Lenders Unveil Compensation Plans - 02.10.11
Today's Poll: How do you feel about the new compensation?
A. Bring it!
B. I'm 50/50 on it.
C. I hate it.
D. I'm looking at bartending.
Rate this Program
Steve0: (February 14, 2011 6:58am)
This Morning I wrote a Blog and sent a letter to a CNNMONEY Reported trying to get some media coverage on this thing. The media has not picked up on this story, which in my opinion is the biggest news in our industry in decades. Please feel free to share, plagerize, edit, and distribute anywhere you like. Check it out here. http://activerain.com/blogsview/2135758/new-federal-originator-compensation-regulations-threaten-housing-recovery-a-call-to-action Thanks for reading.
slacknup: (February 12, 2011 11:18am)
There is a problem setting compensation with wholesalers at .75% ,1% and 2% to be able to repond to a competitive situation. It's called "Safe Harber". We have to provide 3 different offers to the borrower to prove we are not "steering". Which of the above offers do you think they will want???
mbreston: (February 11, 2011 7:21am)
From a practical standpoint you are correct in that unless we were to define our income % in the lender paid option so low as to allow for a zero cost on the lender paid (eg excess ysp over our comp) or unless we were to define our cap low enough to where on large loans our cap limited our comp so that more ysp went to cover costs, the zero cost deal is essentially not going to happen. This is something that needs to be taken up with the staff at the Bureau for Consumer Protection when they start working on this. There needs to be an exception that allows a broker to earn less than the prescribed income % when they are trying to accomplish a zero cost loan for the consumer. However, it is important to note that the regulators can come back and say that we could, if we wanted define our income % low enough now to allow for zero costs. We would just have to do that on all deals. The Rule allows for excess ysp over the broker comp to pay other costs.
FinanceLogic: (February 11, 2011 7:10am)
@mbreston: effective 4/1 there is not a no closing cost option... if the LO wants to get paid. @nickrapp: Effective 4/1 Borrowers have to pay the LO directly, either cash due @ closing or rolled into the loan amount. The fee cannot be POC. The fee has to be disclosed on the HUD and match the compensation plan the broker set up with the lender. The broker/LO cannot be paid by the lender as this is deemed YSP and is a violation of respa.
nickrapp: (February 11, 2011 6:42am)
Does anybody know what SunTrust means on the borrower paid scenario when they say "All compensation to the broker would be paid out of pocket by the borrower"? Would the fee have to be POC or could it be rolled into the closing?
mbreston: (February 11, 2011 6:09am)
at this point all of us need to realize we are on the verge of setting a record for the longest series of posts on tbws daily. we need to keep this thing rolling even if it means starting to include our spouses who can testify to how dumb we all are. on the low loan size issue, that is dealt with by having a minimum. for instance with Wells in tx this will be 2,200. if , however, i want to earn less, i can earn less by going to customer paid option. low loan sizes are not a problem unless you want to do a 0 closing cost option on a low loan size and typically that is not possible anyway because there is not enough ysp in the deal for that on a low loan size.
Noel Cookman: (February 11, 2011 6:02am)
Love that .750%, 1% and 2% compensation. How many $60,000 loans do you do? Feel-good regs like this end up hurting lower income buyers. They don't get call-backs from the mortgage company. The Broker/LO simply can't afford to spend as much time on a $50,000 deal when their compensation will be $1,000 TOTAL at the most and maybe as little as $375. And greeting at WalMart is so stress-free; Now, it's more profitable.
5pence: (February 10, 2011 6:42pm)
Thanks FTBC, that's what I thought with the Fed in control - you know, the one that has TBTF's as part owners and can't make impartial judgements. Anybody else?
free trade benefits consumers: (February 10, 2011 6:16pm)
Final conclusion is that the controlling of compensation is un-American and creates more problems than any perceived problem it is hoped to solve. It will reduce the ability of businesses to compete, reduce customer choices, increase costs to consumers, and therefore this ill conceived legislation should be repealed.
5pence: (February 10, 2011 5:23pm)
So, what's the final conclusion on compensation?
5pence: (February 10, 2011 2:49pm)
Sorry, my cut and paste took more info than I meant it too.... "Obama's Big Budget Cut Proposals Target The Poor. 02/10/11... Wolfe said he assumed the White House had "drawn a circle" around education-aid programs like Pell Grants and Head Start. "My guess is that the administration sees a course of programs they want to protect," he said. "But why offer this up before the Republicans suggest cuts. Why volunteer us? Why volunteer LIHEAP?". The National Energy Assistance Directors' Association, a group that represents state aid officials in Washington, said Wednesday that the bad economy has forced more low-income households to rely on LIHEAP. About 8.3 million households used it in fiscal 2010, up from 7.7 million and 5.8 million during the previous two years, and the association expects eligible applications to rise to 8.9 million this year. NEADA director Mark Wolfe told HuffPost that the administration's proposal would cut off 3.5 households. "It's just a cruel proposal," Wolfe said. "What this would do is take some of the most vulnerable families in the country off energy assistance."
5pence: (February 10, 2011 2:44pm)
Blindsided: GOP Leaders Shocked As Tea Party Flexes Muscles. More in Politics: Sharron Angle At CPAC... CPAC 2011 Live Updates... CPAC Birther Joke... . Sarah Palin Strikes Back At 'Neanderthal' Rick Santorum. GOP Congressman Resigns Amid Shirtless Photo Scandal. Nancy Pelosi: Women's Rights Facing Greatest Threat In Our Lifetime. GOP Consultant: Sarah Palin Is 'The Obama White House's Secret Weapon'. GOP Senator Not Running For Reelection In 2012. Arthur Delaney HuffPost Reporting [email protected] GET UPDATES FROM Arthur Like 3Obama's Big Budget Cut Proposals Target The Poor First Posted: 02/10/11 03:47 PM Updated: 02/10/11 03:52 PM ... http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2011/02/10/obama-budget-cut-proposals-target-poor_n_821010.html
5pence: (February 10, 2011 2:40pm)
BTW, Paul Mondor in disregarding the letter because everyone sent the same one is the defense the banks are using in foreclosure contestments, that the deficiencies statements of the banks in handling the mortgages wrongfully has become too common and therefore should be disregarded by the courts. And courts are agreeing with this! If the complaint is too common and the views are held by all in all states, then it's commonality loses it's validity as being a viable complaint - it becomes spam. Huh??!! What??!! The fight for womens right and civil rights was spam because the same problems were quoted over and over? That is our government for you, valid complaints by all citizens in writing or by voice agreement is spam. No wonder they ignored all the letters against HVCC! Spam ! Sickening that they can disregard doing what's right because too many people are saying the same thing. Just goes to show, banks are in charge, not the courts and not the governments & certainly not the consumer
RockRidge: (February 10, 2011 2:34pm)
Hey loansbylynch What if 360 is interpreting the rule incorrectly? Everyone is talking about competeing with the banks. What about the small or mini correspondent who has a small warehouse line and can pass thru the fees and gets better pricing and volume discounts. That is who the brokers should be worried about. That is the giuy down the street who is going to take your business. He has more risk but also more pricing flexability and better pricing.
proceedwithcaution: (February 10, 2011 2:09pm)
underwritten a loan? Have you ever created the guidelines for subprime loans? Have you ever pooled loans and sold them all as A Paper on Wall Street? So why are we the whipping posts for this? Simply because we have the lowest voices and the shallowest pockets. We write letters to our elected officials, we call their offices and all this effort in the words of Paul Mondor is that we are spamming him and that we are doing to little too late. We didn't comment on the Fed Rule during the comment period because no one knew what it was all about to comment on and we still don't as evidenced by all this discussion. This goverment is way out of control and unless we do something about it, we get what we get. I think the only hope we really have for a true difference comes from the NAMB video yesterday that stated that congress is now going to grill the Fed about all this..Barney Frank is not House Financial Services Chairman any longer so with the Replublican in there, keep em x'ed
proceedwithcaution: (February 10, 2011 1:58pm)
How many tylenol have you guys all taken going back on forth on this. I find the whole thing amazing & I am sure you would agree that if someone had told us five years ago that this is what our industry would come to, no one would have believed it. Wholesalers I have spoken w/(I'm a broker)are saying the same thing that Utah is saying. I am concerned that instead of getting the honest scoop from your respective lending environment(wholesale/retail),that each will tell you what they want you to hear so that you will think you're in the right place & that this fed rule is the other guy/gal's problem.I think the Fed, Dodd-Frank is way off on all of this and if they & the rating agencies had done their jobs in the first place we wouldn't be in this situaion at all. When I did subprime loans,borrowers didn't get A Paper rates, so how come those loans wound up in A Paper pools,& in the end, why is are originators being overregulated for what we had nothing to do with. Have you ever
free trade benefits consumers: (February 10, 2011 1:20pm)
I like Mark Savitts approach. These are the questions we should be asking; 1) "Where is the data to show this is necessary?" and; 2) “Where is the data to show it will have any positive change to that data?" This is such a ridiculous concept and evidenced by the incredible difficulty implementing it presents, the consumer choice that will be lost (Compensating brokers via up front costs and YSP (SRP) like banks will still be able to do), and the higher borrowing costs it will create demonstrates Barney Frank does not have a clue about what he proposes.
Source1dan: (February 10, 2011 12:38pm)
FYI Small community banks. If you do not underwrite your own FHA loans your bank will be treated as a broker for compensation!
Driven2n: (February 10, 2011 12:28pm)
btw Jacko, srp's are not included per the Fed guide which says... The rule does not apply to payments received by a creditor when selling the loan to a secondary market investor. When a mortgage brokerage firm originates a loan, it is not exempt under the final rule unless it is also a creditor that funds the loan from its own resources, such as its own line of credit." My point being that the Banks (creditors) do not (still) have to disclose their compensation, whereas the rest of us do. I certainly agree that broker originators have more flexibility in price options to the consumer...IF Utah is right.
justsomedad: (February 10, 2011 12:15pm)
FinanceLogic: I don’t want it to be over for brokers. I know that the disappearance of the broker will hurt consumers. However, the deck has been stacked. Brokers are finished. What is best for the consumer is completely irrelevant.
Driven2n: (February 10, 2011 12:14pm)
Here is a link to the recently published Fed bulletin "Compliance Guide..." http://www.federalreserve.gov/bankinforeg/regzcg.htm Utah,we have also been using the 2010gfe model without any problems. It was easy to wrap our heads around the idea that the ysp was a credit to BORROWERS, and could be used to offset origination costs. My concern is that, as of 1/4/11, they would not be able to use their credit to offsett ORIGINATION fee's, only third party fee's. If you are right on your/360's interpretation of customer paid options...Haleluleah!!!
jacko: (February 10, 2011 12:11pm)
the new rule effects SRP and YSP. Banks have to comply too. It levels the playing field - maybe even tips it towards brokers at least as the originator because as a bank I can't be paid SRP on a loan by loan basis so that argument doesn't really make sense. I'm not an expert and if I'm wrong I would love a compelling argument but right now it just appears to be either misguided or fear based. I am a lender and a broker right now and I'm feeling better about the broker option.
Utah Mortgage&Real Estate Guy: (February 10, 2011 12:06pm)
Yes I agree Finance Logic; I don't really expect to see many Lender Comp plans available from the lenders I use. It is a really sticky issue, if I was a lender, I wouldn't put my business on the line either. UPDATE for Driven2n: on the Lender Paid Model and the Limit of YSP to the borrower. The reason the YSP credit to the borrower is limited to within $250 of third party charges. Imagine if you told the borrower that they would receive a credit of $1500 more than their costs, but you require a $1500 fee to originate the loan. The temptation of a LO selling (coerciing) the borrower to give them a check OUTSIDE of closing to get the extra YSP is actually the more important issue. When limiting the credit to Third Party Fees, it can ensure that the mortgage brokerage/Loan Officer is ONLY compensated by the Lender. I just received an email from one of my lenders addressing this issue exactly and this is what they used for an example of the reasoning to Limit YSP credit.
FinanceLogic: (February 10, 2011 12:04pm)
@justsomedad: I perceive you WANT IT to be over for brokers. Why, what do you have to gain? If brokers all went away it will only hurt the consumer. Less competition is always a bad thing. I'm a broker and I plan on sticking around for a long time, regardless of what you WISH on me. ;-)
justsomedad: (February 10, 2011 12:01pm)
The brokerage model is OVER. Anyone who disagrees please consider YSP vs SRP.
FinanceLogic: (February 10, 2011 11:57am)
@Utah Mortgage&Real Estate Guy: That explanation is exactly why many lenders won't roll out a lender paid option... Too much paperwork, and too much fear of getting in trouble themselves for paying brokers, which COULD be perceived as YSP or paying a broker through an infalted rate.
mbreston: (February 10, 2011 11:47am)
Bank can adjust rate also but can't pay originator less. Broker can still decide to earn less. Broker definately has advantage on this.
Utah Mortgage&Real Estate Guy: (February 10, 2011 11:46am)
The lender paid model. The lender can pay the broker directly (kind of YSP), and still be compliant with GFE 2010, Fed Rule, and RESPA. But the compensation CANNOT be based on an EXACT correlation to the closed loans. In all likelyhood, the mortgage brokers will be compensated Monthly or Quarterly, based on volume, quality of loans, lack of fallout, etc. So, the broker has a comp plan of 1.5% per loan with ABC Lender. At the end of the month, or the end of the quarter. ABC Lender can pay the mortgage broker for exceptional work over that time period for the closed loans. This way the compensation to the Broker has nothing to do with ONE SPECIFIC LOAN. That is the LOOPHOLE in the rule. Any wholesale lender can pay any wholesale broker anything they want. They just can't pay them specific to ONE PARTICULAR BORROWER or ONE PARTICULAR LOAN. So volume and quality over a period of time, a broker can still be compensated.
jacko: (February 10, 2011 11:43am)
I would like to point something out and would love others opinions. Right now there is so much talk about why it is better to bank - HOWEVER, as pointed out in the daily today, as a broker you will be able to have different options with different lenders. As a banker- you will only have one rate sheet - no matter how many investors or warehouse lines you have. This could make it very hard to be competative. I think all those who have bailed out of brokering in favor of banking may regret it come April 1st. More options is more money and easier to compete. I think the broker is going to win this one. What do you think?
jacko: (February 10, 2011 11:42am)
I would like to point something out and would love others opinions. Right now there is so much talk about why it is better to bank - HOWEVER, as pointed out in the daily today, as a broker you will be able to have different options with different lenders. As a banker- you will only have one rate sheet - no matter how many investors or warehouse lines you have. This could make it very hard to be competative. I think all those who have bailed out of brokering in favor of banking may regret it come April 1st. More options is more money and easier to compete. I think the broker is going to win this one. What do you think?
Utah Mortgage&Real Estate Guy: (February 10, 2011 11:39am)
Driven2n: I did read the newsflash from Wells Fargo. And yes the YSP compensation cannot exceed third party fees by $250 when using the LENDER PAID MODEL. You are correct, they will not let the YSP credit tot the borrwer exceed the $250 when the lender is paying the broker compensation. I cannot speak for Wells directly. I made two phone calls, to my rep and his manager with Wells, when I read this newsflash. Both said that this is only when using the LENDER PAID MODEL. Basically, they are not going to allow the borrower to use the YSP credit to PAY their ESCROW ACCOUNT charges at closing. So if third party fees are $3000 and escrow account and interest cahrges are $1200. The YSP credit can only go to the $3000 third party fees and $250 towards escrow and interest.
FinanceLogic: (February 10, 2011 11:38am)
@ Clulessdad: That's the debate, per Respa the lender can't pay the broker as that's deemed YSP. If you want to be compliant 4/1, and also with GFE 2010 then you have to be paid by the borrower... cash @ close or in the loan amount.
FinanceLogic: (February 10, 2011 11:35am)
@ Driven2n: YOu are correct!
Clulessdad: (February 10, 2011 11:35am)
On a lender paid comp loan, is Box 1 =$0? It should be $0 as this Box is for Borrower Paid comp only. Right?
justsomedad: (February 10, 2011 11:31am)
Utah Mortgage&Real Estate Guy: Just read the article you posted. Very informative. I especially love the new term for government wage control “compensation reform”.
Utah Mortgage&Real Estate Guy: (February 10, 2011 11:30am)
I guess another way to look at it. When the mortgage broker receives the compensation check from title the company. The charge in BOX 1 minus the lender fees included in Box 1 is exactly what the check will be for. The YSP does not affect this check. The YSP isn't even addressed in this check. Example. Check for $3500. Total Box 1 Compensation is $4390.95 minus $890.95 (underwriting-lender). The title check does not address the YSP because it has nothing to do with the mortgage brokers check. There could be $0 YSP or there could be $4000 in YSP. The Title check the broker receives for their compensation of origination for this loan is exactly the same no matter what the YSP is (if there is any YSP). If you want to see a copy of one of our checks, I will email it to you. It shows you that YSP is not addressed anywhere in the broker compensation.
Driven2n: (February 10, 2011 11:29am)
Utah... you stated that Wells Fargo was of similar opinion with 360. However, their latest newsflash had this to say about the excess YSP, "Any excess in premium price cannot exceed the amount of third-party fees by more than $250. If the total in premium price is more than $250 over third-party fees, then the broker will have to reduce the rate to the consumer. Third-party fees are fees that are not paid to the broker or the lender, such as the appraisal. Third-party fees do not include services that are included in your operating costs (such as processing) - even if you pay another company to complete that task on your behalf." I believe that your information through 360 is faulty.
FinanceLogic: (February 10, 2011 11:24am)
@Utah Mortgage&Real Estate Guy: I think the best thing to do is have you explain how an LO can be paid on a no closing cost loan (to your understanding). If a lender cannot compensate an LO, and they can't, then doesn't the LO fee HAVE to come from the borrower?
FinanceLogic: (February 10, 2011 11:21am)
@Utah Mortgage&Real Estate Guy: You are clear, BUT if your box 2 is equal to your box one you will not get paid. YSP cannot be used to pay LO origination effective 4/1/11. Clear?
Utah Mortgage&Real Estate Guy: (February 10, 2011 11:21am)
Finance Logic, When the YSP credit, Box 2, is bigger than the total closing costs and or Box 1, is irrelevant. Box 1 is being paid by the borrower. That is a charge to the borrower the same as an appraisal fee, the same as a title closing fee. So if the borrower chooses a PAR rate and pays all these fees. The borrower has now compensated the LO. When the BOX 2 charge is bigger than these fees. The compensation is STILL PAID BY THE BORROWER. The YSP credit does not pay the broker. To be fully compliant, the YSP cannot affect the compensation to the broker. It is not, because BOX 1 has NOT CHANGED.
FinanceLogic: (February 10, 2011 11:18am)
@free trade benefits consumers: "FinanceLogic, Tiers aside, I'm referring to the difference between lenders rates for the same compensation. Even if brokers have the same compensation from different lenders but the rates differ, and loans are place where rates are higher, the broker may not be 'steering' for higher compensation but is not acting in the best interest of the borrower would be out of compliance wit the law. No?" NO, you're compliant if you choose the lender with the lowest rate for the day of lock. Of course I plan to document my file with various lender rate sheets plus my compensation structure to prove I was not "steering" but acting in the borrower's best interst by giving them the lowest rate on the day of lock. Documentation will be KEY after 4/1. In case we are ever accused of steering, we need to prove how we didn't!
Utah Mortgage&Real Estate Guy: (February 10, 2011 11:18am)
This is the biggest misunderstood point. BOX 1 is the only compensation to a Mortgage Broker or Lender. Box 2, and any credit in this section does not HAVE ANYTHING TO DO WITH ME. Box 2 IS NOT COMPENSATION. How many times do I have to say it. Box 2 IS NOT COMPENSATION. Even under the FED RULE. No Matter what the credit is, the total dollar amount (if any) that is in BOX 2 HAS NOTHING TO DO WITH COMPENSATION to the Wholesae Broker and/or the Wholesale Lender. The credit in BOX 2 is SOLELY the BORROWERS. BOX 1 INCOME, BOX 2 BORROWERS. The FED RULE DOES NOT CHANGE THIS. BOX 1 is PAID by THE BORROWER. BOX 2 is a credit to the BORROWER from the LENDER for the chosen rate by the BORROWER. BOX 2, where the credit resides, IS NOT COMPENSATION. The BOX 2 dollar amount DOES NOT AFFECT COMPENSATION AND IS NOT considered compensation. Can I be more clear? Another way to look at it. Does the Aggregate Adjusmtent for a borrowers Escrow Accunt affect a LO compensation? No. Same Thing!!!
FinanceLogic: (February 10, 2011 11:12am)
@ Utah Mortgage&Real Estate Guy, I think you're still misunderstanding. What you just said is correct, but using GFE2010 on a 'no closing cost loan' meant that the YSP credit in box 2 covered all closing costs, even the origination charges in box one. Effective 4/1 that is not allowed as YSP CANNOT be used as compensation to an LO. So your box one will have to include our set fee, and not deducted in box 2, unless you want to do the loan for free. To be fully compliant with respa you HAVE to be paid by the borrower.
RID22: (February 10, 2011 11:11am)
Utah - Do you think 360 mortgage might have something to gain by slanting their interpretation of the rule in favor of the wholesale channel... Maybe you should consider a less biased source for your info, just a thought.
5pence: (February 10, 2011 11:10am)
Utah - great link, clear and precise. I like it. "If you're a broker, you might wonder why you should care about what happens to retail-originator compensation. Maybe you shouldn't. On the other hand, you might find it important to know that the Fed rule eliminates the last major benefit associated with working for a retail mortgage bank or federally regulated depository institution. After April 1, retail lenders that want to remain competitive must compensate their originators the same way wholesale lenders compensate brokers. This means the end of compensation and disclosure advantages for retail versus wholesale mortgage originators. Come April 1, many originators will have compelling reasons to leave the mortgage bank that has sheltered them from regulation and take steps toward larger compensation and more freedom in the wholesale market. This likely will increase the broker population and drive additional demand for wholesale mortgage products. As a result, we're likely to see a more competitive landscape and more-aggressive rates followed by a surge of new wholesale lenders.
Utah Mortgage&Real Estate Guy: (February 10, 2011 11:10am)
Those of you that are questioning the Mortgage Brokers comments on this issue. Here are the list of wholesale mortgage lenders that are moving forward exactly as Andrew Weiss-Malik, Cheif Operating Officer, 360 Mortgage Group, has interpreted. Security National Mortgage Company, Stearns Lending, 360 Mortgage Group, Wells Fargo-Wholesale, Franklin American, Bank of Ann Arbor, PRMG, Icon Residential, M&I Home Lending, Universal Wholesale Mortgage. These are ALL NATIONAL LEVEL WHOLESALE MORTGAGE COMPANIES. The GFE 2010 made Mortgage Brokers compliant with the FED Rule.
5pence: (February 10, 2011 11:01am)
In the survey 41% say they hate the new compensation and 20% say they're looking at bartending. Hey Frank and Brian, I'd be really curious to see how many here love the banks, hate the banks, tolerate the banks or want to see prosecutions. I mean, we are most affected by their takeover - I'd like to see how many that view here still love the banks with all their heart and soul and view them as kindly benefactors - still. Can you guys arrange that? I'm dying to know and I'm sure more than a few others are too. Thanks in advance? ~ Ed
Utah Mortgage&Real Estate Guy: (February 10, 2011 10:58am)
All of you talking about the Fed rule and RESPA as it refers to YSP. Box 1 of the GFE 2010 is the only income a brokers receives. Box 2 is the credit the borrower receives for the chosen rate. The YSP Credit HAS NOTHING TO DO WITH THE BROKER. I will say that the FED HAS NOT ADDRESSED THIS ISSUE, even the links you shown does not address the issue. YSP IS not compensation to the BROKER. I charge an origination Fee, and no matter if the borrower chooses PAR or a rate that has a YSP. My compensation DOES NOT change. In this instance the broker is not being compensated by product, not being compensated by interest rate, and not being compensated by the lender. These 3 rules are CLEAR as CLEAR. How can you guys be so obtuse?
5pence: (February 10, 2011 10:56am)
Are you guys seeing what's happening in Egypt? The PEOPLE are overthrowing their government! That should show us the power we have. If you want to overthrow the shackles of the banksters in their forced race to the bottom in fees for appraisers & brokers, we don't even need to show near their revolutionary spirit to get our way. They are en mass overthrowing a government, as peacefully as can be managed. En mass we could do the same, but we don't need en mass to overthrow the banksters grips on our lives & livelihoods. 200,000 people? 100,000? Would just 50,000 be enough? Could be! We don't know what we can acheive together until we try-and our government doesn't know what we need until we let them know! This quiet obesance to any new clearly bankster favorable rules and policies is vindication for them that what they are doing is right and they will continue to do so as long a there are no hoops and hollars! All that's needed for evil to triumph is for good men & women to do nothing.
Utah Mortgage&Real Estate Guy: (February 10, 2011 10:54am)
justsomedad, doitright, mbreston: As 'loansbylynch' posted 360 Mortgage Group is heading the wholesale industry in explaining the Fed rule and how it affects brokers. All of you that think the broker channel is OVER. Read this article, because it is exactly the opposite. http://www.scotsmanguide.com/default.asp?ID=4473 This new rule is going to force poeple out of the retail banking industry and back into the wholesale channel. Please do some research before you make such retarded statements as, "the mortgage brokers are dead." Read the article, read the article, read the article.
Clulessdad: (February 10, 2011 10:49am)
I agree that I am a dumb stupid ass. My wife tells me that all the time. LOL But I have made a living for almost 40 years now, and I will continue to make a living as long as there are more arrogant lo's and banks out there.
justsomedad: (February 10, 2011 10:43am)
Look, the GOV, the FED, and the TBTF banks have recognized that mortgage brokers deliver a superior product, at a significantly reduced cost. This is simply unacceptable.
doitright: (February 10, 2011 10:32am)
you are all using credit to borrower wrong under the new law the GFE will protect the borrower as it was meant to . Credit to the borrower will have to be just that ! Time to hang it up , not more fooling the consumer with a YSP credit to the borrower , it that is what it states it must go to the borrower .
mbreston: (February 10, 2011 10:28am)
Clulessdad, can you email me at [email protected] . I have a separate question I'd like to ask you.
justsomedad: (February 10, 2011 10:24am)
Aguadulce and Clulessdad: I’m not getting out of the business. What I am doing, is dominating your dumb stupid asses. The broker model is over.
Bryan/MortgageFinanceGroup: (February 10, 2011 10:22am)
This will only make the small loans more expensive. No way would any broker work on a $100K loan for a point rebate, and no way is a consumer in that market paying 2 points or more. So, they will just get forced to pay a higher rate/rebate, or simply be told to go somewhere else, because these loans are often more difficult to process/underwrite than the jumbo loans anyway. The jumbo market won't be affected because a 1 point rebate will still be worth doing. Way to go govt. regulators. Just like Vince Vaughn told Will Ferrell at the altar in Old School - "Way to think this through."
mbreston: (February 10, 2011 10:06am)
Loansbylynch read the prior post with link. Ask your compliance dept to read the post. The Fed's position appears to be very clear on this issue.
loansbylynch: (February 10, 2011 10:00am)
I am at Acct Exec at 360 Mortgage Group in Northern Calif. Have you heard of us or seen 360's policy on the Fed Rule? Our interpretation is that mortgage BROKERS are ALREADY in compliance with the Fed rule via 2010 GFEs. It is the mortgage BANKERS that will have trouble! Check us out at www.360mortgagegroup.com. Fed rule is right there on the home page. If you're in Nor Cal and want to get approved with 360, contact me at [email protected]
aguadulce: (February 10, 2011 9:57am)
to justsomedad below this post. You are retarded. This is one other bump in the road but nothing to cry about. Last years GFE stuff everyone thought would kill the brokers. I had my 2nd best year ever. This year will be no different.
mbreston: (February 10, 2011 9:56am)
My understanding is that we have Safe Harbor as long as we do not earn more with the investor to whom the customer has a higher rate. There could be other reasons to deliver to that investor like service, or liklihood that they will accept the appraisal etc., Also, even if we earned more delivering to that investor we could justify it, it just gets more complicated which is why it may be safest to define income as the same with all investors.
Clulessdad: (February 10, 2011 9:51am)
justsomedad-OK Before you leave the industry, go see what the banks are charging today for their deals and see if you can compete. I just compared my Provident rates with BofA and 3 others. I can make a good living, keeping my costs down, and give my borrowers a much better deal, better service and availability and years of education and experience. Until they say, you can never broker a loan, I can compete, because first and foremost, I am a businessman. Maybe a 7 figure salary wont happen. but I can pay my bills and put food on the table. See Ya!
free trade benefits consumers: (February 10, 2011 9:48am)
FinanceLogic, Tiers aside, I'm referring to the difference between lenders rates for the same compensation. Even if brokers have the same compensation from different lenders but the rates differ, and loans are place where rates are higher, the broker may not be 'steering' for higher compensation but is not acting in the best interest of the borrower would be out of compliance wit the law. No? If this is the case, logically the brokers agreements should be for the same compensation for the same rate from all lenders to prevent ‘steering’ and acusations that the broker did not act in the best interest of the borrower. This effectively eliminates competition and consumers lose the biggest benefit of using a broker. If this is 'acceptable' to the letter of the law, lenders will then compete based on other factors, like speed of closing or simplicity of process, rates will move higher to compensate for the added 'services' to get broker businedd and the consumer will pay more.
mbreston: (February 10, 2011 9:47am)
Utah. For confirmation that the Fed does not view ysp as paid to the customer per RESPA, see the final rule, http://edocket.access.gpo.gov/2010/pdf/2010-22161.pdf , see page 58525 (17th page of pdf) 3rd column, last 1/2 of of 3rd column: "The Board proposed in comment 36(d)(2)–2 to clarify that yield spread premiums, even if disclosed as ‘‘credits’’ in accordance with HUD’s Regulation X, which implements RESPA, are not considered compensation received by the loan originator directly from the consumer for purposes of this rule. Under Regulation X, a yield spread premium paid by a creditor to the loan originator may be characterized on the RESPA disclosures as a ‘‘credit’’ that will be applied to reduce the consumer’s total settlement charges, including origination fees. A mortgage broker trade association opposed the clarification in proposed comment 36(d)(2)–2 and urged the Board to treat yield spread premiums......"
Daggone: (February 10, 2011 9:45am)
Utah it appears you are beating the same old drum we've heard over the last year or so. YSP belongs to borrower, not lender, blah, blah, blah. Many of us banked on things not being different because of that and did nothing when the Feds were asking for input. Now we find out the whole YSP belonging to the borrower has no affect on how this comp plan is going to work.
Utah Mortgage&Real Estate Guy: (February 10, 2011 9:42am)
After so many posts: I thought everybody would like to read this article that was in Scotsman Guide. The contributor is the Chief Operating Officer from 360 Mortgage Group (wholesale lender). http://www.scotsmanguide.com/default.asp?ID=4473
Daggone: (February 10, 2011 9:41am)
Utah - if I'm reading this correctly, your one scenario says you are paying closing costs and yourself with YSP. My understanding is that you can't do that because you are getting paid by the lender and you cannot use that YSP to pay borrower's costs. That is what we are doing now and I don't think we can do that after 04/01. I don't know where you guys get borrowers who will pay your fee. I don't have a single borrower who is willing to pay me $XXX to do their loan out of their pocket. Again, I don't think it is the issue of the YSP belongs to him and he pays me. I think he has to pay me and I get no YSP in that case. As to third party fees, if you are paying an outside processing company, they show up under services they cannot shop for, just like the appraisal, as it has been explained to me. It is not paid to me, I don't get any of it, so it can still be charged.
justsomedad: (February 10, 2011 9:41am)
ATTENTION BROKERS: It’s over, you are finished. Period. End of Discussion.
Utah Mortgage&Real Estate Guy: (February 10, 2011 9:36am)
Clulessdad: According to GFE 2010, the YSP is the borrowers. The YSP is a CREDIT to the borrower, not a CHARGE. The borrower IS NOT paying for the YSP. There are no RESPA concerns. Obviously, you can argue that the borrower pays more over the life of the loan because of a chosen higher interest rate, but the CHOICE is still the borrowers. There is NO RESPA violation ro concern because the CONSUMER has the choice to choose which rate they want. If they choose to take a higher rate with a higher YSP credit, that is their choice. You cannot penalize a mortgage company for giving the borrower a choice, and when the borrower takes a higher rate, blame it on the mortgage broker/lender. The biggest confusion, it seems to me, is that people aren't understanding that the CONSUMER/CLIENT has the CHOICE. In practice, I have shown every client at a minimum of 4 interest rate/fee structure to choose from for OVER 10 years. The borrower has the choice to choose which plan works best for them.
Clulessdad: (February 10, 2011 9:31am)
You are right Utah. Most people haven't thought this thru and are listening to lawyers and their interpretations to what we do on a day to day basis. I see the biggest challenge with lender paid comp and conv vs FHA and how will we strategize the wholesalers we have with comp plans knowing that rates are different for each lender AND the fact that with overlays, not all lenders will qualify our clients. How will we need to document which lender will qualify our client with FICO's and the overlays? At that point, it is our opinion. Is that good enough to satisfy safe harbor?
mbreston: (February 10, 2011 9:30am)
Utah. The borrower cannot do a $0 cost unless it is a lender paid option. In the case of a customer paid option (eg the broker elects to get paid not according to their pre-determined comp plan with the lender and they go off the customer paid rate sheet), the ysp in a customer paid option cannot go towards paying the broker. There would have to at least be enough closing costs and prepaids paid by the customer to equal the broker comp. This is an area we need to go back to the Bureau and get relief on. Eg an exception to allow this. Per prior emails this is why we need to maintain a dialog with the regulators. There are clear areas where "band aids" will be good for consumers. In these cases we need to request fixes.
Utah Mortgage&Real Estate Guy: (February 10, 2011 9:28am)
Doitright: I am a mortgage broker, and 7 of my lenders requires a Mortgage Fee Disclosure that shows the client exactly what CAN be made by the Mortgage Broker Company in the trasnaction. I am approved with 16 (A paper) lenders. 7 of them require this disclosure with initial submission. It's called a "Mortgage Broker Fee Agreement". It discloses the Origination Charge (including any lender fees), it discloses the YSP credit that the borrower will receive for the chosen interest rate, and it shows the Loan Amount for which they applied for. Those 3 factors are all that is on the page. I am unsure if many of you are aware. The NMLS testing system, prelicensing education, and continuing education was created following the State of Utah's template. Utah has had these guidelines for Background Check, Finger Print, Testing, prelicensing Ed, continuing Ed, etc. since 2000. Basically the mortgage industry has just taken the Real Estate Industry model and adapted it to the mortgage.
Clulessdad: (February 10, 2011 9:25am)
I am surprised that the lawyers aren't saying that all YSP, per RESPA belongs to the borrower. That way the borrower pays all comp. And to be honest, that is correct. Borrower pays a higher rate for 30 years, it is indeed their YSP. This is really the basis for a lawsuit and the conflict with RESPA.
Utah Mortgage&Real Estate Guy: (February 10, 2011 9:21am)
For those of you that haven't done a NO COST loan with GFE 2010. The new Fed Rule does not affect the borrower compensation plan. Loan Amount $200,000; Closing Costs (hard costs) $3000, Origination (broker and lender) $4000. The borrower chooses that rate. Show the borrower 5 different interest rates, PAR all the way up to a rate where the YSP credit, to the borrower, covers ALL COSTS. This would mean that the borrower choose the rate that has a 3.5% (3.5% X $200,000 equals $7000) YSP credit. That covers all the costs and becomes a NO COST LOAN. The brokers compensation has not deviated and the borrower pays NO CLOSING COSTS. This type of loan is not affected by the Fed Rule or the Frank/Dodd act. It is in complete compliance with GFE 2010. I am amazed of how much confusion there is with this issue.
doitright: (February 10, 2011 9:20am)
What we need is one disclousure this is what the broker is being paid for this deal . that will end it and as you all say " IT will be better for the consumer" . Lets vote that a broker has to do this , a one line disclosure stating I will earn $XXXX on this transaction for a rate of XX% . Then we will see who beats who cares more for the consumer .
Clulessdad: (February 10, 2011 9:18am)
It would have been a lot easier had they said you can only make 3% or $3000, whichever is higher.
FinanceLogic: (February 10, 2011 9:16am)
As for using different lenders and earning differt compensation from each, I think maybe F&B meant 'in accordance with loan tiers.' For example, with lender A you may opt to earn 2.5% if the loan amount is $50k - $150k. At lender B you may opt for 2% if loan amount $151k to $250K. This is allowed under safe harbor since you're not steering but rather the lender & compensation is based on the loan amount (within that tier).
mbreston: (February 10, 2011 9:12am)
Lenders will have to offer a lender comp plan. There will be cases where it is necessary. Zero cost loans is one example. Another example is on large loans with no escrows where there are not enough 3rd party charges to absorb the lender credit for the rate the borrower wants. Also the Federal Reserve specifically said in their commentary to the Rule that for purposes of the Rule they do not define ysp as a payment to the consumer from which the consumer can pay the broker. Depending on the interpretation from the Fed on whether seller paid costs are considered customer paid or another third party, it could be required that on many transactions where there are seller paid costs the broker will need to go with the lender paid option. As such it appears that all wholesalers will need to offer the lender paid option.
Utah Mortgage&Real Estate Guy: (February 10, 2011 9:01am)
GFE 2010 Saved the Mortgage Broker industry. Washington and its ill informed regulators wanted to get rid of Yield Spread Premium. By making the YSP the BORROWER's CREDIT. It has nothing to do with us, the mortgage broker, anymore and everyone is happy. Provident Funding, Stearns Lending, Security National Mortgage Company, M&I Home Lending Solutions: I have received preliminary information from every one of these lenders and ALL of them are interpreting the same way. BORROWER PAID COMPENSATION TO THE LOAN OFFICER HASN"T CHANGED ONE BIT. Lender compensation plans, that is another story. I believe that there is so much confusion that some of these mid-major wholesalers are just going to shelve the Lender Comp plan (not use it). Some of these lenders will have to change their accounting::For instance: Provident Funding still shows the YSP as Broker Income, but it is simply an internal accounting issue so that Provident can 1099 that income to the Broker and they have a tax write-off
Kevin Jones: (February 10, 2011 8:49am)
Clulessdad, I agree with you (I think), I would never do Lender Comp plan. You are just asking for trouble. It is not the Fed compensation rule which prohibits different comp plans with different lenders, it is the Anti-Steering rule that in practice will prevent it. You cannot give the consumer a higher rate, if you can give him a lower rate at the same cost elsewhere. This is steering as defined by the Fed Rule
mbreston: (February 10, 2011 8:49am)
A couple of clarifications. Under current lender's interpretations, the seller can pay the broker's comp if they are paying all of it. Also seller paid costs become a non issue on lender paid comp it is only on the customer paid comp. Here is another sticky one if seller and customer are labeled as separate parties. On a VA loan where there is 1% origination and a processing fee - eg a non allowable. If seller and customer are different parties then seller can't pay the non allowable and lender can't pay the non allowable. Unless there is clarification which shows the seller is same party as customer we will be forced to use lender paid on VA loans where we are earning more than 1% (I think the limit is still 1% origination and no processing fee to the borrower if there is 1%).
RID22: (February 10, 2011 8:46am)
Financelogic - I don't understand why B&F are even wasting time talking about a comp plan that can't exist in the wholesale world. Since day 1 of this topic there videos have made me nuts, they talk as though RESPA doesn't exist. I take that back, there initial video about this actually said because the YSP is credited to the borrower the comp rule will have no effect on the LO... They were a little off on that statement, but I guess that's fair since this has been the most vague regulation to ever come about.
mbreston: (February 10, 2011 8:45am)
Here is a real challenge. Right now the lenders are interpreting seller paid costs for the buyer as a separate party paying costs. As such the seller cannot pay any of the broker comp. Well what happens if your deal was structured perfectly. The borrower was paying you $3,000. The lender's credit was $3,500 but there was $3,500 of third party costs and prepaids to be covered. Now, 2 weeks prior to closing there is an amendment where the seller is going to pay $1,500 of buyer costs. Big problem. However, there is a possibility there is going to be clarification on this specific issue whereby the Fed will clarify that for the purposes of who can pay the broker's comp, the seller and borrower are considered to be the same party. That would be very helpful. This is why we need to have a civil conversation with the regulators. There are going to be multiple issues where we either need clarifications now or where we will need "fixes" in future rules.
Mike8307: (February 10, 2011 8:42am)
This is what happens when people who have no clue about anything (politicians) get involved in things they don't know anything about. As a broker, our jobs is to get deals done. Using our compensation, YSP, SRP, or borrower paid pts, we were able to cover costs, reduce costs, lower the rate, affect the ratios, etc. do things that make the buyer comfortable and get the approval. This is the life of sales, without the flexibility our importance becomes diminished. And that is what they are really looking for here. We've now become check out clerks at the local supermarket, and will soon compensated as such.
mbreston: (February 10, 2011 8:41am)
There will be cases where even though we want to use the customer paid we cannot. It will be important to document these cases so that we can go back to the staff at the Bureau to see if we can get fixes. The true zero cost loan is one example. Another example is where a borrower wants a specific rate for which there is too much ysp/lender credit to absorb the other third party costs. This would probably not happen on small loans and will not happen on many larger loans where the borrower escrows. However, on large loans were the borrower does not escrow, then it is easy to have too high of a credit for the loan to work. For instance on a 400k loan if the third party costs and prepaid interest and prepaid insurance are only $3,000 and the lender credit is 1 point, that rate will not work. The problem is what if the borrower does not want the lower rate. Then you have to use the lender paid for the rate they want. See next post for something more complicated.
FinanceLogic: (February 10, 2011 8:41am)
@ free trade benefits consumers.... You are right. Very problematic!
free trade benefits consumers: (February 10, 2011 8:39am)
The most problematic aspect of the compensation ruling, which seems to be ignored, or at least hasn't been addressed adequately is that if brokers have varying compensation from lenders and place loans where compensation is higher along with a higher rate, the broker is out of compliance with the steering for higher compensation concept of the law. Logically the brokers agreements should be for the same compensation for the same rate from all lenders to prevent ‘steering’. This effectively eliminates competition and consumers lose the biggest benefit of using a broker. Further faulty 'logic' of the rule assumes; 1. All borrowers’ scenarios are the same requiring the same expertise and time. This is the reason so many borrowers are denied at banks and turn to brokers for their financing. Once this rule is implemented these borrowers will have no access to financing because LO's will turn to loans that are more aligned with their compensation. 2. All lenders pay the same
FinanceLogic: (February 10, 2011 8:36am)
Exactly my point RID22. You cannot do a no closing cost loan cuz it violates respa. The broker/LO MUST be paid directly from the borrower.. either cash @ close or included in the loan amount.
RID22: (February 10, 2011 8:34am)
What am I missing. Why isn't anyone addressing the RESPA YSP rule. On a wholesale transaction the YSP must be credited back to the borrower, an LO can't get the money unless they increase their upfront fees, wouldn't this negate the whole "no fee" scenario. On a wholesale transaction all compensation must be on the settlement statement(HUD1), so how can a no fee loan ever work in the wholesale world. I don't see HUD changing their RESPA rule because someother government entity didn't think through their new rule. If they did it wouldn't happen by April 1. I know the MBA posed this question to the Fed and hopefully it gets cleared up soon.
FinanceLogic: (February 10, 2011 8:33am)
@ Clueless if the rate is higher and that covers ALL closing costs, including our fee, then isn't that a violation of GFE. Under GFE2010 We're prohibited from earning anything from the lender. It seems to me that if you're compliant under one code then you're in violation under another.
Clulessdad: (February 10, 2011 8:28am)
The no cost option is not dead. Choose the lender paid option and give the borrower a higher rate to pay for the remaining 3rd party costs. You get paid, principal doesn't go up, all is legal.
Clulessdad: (February 10, 2011 8:25am)
As I understand it, processing fees, 3rd party or inhouse will all go away with the lender paid option. In this case, it becomes a cost burden on the broker, not the LO. The problem there is that most processors charge a flat fee, rather than on BPS. I haven't heard of one that allows a % to a broker plus a flat fee. Which is should to minimize the cost for higher loan amounts. Borrower gets screwed again.
FinanceLogic: (February 10, 2011 8:25am)
@ Clulessdad, I guess 5/3 interpretation is wrong. I've sat in on many webinars and most lender interpretation is that the broker fee cannot change (so no credits from us to borrowers, period), whether we're paid by the borrower or the lender (but lender cant really pay us either since YSP isn't ours). The no closing cost loan really is dead cuz no matter how you slice it the borrower has to pay our fee.
FinanceLogic: (February 10, 2011 8:18am)
@ Daggone, I use a 3rd party processing company. Their fee is always included in origination charges, with all lenders beccause the customer doesn't have the right to 'shop' for their own processor.
MortgageBiker: (February 10, 2011 8:17am)
We are fast approaching the stage of the ultimate inversion: the stage where the government is free to do anything it pleases, while the citizens may act only by permission; which is the stage of the darkest periods of human history, the stage of rule by brute force.
Clulessdad: (February 10, 2011 8:16am)
I agree with UtahMortgage-you would only use a lender comp plan on a no point no cost loan. Otherwise use the borrower paid and in safe harbor show the banks online rates-the borrower will see they are getting a better deal from you than the banks, regardless how much you are receiving in comp. Jeez people, remember why this rule is there, so the banks can charge everyone more in rate and fees. We will be able to compete, and probably make more this way. Go look at their online rates today and see what you can make.
Kevin Jones: (February 10, 2011 8:12am)
roy7, That is my point. Under the lender paid comp plan as Frank and Brian were speaking of Today. There solution cannot be done legally. If broker chooses the Lender paid option, the Rate the lender quotes you will be higher because they have to cover their cost to you. Take lender A. If par Rate today is 4.750% (0.000). If you ask the lender to pay you (1.000) your rate to the borrower will be 5.000% If you want (2.000) your rate to the borrower will be 5.250%. So let's assume that Lender B has the same pricing. Lets also assume the total lender fees to the borrower are $1,000 in both cases. You cannot give the borrower 5.25% with lender A when you could have for the same cost to borrower given him 5.000% with lender B. If you do, you will be in violation of the law and open to law suits and license revocation.
Clulessdad: (February 10, 2011 8:11am)
FinanceLogic-go look at 5/3rds Borrower paid comp plan-you can pay for borrowers costs-it is ly in the lender paid comp plans you cannot.
Clulessdad: (February 10, 2011 8:09am)
The rule does not limit a broker from having different comp plans for different lenders. And the spread from one wholesaler to another is sometimes a lot more than .375%. In some cases, it is 1 point or more. The pricing models at the wholesalers will be really in play. Think about it from their perspective-The costs to administer this will be enormous. How will they price in their admin/uw/fees? Again higher rates and costs to be borne by the consumer. Great work, the Fed!!!!!!
Daggone: (February 10, 2011 8:09am)
Kevin Jones, finance logic - if you pay a third party a processing fee, then you can charge that and it is not considered part of your income. It is a third party fee, just like an apprasial, but you cannot charge a processing fee for in house processing. My understanding.
cmoser: (February 10, 2011 8:04am)
Utah Mortgage&real Estate Guy: You're exactly right. When i looked over Fifth Third and SunTrust's compensation packages it was clearly evident to me that I will continue to use the Borrower Paid plan because it is what I'm doing now. However, the one difference in reading Fifth Third's compensation package is that those YSP credits can no longer be applied to the broker compensation, so no matter what, a broker's fee will be sticking out like a sore thumb and a "no cost" loan is a thing of the past. You are right though, why use a set lender paid compensation plan when you can completely control the rate and pricing as before with the borrower paid.
FinanceLogic: (February 10, 2011 8:02am)
@ Utah Mtg. You are inccorect. The Broker/LO CANNOT pay for LTV adjustments Nor can they pay any credits at closing. Doing either of those is deemed a "change in compensation" and is forbidden.
Utah Mortgage&Real Estate Guy: (February 10, 2011 7:56am)
Why is everyone discussing the LENDER PAID COMP PLAN. Who gives a *$&%. The BORROWER PAID COMP PLAN is exactly what brokers have been doing since the inception of GFE 2010. There are ZERO differences. Credit back to the borrower's for ANY REASON (even at closing, broker credit), still legal. Interest Rates adjust overnight and the loan is not locked, still the same thing (re-disclose, and take the waiting period). The appraisal comes in low and now there is an LTV Loan Level Price Adjustment (borrower or broker can pay for it). Why waste your time, get one or two lender comp plans and stick them in a drawer and let them get dusty. For thsoe that think MORTGAGE BROKERS are going away. These new rules just leveled the PLAYING FIELD. And there is NOT ONE BANK THAT COMPETE WITH A GOOD MORTGAGE BROKER's cost/interest rate structure. Now that all loans have to disclose YSP or potential SRP. The banks can't hide behind that vail anymore.
roy7: (February 10, 2011 7:51am)
Kevin, the numbers are just examples for clarity. If you want to call it .125, .25, and .375 that's fine. Obviously you can't expect one lender at 5.0 paying 1 and another lender at 5.0 paying 2.5.
Kevin Jones: (February 10, 2011 7:44am)
roy7, If you use the lender paid option (as Frank and Brian were using in the video) - The rates quoted by the lender will be adjusted to cover your lender paid fee. The Rate cannot change. So if you want (1.000) from lender A and Rate for is 5.00%. You want (1.500) from lender B the Rate would also have to be 5.00%. And if you want (2.500)from lender C the rate would have to be 5.00%. This is impossible to achieve. Most lenders are at most (.375) difference in pricing.
THE_DeeOH: (February 10, 2011 7:34am)
Brian and Frank...always love your shows and your input. HOWEVER...I 100% agree with Matt Perillie and DoItRight where you are wrong. A broker can not have multiple comp plans with multiple lenders. A broker MUST have one comp plan. Investors will mandate to see that comp plan prior to signing up the broker. Thus, making 1% with SunTrust, 2% with 5/3 etc. will not work.
FinanceLogic: (February 10, 2011 7:33am)
No, a processing fee is considered an origination charge. Their fee is subtracted from the LO fee. :-(
roy7: (February 10, 2011 7:33am)
Kevin Jones, if you have multiple lenders paying different amounts but the rate to the borrower is the same, you can choose the one that pays the most. That's not a violation, because the cost to borrower didn't change. This was specifically addressed at an MBA presentation I went to last month, by one of the people who was involved in making the legislation. However, he also did have the opinion you have to give the lowest rate if you want the safe harbor. So if 3 lenders are 5.0% paying different amounts, and one lender is 4.875% paying .125, you have to offer that 4.875%. He suggested cutting back on the number of wholesale lenders you are approved with if you don't want to be stuck with situations like that. It's a mess.
Kevin Jones: (February 10, 2011 7:32am)
Lefse2409, In the client paid option, I would not have any lender paid comp.(because I can't) however, YSP can be used for 3rd party fees, if using the client paid option, but YSP can not be used to pay broker fees.
FinanceLogic: (February 10, 2011 7:32am)
No, a processing fee is considered an origination charge. Their fee is subtracted from the LO fee. :-(
Kevin Jones: (February 10, 2011 7:29am)
Question: Can a third party processor be considered as a third party fee?
Lefse2409: (February 10, 2011 7:27am)
Kevin, that is not correct. Unfortunately, your info is not accurate. You cannot issue any credit back to the borrower, period, coming from your lender paid comp. If you are accepting the lender paid comp then you are bound to it. You cannot issue a credit coming from your comp for any part of the transaction. That said, what you CAN do is raise the rate above your par (with your lender paid comp included) and then the client receives that premium pricing. You can also offer a rate below your par requiring the client to pay discount. All along the price scale, either premium or discount, your lender comp is baked in and you cannot deviate from it or issue any kind of credit or pay for any fees. Does that make sense? You are halfway there and your logic is good, it's just still using the old method.
Utah Mortgage&Real Estate Guy: (February 10, 2011 7:26am)
USDA MAN; If for some reason you have to use the LenderPaid compensation model, then yes, you could have problems selling all those USDA loans. If you use the BORROWER Paid compensation plan. NOTHING HAS CHANGED. I REPEAT, the BORROWER PAID compensation plan is exactly what you are doing right now with GFE 2010.
FinanceLogic: (February 10, 2011 7:20am)
Scenario... rate is locked/LO commission set. The refi appraised value comes in low so now there's an LTV pricing adj. The LO isn't allowed to pay it (as I've done in the past). The borrower will be required to receive a new GFE & agree to the change circumstance, and agree to pay the LTV adjustment that I'm prohibited to pay for them. Also, in my state ALL closing costs cannot exceed 5% of the loan. I've routinely lowered my fee to allow for smaller loan sizes. The ruling will stop all small loans. In essence, a loan amount less than $115,000 will be impossible to obtain in the state of GA! What a great deal for John Consumer ay!?
mbreston: (February 10, 2011 7:14am)
It is also important to remember that the Fed Rule is only the 1st shoe to drop. Frank/Dodd gives the Bureau of Consumer Protection much more rule making authority than the Fed currently has. As such it is critical that we maintain as a profession a professional relationship with the regulators who will be writing the rules under Frank/Dodd. We are going to need kinks to be worked out and the way this will occur is through civil conversation - even if we are mad as "heck."
Daggone: (February 10, 2011 7:13am)
Steve0 You are so right! Clearly when they consider a broker the same as a L O, they are not taking into account all the overhead costs for the company. This comp plan is wrong, it is unconstitutional. I saw last evening that the finance committee is questioning the impact on small businesses. A glimmer of hope??? Not unless we make our feelings known by showing up in Washington. Yes, we can adapt,like we have before, yes I can get the same income all the time, but I can't give better pricing to get a deal for instance. We are taking it on the chin while Fed banks like Chase screw our servicemen fighting wars.
Kevin Jones: (February 10, 2011 7:12am)
The strategy I will follow is this... I will use the negotiated "cash" fee from the client - most of the time. I will use YSP as a credit to pay third party fees (as you cannot use YSP to pay your broker fees.) For those few times that we do no cost loans I will use the lender paid option. Let's say I want to make 2 points in a 0+1 scenario. I will charge 2 points. I will use YSP to credit 1 point back to the borrower toward 3rd party fees. This works as long as the 3rd party fees add up to more than 1 point. If I want to make 1.5 points on a 0+0 scenario I will charge 1.5 points and have YSP credits pay third party fees up to 1.5%. This works as long as there is 1.5% in third party fees.
Kevin Jones: (February 10, 2011 7:11am)
I do not understand where Frank and Brian are getting their information. The Anti-steering regulation clearly states that you cannot direct a loan based on compensation. Therefore you cannot have one lender paying .75% another paying 1% and another paying 2%. This is against the law. You can get away with it...for a while... the lenders will never know what agreements you have with others, nor will they care. They have no liability if you the originator break the law. However, "when" you get audited you will be found out and probably lose your license and be fined, or worse yet a borrower suspects you have done this and they class action sue you. You will lose everything you have ever worked for. DO NOT DO THIS!!! The strategy I will follow is this... I will use the negotiated "cash" fee from the client - most of the time. I will use YSP as a credit to pay third party fees (as you cannot use YSP to pay your broker fees.) For those few times that we do no cost loans I will use the len
cmoser: (February 10, 2011 7:08am)
Good show today. Thank you.
SteveB: (February 10, 2011 7:07am)
Certainly the consumer will pay. But we will as well. And how are they going to regulate this? Why is it that we are all having a hard time absorbing this new grand plan? Could be because it makes absolutely no sense. And why did it all start? Barney Frank- aka Barney Rubble. What an idiot. These politicians are so far removed from reality of business. I'd like to see if any of them could make it in our business. And we now have to smile and help our clients navigate this maze of confusion. We'll make it through this if we choose, but what a mess.!
Clulessdad: (February 10, 2011 7:07am)
BTW- LO comp plans are not limited to BPS per loan. A broker can pay an LO an hourly rate, of say $200/hr on a flexible work schedule. Time sheets to be submitted after the loan closes. Bonuses can also be paid to LO's.
mbreston: (February 10, 2011 7:05am)
I have never heard that a lock expiration is not a valid changed circumstance. My understanding is that it is. On the small loan size, that is dealt with using minimum income (eg with Wells it will be $2,200 for the lender paid and whatever the broker wants on the customer paid). The challenges with the rule will relate to technical issues related to when the broker wants to lower their costs and they are on the lender paid model (not allowed) and thus the key problem will be for customer paid scenarios that don't work. One of the customer paid scenarios that does not work is a true zero cost loan where the goal of the customer is truly 0 closing costs and 0 prepaids. In this scenario the broker will have to use the lender paid option and will not be able to reduce their income. It will be important for brokers to identify valid "business" problems with the Rule and to communicate those up through their NAMB chapter.
Clulessdad: (February 10, 2011 7:03am)
Steve0-O a small loan, you wouldn't use a lender paid comp. Use a borrower paid comp. EG $70,000 loan with $3000 of 3rd party costs. Find the rate with YSP =$3000. Charge the borrower $3000 in origination fees and you can use the YSP to pay the 3rd party costs. Net to the borrower is still $3000. You make $3000. You have a little explaining to do, but if you show what the big boys are getting for the same loan, you will still win.
Clulessdad: (February 10, 2011 6:56am)
doitright-rates are going up for sure, and it won't stop at 5.5%. That will mean fewer borrowers will qualify, and demand shrinking. Supply keeps going up with all the foreclosures. jobs are not being created fast enough (if at all) So prices logically will continue to fall until the cost of ownership is less than renting. But the brokers will still be able to compete and still get a piece of the pie. You have to have low overhead though. If you don't you are screwed.
Clulessdad: (February 10, 2011 6:51am)
roy7-It is about time the lenders eat the lock expiry costs. I have eaten them for 17 years now when their quoted 72 hour turntimes are actually 6-7 business days. The net effect will be that they will build it in a higher rate upfront. Another unintended consequence to the consumer.
doitright: (February 10, 2011 6:47am)
I have been telling everyone all along go back to my prior posts it is over for sure April 1 , now go get a real job and let housing prices tumble and bottom out as they should , another 20 to 30 % here we come
roy7: (February 10, 2011 6:38am)
Actually, our Suntrust rep told us if a closing is delayed and the lock expires, the lender has to absorb the cost. If they try to charge it to the borrower, the origition cost on the GFE goes up, but you can't raise the origination. Lock expiration isn't a "changed circumstance"...
deblakeley: (February 10, 2011 6:36am)
We received some of our lender compensation emails yesterday. Wow! What a screwed up mess our own government is creating. Damn them, damn them, damn them all who voted on this garbage. I hope Dodd and Frank both have houses full of Chinese drywall and formaldehyde insulation. These pinche' cabrons have contributed nothing to our world but sorrow and shame. May they all rot in CRA hell. I guess next time I write here, I'll write what I REALLY feel.
Steve0: (February 10, 2011 6:15am)
Think abou this, a $70,000 loan paying 2% to the broker. Nets the broker $1400.00. Now let's say you have an LO working for you, The LO recieves 1% compensation based on your agreement with the LO (personally I dont any LO that would work for less than 1%) Leaves you $700.00 from that pay your expenses, pay the employee's or LO's side of payroll taxes, pay your processor. You actually come out in the hole every time. You can not do enough volume to make up the loss, because at the end of the day, a loss is a loss is a loss. The only thing that can happen as your volume goes up is how much more you are going to loose. Personally I think this sucks, and I dont see anyway Brokering will be viable. I for one am glad that I held on to my Real Estate license. Guess it's looking like its time to re-activate and just go to that. I think I will let someone else beat their head against the wall for no money. Way to go you Federal F***ER$, there's 15 years down the tubes.
justsomedad: (February 10, 2011 6:13am)
Is it too early to start drinking?
Clulessdad: (February 10, 2011 6:10am)
Everyone has to remember the true reason for this rule. The TBTF's want to make more money on every transaction, and by decimating the broker ranks, they know that consumers will by nature go to them vs brokers. The rates at the TBTF's are going up. Look online for what they are charging today. Let the banks get greedy. We can compete against them.
Clulessdad: (February 10, 2011 5:57am)
MRUSDA-You can still do a no point no cost loan with the lender paid comp plan. Just use premium pricing to cover the 3rd party costs. You will still get your fees from the lender and the costs covered. In fact, the more you think about it, that may be the only time you would use lender paid comp. If I wanted to make 1 point on a deal, I would get the borrower to pay the 1 point and then give them a rate with YSP enough for the 1 point to pay some of his 3rd party costs. The math would work out the same. In regards to safe harbor, 3 options must be given. The lowest rate-not the lowest par rate-so 4.25% with 6 points. Lowest fees-no point no cost loan. lowest rate with no features-again it is a rate with 6 discount points. I am also going to show the TBTF and get online rates from BofA, Citi, Wells, and Chase. You should all look at them today. They are starting to really charge higher rates. I did yesterday and they all are at 5.125-5.25% with at least a 1 point fee.
Adam Miller: (February 10, 2011 5:48am)
I believe you are referring to Sun Trust with the two rates and they are being the most conservative. Here is another unintended consequence, what if the rate goes up an .125% overnight and the borrower did not lock but now wants to lock in at the lower rate. Because of the rule, the lo can not make the deal work with the current lender. The LO would have to resubmit to another lender OR the whole deal would go from a lender paid to borrower paid and the bottom line to the borrower will double because of an .125% in higher rates. The first scenario is illegal because now we are steering which is laugable. Sorry consumer, Dodd Frank was not written to protect you.
Scalise4: (February 10, 2011 5:41am)
So what is going to happen on those conventional loans where fannie/freddie has like 2.5% hits because of score, cash out, loan amount, no escrow... etc.. and you need to charge the customer up front for that and you still need to make some money out the back? What about FHA 203k loans where we can only make like 1 ysp and we need to charge one up front as well to make it worth while doing? or small loan amounts period?? Also.. we are not a broker, we are an actual lender that pays SRP.. will this even apply to us?
JustTheFacts:NoSpin: (February 10, 2011 5:37am)
The idea that a Broker needs to set up different compensation to get 1 point from lender, 2 points from another, 2.5 from yet another has destroyed the highest value a Broker brought to the consumer and that is the option to find the most appropriate Lender for each borrower unique situation including underwriting guidelines. Now a Broker will only be able to take borrower to one Lender for a 1 point program and if the borrower wants a 2 point program they will not be able to be taken to the Lender. I can assure you, Mortgage Bankers and Banks will be having a media campaign to educate consumers to the disadvantages a Mortgage Brokerage Company will be in under this new Mortgage Brokerage killing regulation. Unfortunately, TBWS has missed the boat on this game changer knocking Mortgage Brokerages out of the highest value they offered their clients.
mbreston: (February 10, 2011 5:33am)
I am curious to see if others have received legal advice on the Safe Harbor issue. The advice I have received is that it is safest to define our income at the same level with all investors. Otherwise, we could be required to justify why we locked a loan with an investor who paid us more when we could have given the customer a better rate with an investor who paid us less. There is not a prohibition on our earning more if the customer gets the same deal. The issue is if we choose an investor where we earn more and the customer gets a worse deal. If we define one investor as being the investor used only if we need to lower our income to "win" a deal, I think we risk not being able to justify why we did not deliver to that lender in all cases except for those in which the lender who paid us more also had a better deal for the customer.
doitright: (February 10, 2011 5:29am)
@mattperillie: I think you are on the money they are wrong . It can not be done that way plus the lender would be designing a system to get around a law and that opens up so many cans of worms . I think we all forgot about ECOA . What that means is you have the same offer upfront no matter what the applicant is. If they dont quailfy for your rate of that time frame you have other suggestions , but think of this . They get turned down at your 640 lender , now you try a 625 lender . Guess what you did?You broke the law, you took a case of no commission and put the borrower in a higher rate just so you could close it and get paid . SO you did increase your pay by loan type . This all goes so much deeper then we all think . And by the way Congress will not change their mind on this without some envelopes being handed out in a Georgetown pub if you know what I mean . The fact that the NMBA is going to DC means nothing with out the envelopes in hand.
JustTheFacts:NoSpin: (February 10, 2011 5:23am)
I do not believe you guys have interpreted a Broker's ability to to use lender paid credits to Borrower toward compensation as it has been on the new GFE. 53 clearly indicates this credit can not be paid to Mortgage Brokerage Company. What Investor(s) do you indicate allows for this credit to be paid to Mortgage Brokerage Company?
Steve0: (February 10, 2011 5:18am)
The area i'm in has been crushed with regard to value. Average loan amount is about 65k. So now if I choose a lender paid compensation of 2%, that's all the compensation I can get. Do the math, 2% on 65,000= 1300. I'm not going to beat my head against the wall for 45-60 days dealing with someone's financial issues, UW problems, lender problems, processing issues and then come out of it with 1300.00 bucks? NO THANK YOU! That bearly covers the cost per loan, or the actual cost of doing business. By the time I calculate, my rent, salaries, lights, phone, internet, and other ancillary expense I have now become a minimum wage employee of myself.Its realy nice that you painted a rosey picture, but the bottom line is this will forever change our industry as long as this is in place and change is not our friend. We all saw how well Obama's plans of Change worked out. You can keep the "Change" I'm not interested. Good luck with all this madness!
mattperillie: (February 10, 2011 5:11am)
I think you guys may be wrong about having a lender that pays .75, onr that pays 1, and one that pays 2 as a way of helping you be competitive. The final rule states that you can not steer a buyer to a loan based upon your income. This means that unless one lender is paying you 1 at 5% and the other is paying you 2 at 5% (UNLIKELY) you will end up giving the borrower the loan with the lowest fee to you.
justsomedad: (February 10, 2011 5:08am)
Welcome to the USSA. If you think big brother’s loan officer comp scheme is a screwed up, expensive, inefficient mess, just wait until you see what they can do for your health care!!!!
redsoxnation: (February 10, 2011 5:04am)
So the consumer gets screwed. Waiting for the other shoe to drop. Wholesalers are probably give rosy pictures now... but wait come April 1st they'll reveal the real deal...
Nuke 'em Until They Glow and Shoot them In the Dark: (February 10, 2011 4:56am)
Oh Cool. Screw the Consumer. Can't wait until Realtor comp caps comes that some lenders have started to impose. Bring it baby!
USDAman: (February 10, 2011 4:32am)
So the politicians screw the consumer again! I can live with the new compensation plans but I get a lot of my business by selling 100% USDA loans, and then using the YSP to cover most, if not all, of the closing costs, allowing my borrowers to purchase a new home with virtually no cash. Since I cant do it that way anymore, it hurts both the consumer and me! Way to go Frank & Dodd.