Fed Clarifies "Broker" Compensation - 02.15.11
Today's Poll: Will you go to DC and protest with NAMB?
A. Yes
B. Will Try
C. No
Rate this Program
free trade benefits consumers: (February 16, 2011 9:26am)
Never been to Washington. Might be a good time for a visit to see all the monuments that were erected in honor of the ideals of freedom and liberty that made this nation great at one time - I would imagine it would be tax deductable too!
5pence: (February 15, 2011 6:33pm)
I just ran across this, not too bad - check it out. We got the workin man blues : http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tslli4T_dag
philg: (February 15, 2011 5:38pm)
We simply need to go Egyptian! If we cannot make the Washington DC trip. We need to march infront of our state capital, congressman's office, or Federal Reserve branch. Come on Frank and Brian...you've got a big following. Let's get organized. Are we going to do something or continue to act like sheep? What do you need me to do??
Clulessdad: (February 15, 2011 5:05pm)
CMBARBOUR-With Borrower paid comp, you can charge points and give the borrower a YSP to their 3rd party costs, but not processing. Wells is saying that they can't give more than $250 back to the borrower in that option.
Owl Tree: (February 15, 2011 5:05pm)
We don't have a free market....it's a command economy.
cmbarbour: (February 15, 2011 4:25pm)
What happened to free enterprise? The way I understood the new law was that you could either charge our clients points or zero points (rebate), but not in between - which hurts the borrowers as you cannot give them the credit of a rebate on top of the point charged if that is the case when locking?
KT. Eckardt: (February 15, 2011 3:47pm)
Talk about the big few financial institutions the only ones left doing loans unless we march on Wshington--I would like to add that it's clearly becoming no different for realtors. Cashin Company on the San Francisco peninsula just got swallowed by Coldwell Banker. While some may think that's a good thing, those of us at Cashin were thrown under the same proverbial bus--with the same expectation of attrition that you mortgage guys/gals are getting with the Fed owning you guys as well. Independent contractors and their small business is the mainstay of this country and they're killing us. As 1099er's, we don't get to collect unemployment, yet we pay higher self-employment tax. Your march to Washington should protest the murder of small business--from mortgage lenders to realtors--and 1099 employees in this country. Companies are laying off W2 wage-earners to hire 1099ers with no benefits and no unemployment, where in reality, we who are 1099ers, pay more in and get nothing back.
Lefse2409: (February 15, 2011 3:04pm)
@Van: I am a one man shop, too. No, it is business as usual for you. You have it the best out of anyone. If you are like me, you probably already pay yourself a small salary. Depending on your tax status, you then pay distributions to yourself monthly, quarterly or annually. No issue for you, other than the compensation issue itself, prohibiting you from earning the YSP credit and client fees at the same time. In terms of the way you pay yourself, however, nothing changes. Does that make sense?
FinanceLogic: (February 15, 2011 2:43pm)
@Van: You get to keep all of your earnings if you're a broker/LO. As for the 65% not going to DC. I for one can't afford to go. Refi biz is all but dead and purchases are few and far between.
Van: (February 15, 2011 2:15pm)
I am a one person shop. Does that mean I can't pay myself anything?
Clulessdad: (February 15, 2011 2:12pm)
I just donated $200. All on this board should contribute.
Clulessdad: (February 15, 2011 2:09pm)
BTW-Marc Savitt just wrote a note that the NAIHP has not filed a lawsuit yet. But they are the best bet going forward for our industry. (Along with TBWS)Since it is not just brokers, but anybody in this industry, this would be the logical choice to join going forward. I know that many of us can't afford going to DC, but we can join and contribute $50 or 100 to NAIHP and our cause.
Notgoingtothebank!: (February 15, 2011 1:19pm)
Amen Edin! Who and when are we going to find out what we are doing on April 1.?
Edin: (February 15, 2011 12:55pm)
A comment re going to D.C. and membership with the NAMB. For some of us we are literally to the wall financially and it means keeping utilities on vs a membership. The membership is so important but it has to be on a back-burner for some of us. As far as a march on Washington it is ridiculous that they are not mentioning an alternative. People who cant afford to go to D.C. should be encouraged to go on the same day and picket and march in front of their Senator's and Congressman's offices. That is do-able for many and if it is handled correctly by the NAMB they could still get press for national and state marching. Also, the NAMB could make quarterly payments for membership to help people. I know some of the finest and most hard-working loan officers and they are struggling just to survive right now. They dont have the luxury to fly to D.C. even though they understand the urgency.
5pence: (February 15, 2011 12:38pm)
The too big to fails are parasites, they will NOT make a market that world wide investors would want to invest in, they'd rather keep the money flowing from taxpayers and keep the taxpayers on the hook as they privatize every profession associated with mortgages. It's a closed system, cartelized, so why should they care about taxpayers, consumers, appraisers, brokers, realtors - they can have it anyway they want as long as they control the process without any outside investors to answer to. No boss. The rules are made by them and for them to prosper and the money flowing is flowing to them without stipulations. I can't stand them. As long as they can keep taxpayers on the hook for their mortgage backed securities, they will. No one is looking over their shoulders and if the GSE's want buybacks for bad loans, it's pennies on the dollar. They are Parasites that will eventually devour the host as they grow ever larger and fatter.
mdeery: (February 15, 2011 12:24pm)
The Fed rule on compensation is a FU*&*^%%G mess because none of those monkeys in Washington even understand what is in this compensation bill..they did not read the Health Care bill or the Stimulus bill, or the Tarp bill when it came out. Its all a mess. The only journey to DC I will make will be when I am an old man, I will find the grave Bernanke is burried in and I will piss on it.
5pence: (February 15, 2011 12:18pm)
joecolorado : The only way things are going to change for appraisers and maybe brokers is when the banks have to make a real market for mortgage backed securities that isn't wholly taxpayer supported. Even though we taxpayers are their investors, they are making the rules- because they can. When real investors are catered too and this continued bailout of the banks through the GSE's ends, then it will be THOSE investors telling the banks how they want things done and in my opinion, they will not want banks owning appraisl management companies - it's too collusive for more easy money corruption by the banksters. Till then, even though we taxpayers are paying them and making the market, they get to write the rules and the rules only favor them and keep taxpayers on the hook while they perfect their corruptions that they can hopefully spread to the world - such is the way with unbridled greed and that is exactly what we have in these raised to demi-god status banks that are never to blame
5pence: (February 15, 2011 12:10pm)
OT: Common Sense: It appears at least 65% of the people here don't get it either. I'll consider it but I refuse to wear one of those stupid hats lol
Common Sense: (February 15, 2011 11:56am)
5pence, Sounds like an oxy-moron to me. After reading a little bit about the philosophy though, I think you'd fit right in. Most Tea Partiers are libertarians in my experience. The focus is on small government. We're not really interested in actually forming a third party, though, just in moving the current parties towards more accountability to the constitution and the oaths they all take to defend said. You should check it out. It might be a chance for you to make an actual impact. This is a waste of time. Almost no one here sees the big picture.
Common Sense: (February 15, 2011 11:56am)
5pence, Sounds like an oxy-moron to me. After reading a little bit about the philosophy though, I think you'd fit right in. Most Tea Partiers are libertarians in my experience. The focus is on small government. We're not really interested in actually forming a third party, though, just in moving the current parties towards more accountability to the constitution and the oaths they all take to defend said. You should check it out. It might be a chance for you to make an actual impact. This is a waste of time. Almost no one here sees the big picture.
joecolorado: (February 15, 2011 11:49am)
65% are not going to DC,there is no surprise.I went to a seminar for our appraisers group last night with a speaker from an amc.It was pretty obvious that although he stated his company did not screw appraisers and generally backed our plight,he was under no illusions about where the money was coming from to pay for his services and where his amc market is going.It looks as though our days are very severely numbered even more so than I thought.BUT he did state that he felt our pain as he once was a cert.resid appraiser himself and knows the problems we face.It made me want to jump out of my seat screaming hallelujah we are saved we are saved.amcs will be asking for more and more information as THE CLIENT DEMANDS More!!standards are to be upheld and those that dont comply will not be first in line to get work(but again he felt our pain)......hmmmmm where have I heard THAT one before? overall the message I got from him was that"its not our fault appraisers are getting screwed"we love you
Appraiser Mortgage Broker Real Estate Agent: (February 15, 2011 11:43am)
If you ever wondered how powerful the government is remember when there was the national disaster of "Katrina". It took the mighty USA government 3 days just to deliver a gallon of water. Osama Bin Laden? The mighty US government can’t even come close to finding one guy in a designated area. If the people stand up in at least the 100,000's the Gov can't do sh*t. And the military most likely wouldn't touch us. As judge Mills Lane says... "Let’s get it on!!!!!!"
5pence: (February 15, 2011 11:41am)
Off-topic, sorry, but I was directly addressed: Common sense : I'm not sure of the lingo because I don't like labels, but, how does progressive libertarian sound? Or, a Joe Fridayian - "Just the facts." The good I'm seeing about the tea party is that they've made their way into government as a 3rd party to be reconned with. To establish a 3rd party takes many years, so we should be grateful for that. We absolutely need a 3rd party since the democricans and republicrats are 2 sides of the same bad coin when it comes to furthering banker interests and corporate shilling.
ssfranny: (February 15, 2011 11:33am)
Njaramillo: have you ever made $!0,000 in commissions in a month??? NO ONE in the mortgage business is entitled to a hourly wage its a STRAIGHT COMMISION business like ALL OTHER SALES. Maybe a draw but no hourly wage this BS all came about when the wussy Wells LOs were whining abuot getting paid overtime for taking loan apps from existing customers. Heck the custodian cleaning the bank can take an app.
Evil Genius: (February 15, 2011 11:28am)
Thanks Mike, someone's listening and actually thinking about standing up and being seen and heard
Common Sense: (February 15, 2011 11:21am)
5pence, Are you sure you're not a Tea Partier?
joecolorado: (February 15, 2011 11:16am)
I charge $225 for a exterior only drive by,I dont do mountain drivebys' due to the difficulty of access, terrain and trees etc generally masking the buildings..HOWEVER, I charge a fee which I consider commensurate with my worth for that product I offer,so if $175 is not your worth then consider the discount you are giving away to the amc for employing you.The responsibilities do not change for you, just the hourly fee..
5pence: (February 15, 2011 11:14am)
This economic rationalization is the triumph of the cost-effective solutions over what is right and good for the people. It outsources jobs, and reduces independence in favor of cost-effective solutions... those "soutions" were seeing is the privatization of independent appraisers and brokers and soon realtors for the common good (cost-effective) of the banks and not the consumer or it's citizens. We are witnessing the fall of Democracy and National Sovereignty for Global Economic Integration and the will of cost-effective over human dignity. "Democracy, national sovereignty and global economic integration are mutually incompatible. It's possible to have any 2 but not all 3. It's the inescapable trilemma of a world economy" - Dani Rodrik
njaramillo: (February 15, 2011 11:13am)
At the end of the day, all loan officers are entitled to minimum wage of $7.25 per hr or $475 regardless if they made $10K commission the week before. If you're a small shop then you have to figure in $475 times 4 weeks per LO into your fixed cost period or become a one man shop. You can't hire LO's without some skin in the game. Unfortunately there are more bad shops that hire LOs and for hundreds of reasons they decided not to close your transaction, my favorite is "we're not making enough on the transaction" because making 2 pts or 2.5 pts isn't enough. It's Not the LO fault that the price went to the worst and you wont let them lock a week ago when they asked "should we lock this loan just in case?" The reason the country is in the shape its in is cause there are more bad then good shops and since they cant single out the bad ones we all have to pay the price. Since we dont rat out the bad ones, we're all going down with them!
5pence: (February 15, 2011 11:05am)
Inverted Totalitarianism : "Superpower has two main totalizing dynamics. The first, directed outward, finds its expression in the Global War on Terror and in the Bush Doctrine that Superpower has the right to launch preemptive wars. This amounts to Superpower seeing as illegitimate the attempt by any state to resist its domination. The second dynamic, directed inward, involves the subjection of the mass of the population to economic "rationalization", with continual "downsizing" and "outsourcing" of jobs abroad and dismantling of what remains of the welfare state created by U.S. Presidents Franklin D. Roosevelt's New Deal and Lyndon B. Johnson's Great Society. (Thus, neoliberalism is an integral component of inverted totalitarianism.) The state of insecurity in which this places the public serves the useful function of making people feel helpless, thus making it less likely that they will become politically active, and thus helping to maintain the first dynamic." Sound familiar?
Mike8307: (February 15, 2011 11:01am)
Evil.. as I said prior.. the Fed is an animal upon themselves. They answer to no one. Their power comes from their PERCEIVED power and not actual power. As Alcee Hastings, Congressman from Fl said, "All this talk about rules. We make them up as we go along." It is like the Wizard of OZ, we need to pull back the curtain and expose them for what they are.
loppy: (February 15, 2011 10:56am)
Folks. You have been living the middle class illusion. None of the apparent promises will be delivered. Just because you worked hard, followed the rules etc. you are still a challenge to the big banks and the gov't. They print the money, they make the rules. It was fun. You're toast if they want it that way. Sue the FED? Right.
jv03: (February 15, 2011 10:55am)
what are other appraisers getting for dbyes. amc's wont budge from 175 for dbyes, somebody must be doing them from moms basement. i'm in ohio.
Evil Genius: (February 15, 2011 10:53am)
Thomas Jefferson said in 1802: 'I believe that banking institutions are more dangerous to our liberties than standing armies. If the American people ever allow private banks to control the issue of their currency, first by inflation, then by deflation, the banks and corporations that will grow up around the banks will deprive the people of all property - until their children wake-up homeless on the continent their fathers conquered.'
WA_State: (February 15, 2011 10:46am)
Take some time to read the bill in question. LO's at banks win. You cannot take a shortage on your paycheck if you are short to close- last second lock extenion- not the LO paying any more. Bad news for the net branches and small brokers. You cant get paid on the profit of a loan- therefore you cant get paid on the profit of your branch. Specifically written into the bill is a provision that any attemps to cheat the system will be dealt with harshly. Why would you want to own a net branch if you cant get paid on the profit of the branch? If you could, you would simply charge the clients higher fees when there was room and wait to get paid on the profit versus the loan itself. You all believe it is the big banks that will win. It is not. It is the regional banks that arent buried by national compensations plans that may work in one region but not another.
Evil Genius: (February 15, 2011 10:31am)
When we scrape away all the shit, I just want to know who gave the Fed this power. They are not a government agency. Where in their by-laws or charter does it give them the right to do any or all that they've done? I am in the course of reading the Federal Reserve System Purposes and Functions and I'm gonna blow holes in all the power that we have allowed this renegade intity to have. I know it dates back and originates with the Rothschild's. But that's just it. They have given themselves the power, mostly because no one knows how to or has the balls th challenge them. I'll tell you that if the American Indian Tribal Nation was backing a lender with their money, we would be making loans with sovereign ideals. By the same token, if a mortgage investor is a private trust or entity, who will force the lender usingthose funds to play by the Fed's rules. I'm making that my personal challenge when New Generation Lending launches later this year. http://realestatemarbles.com/newgeneration
5pence: (February 15, 2011 10:27am)
Hey Frank and Brian, did you figure out a way for people to send your video to their reps without the blog comments yet? I know it would be appreciated by many here that do and don't post. Passion sometimes ride high in these posts, people are opinionated and it's doubtful they'd be well recieved and the excellent videos given their proper consideration, and action.
Utah Mortgage&Real Estate Guy: (February 15, 2011 10:24am)
Ultimately: using the IRS Tax Code as I have shown: any Loan Officer, can be hourly/salaried by the Mortgage Broker. And any compensation outside of the base pay can be directed to a Third Party which should (stress should) create enough of a corpoarte shelter from the FED RULE that would allow a Brokerage to pay it's Loan Officers in direct comparison of that Loan Officers Gross Income to the Brokerage. Really, if you are a loan officer and make over 62,500 per year in gross income; you should have a S-Corp or LLC in place for tax shelter purposes anyway. Basically the same way most Real Estate Agents pay themselves. Any money paid to Social Security now becomes a TAX WRITE OFF, and you can shelter some or most of the income from SS or Self Employment tax all together. Furthermore, your employer (mortgage brokerage) NO longer has to pay their 7.65% portion of SS on your behalf. The break even point for SS and Self Employment Tax is about $62,500.
rlittlefield: (February 15, 2011 10:22am)
The Fed is showing their hand. Their goal is to to get rid of the bank's competition.
Utah Mortgage&Real Estate Guy: (February 15, 2011 10:13am)
This issue stems from the IRS Tax Code (I am not sure of the exact Code #) of how 'Supervised Employees' and 'Independent Contractors' are compensated for their work. In 1953 the 'Supervised Employee' Tax Code went into effect that states (in short): any employee that is regulated by a license, can only use that license under the supervision of one entity (company of boss), has to be compensated as a W2 employee. By the way; Real Estate Agents were exempted from this IRS Tax Code (and still are exempt) when it was implemented (partly because more than half of the US Congress members had been an agent at some point in their job history). In 1959 the "Supervised Employee" Tax Code changed allowing the EMPLOYEE to direct his/her Employer to pay a portion or all of their compensation to a third party ENTITY. Obvioulsy over 50+ years there have been many guidelines, laws, or rules that have infringed on this tax code. But Utah has proven and justified their guidleines many times over.
5pence: (February 15, 2011 10:07am)
As long as you understand that the government is complicit in the bankster crimes by their support of fractional reserve banking and inflation of the money supply. I don't need to demonize the big banks, they are demon spawn and their amc's are their retarded inbred children.
Utah Mortgage&Real Estate Guy: (February 15, 2011 10:02am)
@JSR and FinanceLogic: Any entity (even mortgage lenders or mortgage brokers) CAN under the DOC and DRE pay a Third Party ENTITY any fee for any reason. Such as a Consulting Fee as long as it does not CREATE the Appearance of payment for REFERRAL OF SERVICES. IE: Loan Officer paying an Entity owned by a Real Estate Agent that could give the appearance the compensation was given because of a REFERRAL (client). Under that interpretation (I say that lightly because every person, city, state, county, etc. can interpret anything differently) that State of Utah has not just allowed this practice but ENCOURAGED it since 2003. While implementing and after implementation: the State of Utah has been taken to task to ensure their interpretation hasn't broken any other laws or regs. Every time they have had to prove something, the State has come out the victor. And this comp. rule has been repeatedly challenged for over 7 years. The IRS has backed everything the State has done with this issue.
Common Sense: (February 15, 2011 10:01am)
5pence, I'm not saying you're wrong, but you're wasting energy demonizing the big banks when it's the out-of-control government agencies that are enabling them.
doitright: (February 15, 2011 9:59am)
SSFrany you are wrong it is 65 % wont go but it is actully less then 50% of what we made before more like 25 % ! :)
5pence: (February 15, 2011 9:58am)
I guess they're all fat cats ssfranny and don't care about a 50% wage loss.
ssfranny: (February 15, 2011 9:55am)
wow truly astounding that 66% of people polled wont go to DC on March 14th. So that means that majority of people doing loans dont care that they will make about 50% less after 4/1?? What about any of you who arent a retail LO or one preson broker? You going to work for an hourly wage or salary and thats if your broker can afford to even do it. Guess it says everything and you better go find another career.
5pence: (February 15, 2011 9:49am)
I do have to take exception with your one comment Common Sense : "Quit blaming the big banks, they are just doing their job and trying to increase value to their shareholders while working within the system as it evolves." 1) The big banks are controlling these changes, writing legislation and lobbying to benefit themselves. 2) First of all they are to protect and promote financial stability in the markets and THEN reward shareholders. Theirs is a time-honored role, that of banker, and they are paid well to not destroy the financial systems - because they can. It's a position of trust and honor that they have betrayed and still do. They are there first of all to protect the financial system. When they betray that trust they are a detriment to society and need to be dissolved, CEO's arrested and trustworthy bankers installed to take their place and stabilize the financial markets. None of this has happened, thanks to Bubble Ben and the Fed.
doitright: (February 15, 2011 9:47am)
Here is the real tough part to work on the max total and this must include all compensation is now 3 % or 3 points . SO if you have fees of 1.50 % then that only leaves a max of 1.50 for all other pay to the company . Max gross revenues are capped at 3 % it is listed in the bill . Keep that in mind when you have other fees on the GFE
FinanceLogic: (February 15, 2011 9:39am)
@Utah Mortgage&Real Estate Guy: It's my understanding that lenders DO check who an LO is sponsored by, in the NMLS system. And LO compensation is payable to that sponsoring broker (solely). That income cannot be split with anyone else. So why dont LO's just get their broker licnese? It's easier to be an approved broker than it is to be an approved LO!
JSR: (February 15, 2011 9:35am)
Part 2: I also have to take issue with the person who appears to be from Utah; my state also, and probably many others, would not allow an MLO to have a separate corp, even s-corp, to accept payment for services. Believe me, I have been all over issues with the Department of Corporations. Here is a very important news-flash for you: The DOC and the DRE both have rules within their Finacial Code that prohibit an MLO from working from a remote site (home office/virtual office) if the parent company is a far distance from the MLO's home. In my case, the company was 190 miles from my home, which has never been an issue in the past, but with this new oversight, it is apparently a problem for them. I find it rather incredible that in this day and age the DOC and DRE do not recognize the concept of a Virtual Office. Some have escaped scrutiny because they filed last year, but if you change employers now and file an amended MU4 with the NMLS, the NMLS will notify DOC/DRE and u wil hv a problem
Lpassadori: (February 15, 2011 9:32am)
In addition to all the costs that these new rules have brought on to the clients, how many of you are dealing with per diem fee's. I just had a client that is a first time home buyer using down payment assistance pay $2500.00 at close of per diem fee's =0( how fair is that to the buyer?
Common Sense: (February 15, 2011 9:29am)
Wsonsma, Obviously we all need to learn to work within the system if we don't want to end up living under a bridge somewhere, but It's not an either/or situation. We can live within the system and fight to change it at the same time. We must fight, but at some point we must realize that it's not just Brokers and Community Bankers (like me) and appraisers, but our whole free market system that is under attack. Obama and his cronies are Marxists and if you don't know what that means, it's time you found out. It means no private property rights, redistribution of wealth from the movers and shakers to do-nothings, and most of all, centralized control of the economy. It's time to wake up. Quit blaming the big banks, they are just doing their job and trying to increase value to their shareholders while working within the system as it evolves.
Appraiser Mortgage Broker Real Estate Agent: (February 15, 2011 9:27am)
Die and give new opportunity to new generations. They would still have billions for their families for generation to come. Did you know before the banks failed they were asking the feds to let them buy and/or become real estate brokerage companies. Can you image what would have happened if they got that years before their failure. They already own several Appraisal Management Companies (AMC) and are in the process of buy them all up to control the appraisal industry almost 100%. Fight the good fight. Good luck.
Source1dan: (February 15, 2011 9:27am)
Our best and strongest advocate right now is NAIHP. Go to www.naihp.org and contribute money to the legal defense fund. The NAIHP is our best chance to beat this thing. Click on the "Stop the Fed Rule" link on the home page. Marching on Washington won't do a thing. They do not care!!! However a lawsuit (which has already been filed by NAIHP)can! It is our one and only chance. The Feds have overstepped there powers and can be challenged in court.
Appraiser Mortgage Broker Real Estate Agent: (February 15, 2011 9:26am)
The hardship should be better defined or direct at - not how cheap we can buy it and that we have only 2 or 3 choices, which is enough for the feds, but how it effects local economies and the opportunity individuals or, aka small business people, will have at a “piece of the pie”. That big corporations can’t continue to buy their competition or other companies in other industries. Because when one industry fails, like the banks, the other industries will fail too. It would be a “real insurance policy”. It would add protection from multiple collapses in multiple industries as well as giving opportunity to others to, at least, have a chance to buy companies at better prices, or creating new ones. It spreads the wealth and gives more choices. Should corporations really be considered individuals and protected under the Constitution as such? Do they really need to survive for centuries? Let the market weed them out if that company can’t keep up in their industry.
Appraiser Mortgage Broker Real Estate Agent: (February 15, 2011 9:25am)
Nice to see everyone up in arms about the big banks taking over the entire real estate industry and in case you didn’t know, the auto repair industry, which in the end insurance companies are the banks! The auto repair shops are also being controlled by contracts to do work at set fees or the insurance companies will not approve them for any work on any car for anyone that they insure. I have been telling people on this blog for a longtime that they are coming for you and real estate agent are next. Don't forget your second amendment rights. That’s your right to bear arms. That's BEAR ARMS - not the right to go to Wal-Mart and buy one. Do you think it’s time the government redefine the rules and regs of what a monopoly is or how big a company can get before it becomes a hardship on the American people.
Mike8307: (February 15, 2011 9:20am)
First of all... Everyone here needs to realize that the Federal Reserve is NOT the Government, nor even part of the Government. While they will tell you differently, the Federal Government really has no control over the Federal Reserve. It's decisions and actions DO NOT have to be ratified by Congress, nor signed off on by the POTUS. Therefore assuming that the Federal Reserve Board of Governors acts on behalf of the citizens of the United States is completely baseless and wrong. They act on behalf of themselves, the banks that are represented by the Federal Reserve. The congressional oversight of the Fed is nothing but a dog and pony show, as we have witnessed over the years. Even the disgraceful Alan Grayson (former Rep from FL) took them for task for having no clue as to where $trillions have gone to, yet they still to this day have no idea, or will not divulge to the public their internal dealings. What makes anyone think they'll act on behalf of brokers over the banks?
Utah Mortgage&Real Estate Guy: (February 15, 2011 9:19am)
@FinanceLogic: That is an interesting viewpoint. I guess I am going to have to address that issue with the state and request info from the IRS. Utah state guidelines ALLOW the Loan Officer to direct compensation to a Third Party of thier choice (IE: bonus, commission, etc.) over and above their hourly/salary rate. And the IRS tax codes have allowed Supervised Employees to direct compensation to a Third Party since 1959. Essentially, all Mortgage Brokers (except those that haven't been caught by the state of Utah yet) have been compensating their LO this way. Salary of $500 to $2000 per month, or applicable hourly rate; then any commission/bonus gets directed to a S Corp or LLC.
JSR: (February 15, 2011 9:19am)
There is still a lot of confusion over the language pertaining to MLO compensation. Many banks (read wholesale lenders) will interpret it differently, therefore changing the way we have been paid in the past. It still remains to be seen how all their legal heads will make their determinations. I noticed that about 10% of those polled today say they will be going to DC with NAMB...That would be 183 at that point in time, and as you read this, it may go higher. However, I was there last year, and the way the meetings are set up, the only reason to go is if you have registered with a respective "AMB" organization and will be visiting your Representatives or Senators. It is probably the last hurrah for our industry as we know it, and all the support available would be great, but there probably will not be thousands of MLO's and MLB's in attendance. Someone suggested teaming up with the Tea Party or some other larger entity, but our issues would be lost to the larger agenda of those types.
Wsonsma: (February 15, 2011 9:14am)
I truly enjoy these updates and appreciate the passion; it might be good to perhaps consider the "other side" and work within the system might be an approach that might gain better traction. The "other side" is going to listen to solutions not rhetoric. We know it appears to be really bad, we know it is going to affect compensation and we know the "big banks" are smiling all the way to the bank but it is now when we must work smarter, work within the system, and provide service that will be a benefit to our clients; we know the "big banks" cannot compete with our service, knowledge and understanding. Sorry the cup is half full.
Appraiser Mortgage Broker Real Estate Agent: (February 15, 2011 9:14am)
Nice to see everyone up in arms about the big banks taking over the entire real estate industry and in case you didn’t know, the auto repair industry, which in the end insurance companies are the banks! The auto repair shops are also being controlled by contracts to do work at set fees or the insurance companies will not approve them for any work on any car for anyone that they insure. I have been telling people on this blog for a longtime that they are coming for you and real estate agent are next. Don't forget your second amendment rights. That’s your right to bear arms. That's BEAR ARMS - not the right to go to Wal-Mart and buy one. Do you think it’s time the government redefine the rules and regs of what a monopoly is or how big a company can get before it becomes a hardship on the American people.
Utah Mortgage&Real Estate Guy: (February 15, 2011 9:09am)
Apparently I Didn't Listen to Frank & Brian at the start of their video today. Brian states, that "LO's and BROKERAGE SHOPS will not be able to receive compensation based on the loan amount if the comsumer wants to pay lower fees and receive a lower interest rate." Frank,"IN THIS SCENARIO, the Loan Officer will have to be paid either Salary or Hourly, for the work on the transaction."Frank and Brian: Which is it? Can the Brokerage Shop still receive comp based on the loan amount? Or is it just the LO that CANNOT be paid based on the loan amount? Either the delivery of the information is skewed or the Actual Interpretation DOESN'T HOLD WATER. EX: Quote $2000 in Origination and a 4.875% Rate. Then the client wants to only pay $1500 and get 4.75%. Brian states that neither the Brokerage Shop or the LO can be compensated on the Loan Amount. Frank states just the LO CANNOT be compensated on the LA. Which is it guys? Is this interpretation only on a loan where the client wants to pay less
5pence: (February 15, 2011 9:08am)
EricO: And the states are getting ripped off. I've tried discussing that with my state AG and they don't seem concerned!!?? Huge amounts of money are being funneled out of edge of bankruptcy states and no one cares? I mean the whole thing is illegal and the AG's should be the first lines of defense for the states! It has me concerned that the state AG's are now bargaining with the banksters over fraudclosures and what kind of "deal" they'll make. Hawaii now has halted foreclosures for 5 months ! That's great, but if the AG's don't do their jobs and put the banksters in jail for destroying proerty rights, who will? No one. The reason the banks got so sloppy is because through securitization THEY ALREADY GOT PAID FOR THE MORTGAGE! Now they want to double down and get the house too. Call your state AG's and pull your money out of the TBTF's and invest in local banks that invest in the community.
Bono Vox: (February 15, 2011 9:05am)
Searcing for the good news in all of this......eventually, Fannie, Freddie, FHA will be so expensive that private sector will take over and our tax dollars will be safer?
5pence: (February 15, 2011 8:59am)
65% said they won't go march in Wa. to save their careers. You guys are as bad as appraisers. Some good points have been made however, marching to Washington without knowing the full facts of what's going to happen might just make us end up looking foolish and that's the last thing we need. We need a rock solid indisputable reason to protest and since these rules are pending and we don't know the unintended or intended consequences, for sure, yet - maybe that's why the high percentage of No's to the poll. But, we all sense it's not going to be good. Some are talking about getting paid per hour. Well, that fits into the Guild and Union scenario - either hourly pay or percentage like NAR has it. Doitright has the right idea about a Union, but a Union will never work - there is no picket line to cross, just like with appraisers. A Guild, like the NAR, could-the sacrifice with either a Union or Guild is that wages have to be set for all. I don't like it, but if they're high enough I could.
Common Sense: (February 15, 2011 8:59am)
EricO, It's not good for America!
EricO: (February 15, 2011 8:54am)
aprzal Brian and Frank were not talking about your compensation, I haven't received a dime more for all the extra work that is now required 1004MC, extra sold comps, one active and one under agreement comps. Arial views, charts and more. My compensation has been reduced per report by an average of $100.00. What B&F were talking about was the doubling of the fee the consumer pays when they apply for the loan they are told the appraisal fee is X. My fee used to be $350.00 per appraisal now the consumer is paying at least $450.00 and in most cases $500.00 and above, the appraiser gets $225-$250 for that report. In Masachusetts this has cost Appraisers 27 million dollars out of the 1,200 appraiser's pockets and the consumers have been ripped off to the tune of $40 million dollars. This whole situation is not good for appraisers or consumers.
FinanceLogic: (February 15, 2011 8:51am)
@Utah Mortgage&Real Estate Guy: Your LO Company idea would not work in my state. Here the LO's corp would have to have their own broker license and their LO's be listed as their employees in NMLS. In doing that ALL the compensation would be payable to them as they would be their own licnesed broker. Their original employer would no longer have LO's as employees and all compensation would go directly to the LO (and cannot be split with any other LO). So even then the LO corp is ineffective cuz you still can't split commission. This ruling ends all the broker shops and will cause each LO to be individually licensed as a broker. An LO who is a licensed broker can keep all their commission. They cannot split their fee with a processor or anyone else.
Maxman: (February 15, 2011 8:51am)
doitright, yes it's for real. Same name and address for his shop.
Maxman: (February 15, 2011 8:50am)
doitright, yes it's for real. Same name and address for his shop.
Sandie: (February 15, 2011 8:49am)
I just wish I could figure out exactly what the Fed is really attempting to do here. Other than make it harder and harder for the consumer to buy real estate I can't see where they are accomplishing much except prolonging the economic recovery. Does anyone beside me see where this is headed? The Banks have tried and tried to take over the Real Estate Industry and if they can price everyone out of the game and put all the Real Estate Professionals out of business they will get their wish. One more step toward the Government controlling every aspect of our lives. Please 2012 can't come soon enough!
Common Sense: (February 15, 2011 8:46am)
I quit posting here some time back because I was disgusted with you broker's support for the Frank-Dodd Bill because of the possibility of it's eliminating the HVCC,and all of the reveling over the damage the bill would do to banks. If any of you recall, I said we are all in this together and it's our industry that is under attack. The government is out of control and if you think you are going to get a big enough crowd to Washington to make a difference, you're dreaming. The Tea Parties have put together a monstrous coalition of people from all walks of life that are sick of high taxes and government interference in the free markets as well as our daily lives. Do you get it yet? By banding together with others we can have a voice. Seperately, we are wasting our time. The focus must be on the burden being placed on the public, the common guy trying to buy a house, not how hard your job has become.
Utah Mortgage&Real Estate Guy: (February 15, 2011 8:42am)
Broker LO cannot get paid on a percentage basis per loan. This language is ambiguous at best. The term is the LO cannot be paid on a percentage basis. That doesn't mean the BROKERAGE can't be PAID ON A PERCENTAGE BASIS. The BROKERAGE can then pass on EVERY PENNY OF INCOME IN A FORM OF MONTHLY BONUS, WEEKLY BONUS, BEFORE NOON BONUS, SHOWING UP TO WORK AFTER HANGOVER BONUS, ETC, ETC, ETC, ETC, ETC. Furthermore, there is no PERCENTAGE BASIS even on the Good Faith Estimate. Origination shows as a total dollar amount in Box A. So from a real simple standpoint. Current LAW LANGUAGE: PLAIN LANGUAGE or SIMPLE ENGLISH. The sentence that everybody is addressing: Loan Officer cannot get paid on a percentage basis. Is irrelevant and ambiguous!! Then again, all you LO's should have your brokerages paying the majority of your income to an LLC or Corporation anyway.
doitright: (February 15, 2011 8:39am)
I think you may be right I found this online wow what a twist?? Look below do a google in him , Is this for real ? Maybe the same name as Mike from NAMB ? Does anyone know this answer ? Philadelphia Branch Cole Taylor Bank 1126 Horsham Road, Suite D Maple Glen, PA 19220 Mike D'Alonzo 215-657-9600
Notgoingtothebank!: (February 15, 2011 8:30am)
Whats going on??? Last week I heard the loan officer's at the banks we running to open up BROKER shops!!
Maxman: (February 15, 2011 8:28am)
No not when the President of NAMB is now a retail shop. Mike D'Alonzo is a retail branch for Cole Taylor.
Utah Mortgage&Real Estate Guy: (February 15, 2011 8:28am)
Comp CONT... It doesn't matter that the employee that should be compensated, is the owner of the LLC or Corp. The Loan Officer's Corporations receives the majority of the compensation earned by the LO over the year. The Mortgage Broker gives a W2 to the LO and a 1099 to the LO's company. By removing the person and replacing it with an ENTITY. The compensation rule regarding an LO being paid a percentage of the loan amount is tossed right out the window. Because the company makes the percentage. Keyword: COMPANY or LLC, Corporation, etc, etc, etc. There is one other thing that this NEW (supposedly) interpretation doesn't address that will allow loan officers to still get paid what they want.
JJ320: (February 15, 2011 8:27am)
I have been a mortgage broker for 25+ years, the last 3 of them switched into Real Estate because of all the changes. At one time I was doing 30-40 loans per month, all fixed rate "A" paper. I did get NMLS, however, what a waste of money. Why should I renew and pay fees next year if I have no loan business. I don't see it getting any better. I am not sure about going to DC, but I would be up for going to Sacramento and giving "Jerry" a visit. With budget deficits, he should be concerned if we don't renew our licensing fees. Pretty soon we will only have large companies and the rest of us will be beggers. Politicians either don't have a clue what they are doing or are allowing special interests/big banks to slowly kill our industry with rules no one can understand..either way, Shame on them! I want to know since I am licensed why I don't get notified in advance when changes are proposed that affect my license? Seems reasonable that I should be able to voice my opinion.
Utah Mortgage&Real Estate Guy: (February 15, 2011 8:23am)
Everybody hold on: this might sound like doom and gloom, but it really doesn't change too much for the mortgage broker with multiple loan officers. There is a STATE that required ALL loan officers to be compensated by W2 more than 7 years ago (FHA, Conventional, VA, everything.). Under the IRS Supervised Employee Tax Code: a loan officer that can only have their license with one company is considered a 'supervised employee.'This employee MUST be W2'd.This TAX CODE has been in effect since 1953.Now dealing with a commission check, that would result in the loan officer being directly compensated by a percentage of the loan amount.First, every loan officer that works for a broker will start making $8 per hour (paid at 20 or 30 hours a week) or a monthly salary for $1000 per month. Then at the behest of the employee: any other compensation such as commission, bonus, overtime (whatever the hell the broker wants to call it) IS PAID TO A THIRD PARTY SUCH AS A LLC, S CORPORATION, ETC. cont.
doitright: (February 15, 2011 8:18am)
Taking a real poll here state how you are going to be paid on April 1 new deals for laon officers . All of us should know by now if now that is a bad sign! Example I am getting 1.25 % on all deals no matter what the loan amt . Now how about the rest of us , lets see how this is panning out for all thanks
mark: (February 15, 2011 8:15am)
National Mortgage News (02/14/11) Vol. 35, No. 20, P. 1 Muolo, Paul The National Association of Independent Housing Professionals has filed suit to block the Federal Reserve's loan officer compensation rule, which would prevent regulation payments to loan officers from being based on interest rates or other terms as well as ban compensation payments from borrowers and lenders on the same transaction. NAIHP says the rule will put brokers out of business and narrow borrowers' choices. Both it and the Mortgage Bankers Association want the rule clarified in writing, but the Fed has not responded.
Rollo Tomasi: (February 15, 2011 8:09am)
Matty Ice, I'm a Republican too! But not a choke artist like you. Airy Roge is a cooler customer and slaying the Hokies is no annointment. Any Demo-Lib who pimp slapped themselves out of a job is well worthy of reaping what was sewn.
Rollo Tomasi: (February 15, 2011 8:04am)
I was wondering how people will feel if the SBA can really stall this thing?
JUSTFRANK101: (February 15, 2011 7:59am)
The PLAN from the beginning was for BIG BANKS to eliminate their competition. They have all the money; they have all the Federal Support. No more independent Appraisers, Loan Brokers, Loan Agents, Loan Officers, Real Estate Agents, Real Estate Brokers. Unless you are employed by a Bank and paid a salary, you will not be in the Housing Market Business. Next is a 3.8% Tax on Sold Properties be them commercial or residential. The Banks are the only ones that will be able to offer a property loan – all FEES included and NO ONE will ever really know what they are they will just think they are getting the best deal. Now join a coalition, union or association fight, fight, fight but in the end that is the best, you can expect, getting it in the end.
doitright: (February 15, 2011 7:55am)
I think the route of it all is we should be one Brokers and Banker Loan officers . If power in numbers works there are 360000 plus loan officers if you include brokers , or 100,000 plus brokers and 260,000 correspondent and bank employed loan officers . Why do we argue and not work as one ? It makes no sence , we all want to be able to control our own rate of pay. How many of you would back someone that has a union just for loan officers , that means from your basement to the top floor of a skyscraper office , the cost would be around 5 bucks a year each . Then I can put a memo out on April first , no one is allowed to write a deal until they new rules are changed . This is the only way it will work , we have to stop it in its tracks . [email protected] afer we clear this situation up we can take a vote on the next set of actions that need to take place. We need to truly become one nothing else will work .
mortgagesbyken: (February 15, 2011 7:46am)
Oh, and MI is going up again by 25bps in April on FHA Deals. Does anyone have ANY REAL positive news for loan officers????
Matty Ice: (February 15, 2011 7:23am)
I won't believe anybody's interpretation of all of this until after rules have been inacted for 30 days with the wholesalers - usually all these interpretations are wrong anyways. What I do know is all you mortgage guys that voted democrat in the 2008 elections because you wanted to feel good about yourselves for various reasons - well, you just lost control of your industry and my industry as well. While Republicans are not without sin, Dems want to control every part of the human experience - and they are on the verge of wiping out the mortgage brokers and our ability to make a living. So.....enjoy!
kafprocessing: (February 15, 2011 7:15am)
Isn't it ironic the banks and Wall Street firms who caused this mess benefit from the changes and reforms enacted? I bet a poll would show the majority of people blame LO's folowed closely by "People who took mortgages they KNEW they could not pay". Congress and the Fed have passed regulations which the big banks circumvent with different fees. The worst collusion between the banks and the legislators they lobby ($$$) was the mark-to-market change. That alone has distorted the situation (banks claim the full value of an asset until sold, e.g. FL condo was $500k now $200k counts as $500k until sold). There are still 50,000 houses in Palm Beach County in some stage of foreclosure. 60% of properties in the State are under water and because of mark-to-market, they banks are sitting on the huge shadow inventory. So, the solution for the big banks? Eliminate the competition (LO's) and drive up their compensation. They have even thrown the local and regional banks under the bus
proceedwithcaution: (February 15, 2011 7:02am)
I am looking for confirmation. Confirmation that this broker compensation is for those LOs that work for the broker, not the actual broker him/herself. My understanding from speaking with my United Wholesale rep is that only the one man broker shop like me will be the only broker shops left as those brokers with LOs who won't be able to meet the Fed Rule regarding the hourly or salary for their LOs will have to get rid of those working for him/her. Like everyone else, I am looking for clarification of all this. Thanks.
doitright: (February 15, 2011 6:45am)
Best way to stay positive is get out of this crap business and anything tied into it . Buy BOA , CITI, JP, and Wells stock , they will rule the market thanks all of you not joining the NLO Union National Loan Officers Union , think back when this was recommended you all laughed , well now look ! [email protected]
Fundem: (February 15, 2011 6:45am)
Too little, too late- campaign finance reform now- it's over brokers- see you at Wells.
fledermaus: (February 15, 2011 6:39am)
mbreston- I agree. the 1st post of today, (the 1st post there is today), is right on. We can all re-hash it here, but it doesn't matter to the people that are in positions to do anything about the legislation. CLEARLY we NEED this FED rule delayed, then killed. All other matters are 2ndary to all of us. I am a Real Estate Broker too and will move more of my business back over to that from MTG Brokering as the writing is on the wall... But RE is going to suck too when loans are getting harder and harder. Who is going to want to do a borderline loan in the $100-200K ? No one. What is the average home selling for? OH not much above that... Let's stay positive but we really do have to act now...
HVCCSICK: (February 15, 2011 6:29am)
Jim, Good point. Take out the appraisers, take out the mortgage brokers and then take out the tilte companys, because many of them have lawyers attached. And once they do that, there is nothing that will stand in their way.
TD Hawk: (February 15, 2011 6:29am)
I'm afraid consumers will soon get mortgages at ATMs. The product choices will be so few and rates pretty much take it or leave it that robots will be able to originate.
HVCCSICK: (February 15, 2011 6:26am)
FHFA Posts Discussion Documents on Mortgage Servicing Compensation Initiative http://www.fhfa.gov/webfiles/19720/MortServPR21511.pdf Hey Mortgage Brokers. It's better to get in on the discussion before they make the decisions, than to be standing around the streets of Washington in the slush trying to figure out why they don't listen to you.
Jim Moody: (February 15, 2011 6:16am)
As an independent Title Insurance agent I have to say this will just kill us! If the only folks doing loans are going to be the big four, guess where the title and escrow referrals are gonna go? Their affiliated settlement businesses. And that, too, is yet another way to screw the consumer.
Chukster: (February 15, 2011 5:21am)
Looks like the mortgage industry is joining the appraisers. I suggest you start a union, like the appraiser's have started to do.
John S.: (February 15, 2011 5:18am)
Brian & Frank, If your assesment is correct and the only players standing will be the "Big Banks", then it is imperative that both of you attend the NAMB march on DC. Your voices are heard mostly by brokers and we appreciate your efforts. However, if we are "toast" then your audience is far less and the likes of UWM (United Wholesale Mortgage)are no longer supporting TBWS. Hope to see you there.
aprzal: (February 15, 2011 5:10am)
Loan officers have always been paid a lot more than appraisers. And as for your comment about HVCC, "doubling or tripling appraisal fees." Well that is BS as far as the appraisal fee "I" get. My fees have only gone up $25 for the additional HVCC form. If that is the case, then WHO is getting the doubling and tripling MONEY???
VELSHIRLEY: (February 15, 2011 5:08am)
Namb video on LO compensation http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rSKKGkaRQzI&feature=email
doitright: (February 15, 2011 4:29am)
@FLappraiser What is with the chip on your shoulders . What jealous of loan officers ? We did not make the HVACC rule . Lighten up HVACC is a pain in the XXX to loan officers so lay off . The beast one was TBWSIAI Think big work small in another industry ! LOL
mbreston: (February 15, 2011 4:20am)
My interpretation of what Frank and Brian were advocating was that brokers need to have the flexibility to reduce their income on larger transactions as most of us do now. The issue is not that we want to be paid the same % on each transaction. We want to use the customer paid model which is the most transparent to the customer. The problem discussed on the video today is that to use the customer based model we may be required to pay loan officers on a salary or hourly-based system. This is not economically feasible. There is no extra revenue to pay a loan officer if that loan officer does not produce. Thus the issue is that we need a mechanism to earn less on larger transactions and we do not currently have an effective mechanism with the Rule. There are minimums and caps but these also do not provide the flexibility needed to compete.
USofDumbamerica: (February 15, 2011 4:05am)
Yup...appraisers misery loves company and now we got it. Hey, its not all bad. Just start getting used to buying those ramen noodles (12 for $2) and teach your kids that THREE meals a day are not really necessary. Oh..and just WAIT for the commentary to be released well after the industry hemmorages further about "unintended consequences".
FLappraiser: (February 15, 2011 3:54am)
Well loan originators welcome to the world the appraisers have been living in for years now. Having someone else set your fees is not fun is it? Well you can do what many appraisers have done, quit. Or, like some other appraisers we just refuse to work for less than our normal & customary fee. As you can imagine you don't get much work that way. So, you have to cut back on living and manage day to day. Absolutely NO reason that a Realtors fee, a loan originators fee or anyone in the process should be compensated based on the AMOUNT OF THE TRANSACTION. iF, What Frank & Brian say about it being more costly to the consumer and if that really matters to them they would be pushing for a fee based payment. Why not? Does a Realtor or loan originator really work 2X harder on a $400,000 loan than a $200,000. You know the answer is NO! So, why 2X the pay?...enough said.
mbreston: (February 15, 2011 3:39am)
Service is at least as important if not more important than margin in a purchase business. A couple of botched closings and having the lowest rate won't make much difference.
doitright: (February 15, 2011 3:13am)
THe clear winner will be th company that sets the rate in the AM to the lowest possible margin . Not like before with a 1 .70 to 2.30 but more like a .75 total. Then the law worked that is what they want low rates . Get rid of some of the mid managers , cut costs and have low rate. No one can march to a differnt drummer
mbreston: (February 15, 2011 2:22am)
We need to find a way to make the creditor paid model work in all scenarios. The problem with the creditor paid model is that we cannot lower our compensation to win deals or salvage deals that we thought we had won but which are now in jeopardy. How do we structure our contracts with wholesalers to create a fund that the broker can tap into to give a bigger credit to the borrower when necessary? Is there a way to do this that is compliant?
mbreston: (February 15, 2011 2:13am)
Also a request from a little broker shop in Tx (and I hope I am not out of place in requesting this), I think it would be great for all of us to maintain professionalism with posts. When we forward links to those who might be inclined to assist us, it would be nice that the posts under the link reflect positively on us. I think the venting could be taken to a group on Marbles. For those who have not joined Real Estate Marbles, it is free and it is the best platform I have found to interact with others in our industry.
austinmtgpro: (February 15, 2011 2:09am)
TBWSE - Think Big Work Somewhere Else
mbreston: (February 15, 2011 1:54am)
You guys are right on target. It would be helpful for you all in conjunction with NAMB could produce a series of Daily Shows designed to assist us to better communicate now with our members of Congress. If plan A is to delay the Rule, who really can do that? Short of a court injunction, how practical is it to stop the train, given the technicalities of how the Fed works? Members of Congress are going to ask, "What do you want me to do?" What can we ask them to do for us that is practical? If plan B is to get favorable interpretations from the Fed on some key issues, which are the key issues that we should ask our Congress members to have their staff contact the Fed about? If plan C is to lay the groundwork for modifications in future Rules, what does that look like? How do we best present the case that our interests are aligned with what is best for the consumer? It would be great if there were some videos designed simply for forwarding to Congressional staff.