died in 08.
2bsquare: (October 14, 2010 9:11am)
I have been touting this concept on DC for 3 yrs. I sent an email to 2 US Senators and a half dozen Reps just last year. Your missing the point. Every Porgram since the last 9 months of Bush was to solely re-capitalize the big 5 banks. THe Big 5 have been using the HAMP Refi for just this concept, but they are earnign 5pts per loan. No joke, I just watched one go through at Citi. Using my wholesale sheets they had to have earned 5% or more. If this bill were put through, and it was open tot he entire market, meaning we didnt have to go back to the servicers and it applied to all loans now eligible for Fannie Limits, it would solve a world of problems.
NOSNEH: (October 14, 2010 9:10am)
The housing industry runs so much of our country's financial road, in terms of equity, investors, stablization of neighborhoods, etc. I have always thought that the government should have come out two years ago or at leastlast year and said "Everyone's interest rate is 3% or 3.5% of 4%. This would have kept families in their homes, avoided all the negativity of the empty, foreclosed houses, kept the ball rolling. The banks can certainly afford this drop in payments and they have shown that they are only out for themselves with their lack of help to consumers. On top of this mess starting because FNMAE & Freddicmac began buying no down payment loans so the floodgates of where to sell them, there were no consequences to anyone who created this mess. The homeowner and all the segments of jobs in the real estate industry have been the ones to take the hardest hit. The government needs to demand that the banks lose some money because of lower interest rates with no qualifying.
2bsquare: (October 14, 2010 9:10am)
I have been touting this concept on DC for 3 yrs. I sent an email to 2 US Senators and a half dozen Reps just last year. Your missing the point. Every Porgram since the last 9 months of Bush was to solely re-capitalize the big 5 banks. THe Big 5 have been using the HAMP Refi for just this concept, but they are earnign 5pts per loan. No joke, I just watched one go through at Citi. Using my wholesale sheets they had to have earned 5% or more. If this bill were put through, and it was open tot he entire market, meaning we didnt have to go back to the servicers and it applied to all loans now eligible for Fannie Limits, it would solve a world of problems.
GODLIKE: (October 14, 2010 9:08am)
Rather than rely upon high tariffs to make us competitive (which will only raise prices to the consumers and make the recovery tougher) how about getting rid of the unions with their artificially high wage rates and outdated work rules of I can't do that its not my job, so that we can be competitive. That has the advantage of lower prices for all.
midago: (October 14, 2010 9:04am)
I tried to modify a $200k loan from 6.5% 30 yr to 3% Interest Only for 3 years then review again. Rather than take a $7,000 reduction in interest income for 3 years, they advised me to do a short sale. I now have a contract in process for $77k with would net them $65k after commission and closing costs. They prefer to take a $135k loss on the loan than a $21k reduction in interest income. I just don't get it. And I sure don't think that the taxpayer should have to pay for the bank making this stupid decision.
sodi: (October 14, 2010 8:57am)
These mortgage bills are all fine and well but let's go to the root of the problem. Tighten up world trade agreements, put high tarrifs on imports so our own labor force can compete, bring manufacturing back to our own country. Without a strong economic base, how can we have a strong economy? With manufacturing back home where our own workers can spend their earnings at their neighborhood shops and the shopkeepers can spend their money on more durable goods, etcetera, we all will have more money to spend on what we need, like housing. It's time we looked at trickle up!
Chuck@HRC: (October 14, 2010 8:56am)
Godlike: You're very lucky to live in Texas. It's one of the few states that didn't get hit quite as hard as the "sand states". You can find the info on Case-Schiller's site (Standard & Poors) www.standardandpoors.com/indices/sp-case-shiller-home-price-indices. With 20+% of the national population, California's home value instability will be with the economy for years to come.
jdillingham: (October 14, 2010 8:51am)
All of the advantages you talk about are there. I don't see the additional disadvantage to the government or the tax payer. If we are talking about refinancing Fannie, Freddie and government loans. The taxpayers and government are already on the hook if these loans are not refinanced and they go south so there is no additional exposure, just a reduced likelihood of default as the refinance loans will provide a lower payment to the borrowers.
jdillingham: (October 14, 2010 8:51am)
All of the advantages you talk about are there. I don't see the additional disadvantage to the government or the tax payer. If we are talking about refinancing Fannie, Freddie and government loans. The taxpayers and government are already on the hook if these loans are not refinanced and they go south so there is no additional exposure, just a reduced likelihood of default as the refinance loans will provide a lower payment to the borrowers.
jdillingham: (October 14, 2010 8:50am)
All of the advantages you talk about are there. I don't see the additional disadvantage to the government or the tax payer. If we are talking about refinancing Fannie, Freddie and government loans. The taxpayers and government are already on the hook if these loans are not refinanced and they go south so there is no additional exposure, just a reduced likelihood of default as the refinance loans will provide a lower payment to the borrowers.
Kristian: (October 14, 2010 8:50am)
It's almost like Frank and Brian are testing us to see if we are actually thinking for ourselves. How many readers voted that 6218 would be good without actually reading it? It doesn't look good to me after I actually read it.
Evil Genius: (October 14, 2010 8:48am)
Most believe it's about adjusting the rate. It's not It is two-fold. The rate, but also the inflated prices of property. Read theis blog: "Re-cast the Debt, Not Foreclosure" at http://real estatemarbles.com/newgeneration Why can't we ever get common sense to prevail?
gwilcox72: (October 14, 2010 8:47am)
Let's not forget that there is already a stated, stated, stated, stated loan out there. It's called an FHA Streamline Refi w/o Appraisal.
gcall: (October 14, 2010 8:38am)
This bill could be worthwhile and helpful as a fix for the small but important group of people that would prefer to stay and not default if they could. The problem, as you guys pointed out is to get the banks on board without corrupting the whole system. I really see that as what happened in mods. Obama people were sincere but incapable. Called in bankers to actually write legislation. Banks of course weren't about to take loss so wrote legislation and cut deals to keep from taking the losses on mods and then sabatoged the process when buyers tried to get them expcept in those few cases where "pencilied out" with gmt incentives as best thing for banks. Have the same challenges with this bill and it will only help a few--but at least that is a few. The bigger challenge lies in finding a better, broader "fix". I think it is short sales.
Sandie: (October 14, 2010 8:30am)
If something like this could help people refinance and slow the wave after wave of foreclosures I would support it. It might help people who are self-employed, like Real Estate Agents, who can't refi because they need stated income loans. It would be preferable to FHA or VA which puts MIP or PMI on top of the payment. It may not be a bad idea, at least for a while. Perhaps it would help curb the strategic defaults at the very least. So many people are still underemployed, even if they are working, that lower payments would certainly help.
yerout: (October 14, 2010 8:27am)
I'm with KennyG, I too bought into the hype and voted YES. But having read the bill, I now vote no, I mean NO!
GODLIKE: (October 14, 2010 8:27am)
CHUCK@HRC I don't know about no 20 year recovery on values cause right here in Texas values are still going up for the most part. And you know that Cali will be overpaying very soon. Maybe in Michigan or Detroit those figures would be correct, but not in most of the world.
cgappraisals: (October 14, 2010 8:25am)
I had a Countrywide loan at 5.375 and now refi without income check thru BofA at 4.625. We still have equity. Few forms to fill out so far. $925 lender fee. No appraisal but there are Title and Escrow fees. They call it conv. fastrack loan. Saving $250 a month.
GODLIKE: (October 14, 2010 8:23am)
FINANCELOGIC I'm OK with doing no more refis. Refis have never been THE market except for short periods of time. THE market is purchases and I'll gladly sacrifice a few refis to gain a LOT of purchase money mortgages.
Daggone: (October 14, 2010 8:22am)
kkric I have a whole different feeling about upside down home owners. Why are they upside down? We have all lost equity. I've lost 20% as well. The difference is that I had equity to start with. If the upside down home owners did 100% loans, which most of them have in my experience, are they any more upside down that I? If they can pay, they need to pay. Banks writing down loans just comes back to the consumer. Sorry, that guy making 4X as much money as I and living in a home that was 2 to 3 times as much as mine that he got with 100% financing, I don't care. Let the banks who did those loans refinance them at fully amortizing market rate. Don't take money out of my pocket to do it by putting them in government backed loans or giving the lender my tax money.
hebbyd: (October 14, 2010 8:20am)
Chuck@HRC: The risk in refi vs. Purchase is the only issue at question here. Despite the original risk already taken, any new loan restarts the first 12 months risky period which is when most loans default. Historically speaking, even if you make the loan more affordable, people are more likely to walk from their home after a refi than after a purchase. Why would the bank double the risk for less money? Unless some government mandate requires or insures it, this is not a choice banks will make and rightly so. I agree that collateral has a very long road ahead of it, but the Chase Schiller doomsday scenario refers to areas like downtown detroit where properties were sold for 3,500.00 bucks. Those value will take a very long time to get to pre-recession levels, but if you bought one for 3,500.00 you'll be pretty happy when they hit 50k and that is only a couple of years away.
Robs Homes Online: (October 14, 2010 8:19am)
LO's, how is this different than a Loan Mod without a default?
Robs Homes Online: (October 14, 2010 8:19am)
LO's, how is this different than a Loan Mod without a default?
Robs Homes Online: (October 14, 2010 8:18am)
LO's, how is this different than a Loan Mod without a default?
Analyst 1: (October 14, 2010 8:14am)
The comments with regard to risk are slightly off-base. The refi at a lower interest rate lowers the risk of a default since it makes the mortgage more affordable for the borrower. In as much as the lender is not providing additional funding the loan is less risky at the new reduced rate. If a borrower is under water he is less likely to default at 4% than at 6%. A rate and term refinance would therefore lessen the risk of a strategic default occurring. The lender would in essence forgo a portion of the original interest income negotiated at the outset of the original mortgage in exchange for a reduction of risk. I don't know if the necessary rate decline is commensurate with the risk reduction to make this a feasible alternative but with the glut of REO's on the marketing selling at around forty cents on the dollar, I wouldn't be quick to write this proposal off as an additional means to preserve some value in the market and assist in the recovery of the housing market.
katiemule: (October 14, 2010 8:13am)
my note is 6.25% and I cant re-finance because hubby lost job,and now is making less so we cant qualify for re-fi, but I would jump at the chance to do a stated/stated just to get our payment lowered; we are upside down too, so this idea would impact me personally and many others too. also, I wish you guys would do away with the time consuming intro, I'm tired of it and it wastes time..
Chuck@HRC: (October 14, 2010 8:06am)
Hebbyd: The statistical risk difference between purchase financing and a refi IS NOT an issue here... the loan, generally at much more than the collateral value can support, has already been made! A lender's risk today is framed as a false-choice between writing down principal to help save a homeowner from foreclosure or taking a loss at foreclosure now. With over 60% of homes in California having a home equity loan of some ilk, forgiving principal on a 1st will only serve to IMPROVE the position of the junior lienholder (read here: the city-center banks who hold 75+% of all home equity loans). This IS the "moral hazard" issue. Godlike: Case-Schiller has reported its research says property values are unlikely to return to pre-recession levels for 20 years. That's 2027 (peak to trough)! No wonder programs like HAMP and HARP have been such failures... homeowners are smarter [they got a serious education from all this] and know these programs won't help.
Owl Tree: (October 14, 2010 8:02am)
One final thought - it would be refreshing if the government actually included some real live loan officers (not government apparatchiks and big bank lobbyists) in crafting the implementation of a new refinance product.
Owl Tree: (October 14, 2010 8:01am)
Seriously though, if they go with a triple-stated (income/assets/appraisal) program, they need to take care to seperate the paper from the A+ full doc loans in the secondary market. I'm all for a no-appraisal program on rate-term refinances, because the current system is broken beyond belief, and I don't expect the "Son of HVCC" to be any better.
lendershop: (October 14, 2010 8:00am)
Franks having a bad hair day
Clulessdad: (October 14, 2010 8:00am)
If I am holding a performing note at 6% and someone came up to me and said I will give you $1000 to write a new note at 4%, I would laugh at him. The concept of rewarding the population who are being vigilant with their mortgage payments is a great idea, however this is not the answer. Maybe an FHA Streamline with no monthly MIP? Maybe stick the borrower with any principal losses due a strategic foreclosure? Maybe create a job loss insurance fund with some added UFMIP paid out of pocket? I am sure that some of our "think outside the box" people could come up with a good way of finally rewarding the good people of our country.
Owl Tree: (October 14, 2010 7:58am)
The Cordoza bill sounds like a great idea....and if turns out to be a disaster, they can just blame "predatory mortgage brokers". Win-win for everyone involved.
kkric: (October 14, 2010 7:57am)
This is just another attempt by the banks to avoid writing off principal on upside down loans. Just today, Bloomberg has a story on B or A re-securitizing their pile of junk loans into new securities rated AAA by the rating agencies. They just cut the LTV on the AAA package and take their lumps on the still junk rated junk portion. This re-affirms B of A's position that it will do nothing to help upside down homeowners by reducing principal. This just extends the foreclosure problem as these new packages go into default. We need a nationwide (or even California wide) strike by upside down homeowners. A concerted, "stop paying and I'm willing to walk away" effort would force B of A's hand and they would have to negotiate. Right now, the "moral" homeowners who continue to pay on a significantly upside down mortgage are allowing the Banks to prolong the crisis. Next March in SFO, let's just add to the chant, "hey, hey, we are gay and we're just going to walk away."
Daggone: (October 14, 2010 7:56am)
No Financelogic I do not have enough purchase business to keep me busy. Purchase business? What's that? Most of the Realtors I know have simply laid down, just going to wait it out. I am simply looking at the opportunities to refinance that don't and can't pan out because of values more than anything. How many of the people are walking away because they are under water, but could otherwise pay.
Your Favorite Realtor: (October 14, 2010 7:55am)
It is unrealistic to think that the lender or the investor would have any motive to do this refi. They are after all getting the higher interest from someone who is current. They are too short sighted to see that halting the chance of a strategic default, helps them in the long run. All they will see is the lost revenue. The only to make them want this would be to give them money. That money would have to come from somewhere. Taxpayers?
GODLIKE: (October 14, 2010 7:45am)
If there's a prohibition on fees how can these Mods be done? I mean there are costs, if nothing else there are redrawing and refiling fees. And then there's the fact someone has to handle the paperwork and talk to the note holders. The servicers don't have staff for dealing with the public, they'll have to hire people and that's a cost. I think this is a good idea in concept, but it needs to be modified to fit reality.
GODLIKE: (October 14, 2010 7:35am)
They say the first step for an alcoholic or druggie is to understand and admit they need help. You can't effect a cure from the outside, the person has to know deep down their actions are destructive. They only way that will happen in our industry is for there to be actual penalties. I don't mean paper penalties that no one enforces, it has to be more advantageous to do business the proper way than to cheat. Most of these new bills have come about because there was little to no enforcement of the old laws. We didn't need new laws, we needed enforcement - and we still do.
hebbyd: (October 14, 2010 7:31am)
We're overlooking a key element of risk here. Statistically speaking, refinances have a much greater liklihood of default than a purchase loan. The assumption everyone is making that lower payments means a borrower will stay is just not statistically accurate. Bankers and actuaries aren't going to look for a solution to this crisis through more refi's. It compounds risky loans. Think about it, if you're the bank, would you really want to carry the upside down loan for less profit than you're earning today? NO! That said, as an LO I would love to continue to supplement income with these refi's. Guess we'll see...
GODLIKE: (October 14, 2010 7:31am)
Writing down negative equity sounds good now, but what about when housing prices start to rise again. You know that in California prices will be right back at present day levels soon so do all the ones who got their equity written down get to profit while all the people who did the honest thing suffer?
lolsen: (October 14, 2010 7:29am)
This will favor banks again since many states will not allow lenders and brokers to originate loans without verifying income and assets.
GODLIKE: (October 14, 2010 7:28am)
I wouldn't mind doing them at a reduced fee or even a set dollar amount as the volume and the simplicity of it would more than make up for the lack of $$$ on each deal.
GODLIKE: (October 14, 2010 7:27am)
So does that mean that all these refis would have to go thru the servicer and not mortgage companies? If so can you imagine the glacial speed they'd work? In 2020 we still wouldn't be through.
GODLIKE: (October 14, 2010 7:25am)
CHAPTER & VERSE! I need chapter & verse. An AMC is refusing to get info to the appraiser so he can raise the appraisal. We've had contact with the appraiser twice thru the builder and he says he has no trouble raising it but he must get the request thru the AMC and they are refusing to even send the info to him. What can I say or do to force the issue?
JJ320: (October 14, 2010 7:24am)
Just like everything else the government passes....they have no clue how it affects the industries it serves. If they don't pay for anything, where is the motivation to complete the tasks. Example, look at how many people have been working on their loan mods for a year...or longer. Good luck with refinancing your home with a free government program. By the time you get your refinance through, the rates will be higher than what you currently have. If the goverernment has any hope of getting this through successfully, they will have to pay for the service. The way to do it is to put limits on the maximum compensation. Even if it is low, there will be so many people in line that everyone will make money on the sheer volume. It will definitely stimulate the economy.
Robs Homes Online: (October 14, 2010 7:15am)
Here's the tough question for borrowers in this position from a purely fiscal position...If they are under water on their home, and participate in the program and lower their payment to a more affordable position, but still have 3-5 years before they could sell the home and buy something else, wouldn't they be in a better position to strategically default now, rent for 2 years and be able to purchase in 2 years at a more "market appropriate" price that will allow them to see true appreciation rather than climbing out of the hole they're in now, just to break even in 3-5 years? I'm not supporting either way, but I have a feeling this bill is a way to avoid more Strategic Defaults because the banks know that's a much better option for the consumer, the Bill is better for the banks. Thoughts?
James the Appraiser: (October 14, 2010 7:15am)
The bill would help self-employed like me, an appraiser. Even with a 700+ credit score for both me and my wife, a 60% LTV and being with BoA for years it took a mountain of paperwork to get them to refi us from 5.875 to 5.125 last year. With todays rates I would like to refi again, but the amount of paperwork is not worth it, or is it? My loan is just $220,000. WHY CAN'T BoA OFFER TO REWRITE THE INTEREST RATE ON MY PRESENT NOTE WITHOUT REDOING THE COMPLETE LOAN? Banks did this inthe 70's and 80's for thire best borrowers, I know. So why can't they do it now?
FinanceLogic: (October 14, 2010 7:09am)
So DAGGONE are you ok with not doing any more refinance loans? Do you have enough purchase business to earn a good living? If this bill passes no one will use you to refinance. Why would borrowers opt to pay you and an appraiser when they can get a loan for FREE from their current servicer!?
spurkay: (October 14, 2010 7:07am)
I take offense at the implication that all stated/stated borrowers are deadbeats that had no intention of paying on their loan. Mortgage brokers were more than happy to collect the fees and commissions for financing them, right? I've always paid my mortgage and am far from a dead beat. I can refi directly through the lender, so the mortgage brokers don't need to worry about not getting paid for work. I won't ask them to do a thing. Last time I did, they were paid $15,000 on a $117K loan!! and stuffed me into a neg am without disclosing this to me, even though I questioned it.
spurkay: (October 14, 2010 7:06am)
I take offense at the implication that all stated/stated borrowers are deadbeats that had no intention of paying on their loan. Mortgage brokers were more than happy to collect the fees and commissions for financing them, right? I've always paid my mortgage and am far from a dead beat. I can refi directly through the lender, so the mortgage brokers don't need to worry about not getting paid for work. I won't ask them to do a thing. Last time I did, they were paid $15,000 on a $117K loan!! and stuffed me into a neg am without disclosing this to me, even though I questioned it.
Daggone: (October 14, 2010 7:03am)
IF a home owner can refinance no questions asked, except "are you paying your mortgage on time?", then I agree with all the pros you showed us today. This should reduce the incentive for the home owner who is under water to vacate his property or actually get a government backed loan for that property. I've had several deals that did not appraise, mostly because the AMC appraiser sucked, the home owner is happy with his home. Why not let them refi at the same lender they have, and as a broker I don't care if I'm left out of the loop. Just get some money back into the consumer's pocket. Time and time again I'm seeing people who cannot refi due to appraised value. Give them a break! I DO have a problem with the government paying the lender ANY incentive for doing this. We do not need to give any more $$$ to the banks!
Jim in Atlanta: (October 14, 2010 7:03am)
When you are asigning blame do not forget the politicians. They have been pushing and pushing for a higher and higher percentage of homeownership in this country - on both sides of the isle. This push required lenders to go lower and lower in the barrel to find lending candidates.
thevinehouse: (October 14, 2010 7:02am)
"The Realtor" is absolutely correct.The decision makers that got us into this mess need to be fully prosecuted and thrown in jail!They broke the law(s!)If you or I did something similar to what has happened to cause this crisis (on a smaller scale),WE WOULD BE IN JAIL!What keeps them out of jail?Denial and politics (sometimes known as money).Both are equally dangerous - money keeps the politicians from doing the right thing and denial keeps the people from demanding justice and a real solution!Even as you read these responses, there still is the tell-tale signs of denial.WAKE UP, PEOPLE!There are people - YOUR CUSTOMERS - losing their homes right now that had absolutely nothing to do with anything that put them in that situation - ABSOLUTELY NOTHING!.That was done for them by a bunch of financial industry executives in high rises across this country.I urge everyone to take a look at the RICO class action coming out of Kentucky.If only 5% of the major assertions are true, unbelievable!
Jim in Atlanta: (October 14, 2010 7:02am)
When you are asigning blame do not forget the politicians. They have been pushing and pushing for a higher and higher percentage of homeownership in this country - on both sides of the isle. This push required lenders to go lower and lower in the barrel to find lending candidates.
FinanceLogic: (October 14, 2010 7:00am)
73% of voters SUPPORT the bill. Are you kidding me!?!? Do you want to be out of work? This bill ensures that no loan officer or appraiser will get paid, PERIOD! These loans will be directly from the servicer to the customer with $1000 MAX fees. I would prefer this NOT pass and I can keep earning a living. Are you 73% changing professions???
eMoney: (October 14, 2010 6:58am)
I'm from the Government and I'm here to help Gee Thanks
Mike8307: (October 14, 2010 6:56am)
We rehashed this the other day. How do you sell the loans to the secondary market? You are trying to pay off higher interest loans with lower interest loans (lower ROI) with STATED values (higher RISK). It is completely opposite of what investing is. The higher the risk, the higher the ROI (return on investment) that is required. Sure this plan works great for the homeowner. But it stinks for the investor, and therefore will never get off the ground. You need two sides to participate in mortgage lending. You'll only have one side coming to the table with this, without massive government (taxpayer) guarantees. Smaller government, lesser government involvement, lower taxes, will mean more jobs and more people that can pay their mortgage!!!! Jobs solve 95% of all our problems.
Kschneids: (October 14, 2010 6:48am)
No fees to the loan originator, and a maximum of $1,000 to the servicer. I would love to be able to help my clients out, but that does not mean I work for free.
VinnieB: (October 14, 2010 6:44am)
Read the bill before you vote http://thomas.loc.gov/cgi-bin/query/z?c111:H.R.6218:
5pence: (October 14, 2010 6:39am)
HR 6218 is a re-tread of the original FHA offering when the bust was happening 2-3 years ago. Nothing new, No doc, AVM supported re-fi's with $1,000 for originators. It didn't work then, it won't work now.
5pence: (October 14, 2010 6:35am)
Sure Brian, it's all of the above and it's the volunteer soldiers fault for war.
SBROSEN: (October 14, 2010 6:35am)
Bill has lots of merit, and reduces the next wave of foreclosures but I believe that will also have a big effect on the economy. At this point this is a good way to stimulate buying by putting more money in the hands of the people who need it the most.
VinnieB: (October 14, 2010 6:31am)
WTF?? No fees can be collected? Who is going to originate these loans? (6) PROHIBITION ON BORROWER FEES- The servicer conducting the refinancing shall not charge the mortgagor any fee for the refinancing of the qualified mortgage through the refinancing mortgage
VinnieB: (October 14, 2010 6:31am)
WTF?? No fees can be collected? Who is going to originate these loans? (6) PROHIBITION ON BORROWER FEES- The servicer conducting the refinancing shall not charge the mortgagor any fee for the refinancing of the qualified mortgage through the refinancing mortgage
VinnieB: (October 14, 2010 6:30am)
WTF?? No fees can be collected? Who is going to originate these loans? (6) PROHIBITION ON BORROWER FEES- The servicer conducting the refinancing shall not charge the mortgagor any fee for the refinancing of the qualified mortgage through the refinancing mortgage
pazookie: (October 14, 2010 6:21am)
To save the housing market, we need to solve the unemployment debacle.. Until people have jobs we're simply trying to put a band-aid on a geyser.. Once unemployment is resolved through the creation of private sector jobs I like: DPA for low down payment programs.. HR 6218 with a 20% downpayment... Let responsible people who got caught off guard & now have damaging credit, get back into the game as buyers.
5pence: (October 14, 2010 6:20am)
What happens when we get to the point that no one will buy our debt? Then what. America defaults? More printing? China bought our debt and is being burnt big time by continued QE. High rates of 4.25% are the problem. They are so high that home prices continue to fall. At 2% the banks could get rid of their toxic assets at near full value and our food prices and oil and gas won't go up. The banksters are in the way of recovery IMHO.
5pence: (October 14, 2010 6:14am)
TD Hawk: Spending by consumers creates jobs. I'm not saying 2% rates is a cure-all but it's a hell of a lot better than trying to deflate the dollar to get us out of here (QE). Rising prices throgh inflation is going to help no one but the banksters imho. Also, China can't be real happy about buying all our debt and seeing it's value dropping through QE by 40%+
rayprose: (October 14, 2010 5:55am)
Have you all quit breathing oxygen??? HR6218 is just another way for banks to grab another slice of our pie. I agree with Lenny and Kenny and vote emphatically NO! All this bill will do is make it easier for the banks to offer these programs with government (Taxpayers) underwriting. If you want an example of that look no further than the deal that BOA struck to purchase the assets of Countrywide. They are now making 170% of some of those underwater loans. Why would they NOT offer them an additional incentive low interest loan??? Can you SEE THAT? What we as an industry need to do is to look at the proponent of the bills proposed and then see where they get most of their campaign contributions to see what is buried in that specific bill. Congressman are great at touting a bill as one thing and then hiding pork and curve balls in that bill that no one catches until after it is passed. The sad thing is they are soooo good at it that we seldom notice until it is law!
GaryP: (October 14, 2010 5:47am)
What's the incentive for an LO to roriginate the loan if he is not fairly compensated for his work. $1000? I'm sure that will go to paying lender fees and the LO will make nothing. I'm sorry, but I am not a charity and I don't work for free. This sounds like another socialistic pie in the sky, pipe dream that has no real application. If it were to be approved it would be just as effective as the loan mod programs that have absolutely no significant impact. I could see how these loans would be fairly quick an easy, especially if there is no documentation of almost anything other than paymen history, and I don't have a problem with making $1K on them, but not if the $1K is going towards fees. Here's the other problem. What is the motivation for a home owner to get a traditional R/T refi if this were available? Loan volume may go up, to the point that our loan production system will end up collapsing, but will the revenue associated with that volume?
KKS: (October 14, 2010 5:42am)
the druggie needs to hit bottom. Hitting bottom can and is hard. Many's drug of choice was over investing in the real estate market which pushed prices and folks taking on loans they truly could not afford (convenient amnesia comes to mind with "I didn't know crap). this in turn affects far more people than just the individual "druggie of real estate". Just like the tech bubble, people's portfolios were unbalanced. And just like the druggie we need to hit bottom. "Help" before hitting bottom only makes the problem worse, prolonged and harsher consequences. Need to hit bottom and then get back on our feet the "right" way.
[email protected]: (October 14, 2010 5:39am)
the BANKS won't buy these refi's from anyone -- they will make them in house -- leaving us out of the loop and stealing our refi business for years.
TD Hawk: (October 14, 2010 5:25am)
Wouldn't matter if they gave everyone a zero percent rate, you cannot pay your bills if 1. you don't have a job and/or 2. aren't making enough (even if you're working 80 hrs). I'm afraid nothing is going to work until joblessness abates or the middle class is somehow rejuvenated. This is also known as Paying the Piper or "taking your medicine."
therealtor: (October 14, 2010 4:32am)
sorry for the typos
therealtor: (October 14, 2010 4:31am)
You had to suck me back into it. This bill and your asertions are absurd. The only way this is going to get corrected is if the market finds it's own bottom and becomes more affordable and people who have been responsible for all this BS are prosecuted, take a place in jail and pay for every principle reduction to stabilize this market. Reducing only the rate/payment is not going to solve this. Even our president now believes, at least stated during one of the interviews he did around the financil bill, that we are paddlers who were peddling loans. That's BS...we are not and never were the Authority who created these financial products, we should not be blamed nor the people going throght the suffering. A few day ago I went back and looked at all the trnasactions I did between 2004-2008 and I saw that close to 90%, yes 90, have alrady lost their homes. NO MORE!
kennyg: (October 14, 2010 4:18am)
Sheesh! Congress must be rubbin' off on ol' GoldKenny! I voted 'YES' on the survey based on the hype! Then I READ the bill. Now I vote emphatically 'NO'! Let's face it-the banks have broken law after law in dealing with the loan AND the foreclosure. TARP was originally concieved so that the market would absorb depreciation by writing a new loan considering the delfated value. The bank then would apply for reimbursement of its loss through TARP and the homeowner had a MUCH better chance of keeping the house. But the reality of TARP set up a reason TO push forecloseres since the bank cashes in on it's VERY trumped-up loss. Has ANYONE NOTICED that the second TARP expired, there's talk of a moratorium on completing the foreclosure process? WHY? Are the banks still planning how they can 'let it ride', while keeping revolution at bay? The recourse for the bank for fraud and missing docs should be to tear up the mortgage and 'bank error in your favor, here's your satisfaction of mortgage'!
Divedude: (October 14, 2010 4:13am)
Now all 50 states investigating improper foreclosures. We need to push our Attorney Generals offices for jail time for these individuals and not let them back into the industry. This will create a lot of job openings for new blood that will think twice before circumventing the rules. THAT will put the lending industry back to work! Damm! I'm good!
Fl Mortg Lady : (October 14, 2010 4:10am)
Cardozza's bill is the best start turn this underwater problm for current homeowners around! The only other better option is for banks to write down (or write off negative) equity, but that WOULD cost us. Already good paying homeowners should be rewarded for KEEPING their underwater loan, which wll slow down strategic defaults. Sorry guys, no compensation for LO's or appraisers, but a HUGE number of homeowners in the US would be greatly helped. We can make plenty of money on the purchases.
MortgageAngel: (October 14, 2010 2:51am)
SURVEY SAYS: DING! low interest rates do not = JOBS Quantitative easing does NOTHING for aggregate demand. MUCH NEEDED TAX REVENUE You're fucking killing me!! They don't NEED shit! Snap out of it already. CREATE WORK FOR THE LENDING INDUSTRY How fucking nobel is THAT? This is joke, right? Brian, you're panicing but it's okay. Our government really can afford to spend what ever it wants to spend. And if the ugly old inflation monster creeps up on us it will mean we've returned to full employment - (not just our industry but EVERYONE. Wouldn't that be more fun? ) and THEN (here comes the best part) gov't can raise our taxes and reduce our spending power and that will chase the big boogie inflation monster away and FAST! STORMY www.moslereconomics.com Counter Insurgency, Deficit Terrorist Unit
MortgageAngel: (October 14, 2010 2:49am)
But, what's even MORE absurd is the notion that a Federal gov't NEEDS taxpayer dollars in order have money to spend. I mean, isn't that a kind of like saying the football stadium collects your ticket because they need it to give to someone else? The Federal gov't is the score keeper. It never has nor doesn't have any dollars anymore than the stadium keeps a lockbox full of event tickets. If the seat is assigned (purchased) a ticket prints out. If not - there's no need for a ticket! BENEFITING E Q U I T Y VICTIMS - But what if 5 years from now they have equity again? Housing starts dropping population growing... hello? I would not bet against it! NO COST TO TAXPAYERS - The purpose of federal taxes is to regulate the economy not to raise revenue, per se. Federal taxes don't actually "pay" for anything. LOWER THE RATES SOME MORE TO STIMULATE THE ECONOMY ?-BAHAHAHAHA yeah, SURE! Doy! If it duddn't work just do it sum more, da doy!
dennis2me: (October 14, 2010 2:08am)
I suggested to our elected officials in 2008 that every homeowner should be able to refi at 4% with no credit check or appraisal and if you owed 300k and it was only worth 200k your new mortgage would still be 300k. I believe this would stablize the housing market and improve the economy as the homeowners would have better cash flow so they could buy other things or save for their future retirement. Owner occupants are the backbone of the country and want to stay in their homes. Instead our elected officials offer loan modifications that didn't work and required people to be behind in payments to be considered. Today I would suggest to change the rate to 3%.
stantheman: (October 14, 2010 2:07am)
What do you mean NO APPRAISAL. That sucks.
stantheman: (October 14, 2010 2:05am)
Anything to get things started and more appraisal work
hmci: (October 14, 2010 2:05am)
Did anyone read the bill? There is no compensation for the originator, the servicer will get $1,000 from the GSE. Although no appraisal is necessary, it doesn't say anything about stated nothing. The bill also says the new loan will be priced with comprable risk loans currently being offered. What would be the current rate in today's market for a stated loan, 10% ?? Frank & Brian, I love your daily report, but where's your homework on this one?
MortgageAngel: (October 14, 2010 1:40am)
Olly olly oxen free!!