RealtorPaul: (January 10, 2011 10:52am)
@Kim, I like some of Ventura's position but, seriously do people really think the government is going to enslave us? I don't think so, if you think about it the government needs us to make money and pay taxes so they can waste it! So, not going to worry about these FEMA camp theories. It is a bit riduculous to believe but, what is of a concern do we now have to disclose the government might be trying to enslave us? ;)
It gets crazier everyday!: (January 10, 2011 8:02am)
Where is the need to disclose a Seller's pending divorce if I have both of the seller's signatures on the listing agreement and the sales contract and the seller's proceeds can be held in escrow (at the closing) until they fight it out? I've never had a divorce delay a closing on the seller's side but have experienced it on the BUYERS side! AND FOR YOUR INFORMATION, not all of us Realtors feel that the NAR is the altruistic orginization it supposedly started out as. It's becoming just another power hungry, agenda motivated monopoly!
kim: (January 10, 2011 7:27am)
With all this talk about how HVCC was forced on us and how it actually made things worse and cost the home buyers more, what do you guys think this?
http://www.networkworld.com/community/blog/conspiracy-theory-teeth-government-allegedly-
kim: (January 09, 2011 5:32pm)
I don't think appraisers are going to go away. With that said, is there anything that can be done to make things better? Like I said already, being able to review the appraisals prior to the lender seeing them (being a second pair of eyes for errors and we all know there are many), and be able to challenge comparables used, is the only thing I can think would help. I understand not being able to pick your own appraiser due to influencing them, but if you aren't chosing them, we still should be able to talk to them about the appraisal. They should be limited to their area as well and have a three strike rule that makes them do a better job. I had one say there were no smoke alarms in the bedrooms, but there was one right outside the bedroom which counts. The same appraisal he stated two bathrooms when there was three. I called him up to tell him these things, but he wanted it to go through the system which took weeks. The loan was locked and due to the delay it cost the buyer.
Kris Realtor: (January 08, 2011 7:39pm)
LOL - likewise nice to meet another ethically minded realtor - female, yes, opinionated also yes .. divorce therefore likely LOL ... but ...
RealtorPaul: (January 08, 2011 6:46pm)
Well Kris damn glad to meet you, great minds think alike!!!! I am assuming you are a female, will you marry me. No wait a minute I forgot I don't believe in marriage, I call it pre-divorce, so you want to live together? My girlfriend dumped me, she thinks I am too opinionated, can you fricking believe that!!! LOL ;)
Kris Realtor: (January 08, 2011 6:39pm)
And should the appraisers decide to recognize the fact that some realtors actually DO their job ethically and according to the Professional Standards we were taught, perhaps this market could change ... and again, DIVORCE is not required to be disclosed to buyers - due dilligence and clear title clause in a contract rule ...
Kris Realtor: (January 08, 2011 6:36pm)
No Paul - you didn't "lose me" at all on that one as I have similar scenario in my career - I am consistently the agent that sells the highest priced homes for the most money in my market place, because I comp a retail against a retail, adjusting percentage factor down for foreclosure, shorts in the area, and have ALWAYS obtained top dollar for my clients in ANY marketplace, because that is my job ... I not only know my inventory well and the competition and the solds, I go in an will scrub a home on my hands and knees for them, bring my own staging items in, move furniture, etc... to do my job correctly for my clients - so no Paul - I'm not lost on that one at all :-)
RealtorPaul: (January 08, 2011 6:29pm)
I am a Realtor with 21+ years and appreciate that you agree with most of my points. But, I think I will lose you on this one. The majority of my business by farming several geographical areas, typically a square mile. The area I have had my best success w/$30,000,000+ in sales in 1 square mile. When I began my carear prices ranged $60,000-$130,000, before collapse prices increased to between $150,000-$270,000 (ignoring 6 infill new construction homes I built & sold between $300,000-$400,000). Ignoring all false modesty they increased mainly because of the economy pre 2006 but, also due to my efforts. Because I priced homes over what comparables would dictate, I allowed the "hot" real estate market & buyers dictate price. What resulted was a 15 year period were my listings consistently sold for highest price in square mile. Not a genius, just following my theory the market & the buyers dictate the price. I was ridiculed by Realtors when listed but not 1 word when sold for highest $
Kris Realtor: (January 08, 2011 5:52pm)
SUPPLY is there - start evaluating these properties correctly so these buyers can buy and we can move the inventory so prices at least STABILIZE ... I have to go try to sell some houses or price some listings ... uggghhh.... and wait for the next deal to fall apart because everyone is so frigging scared to give a loan - give me a break - a house that was worth $120/sq 10 yrs ago is now down to $65/$70 with shorts & foreclosures running around $30/$50 - can it go any lower!! MOVE THOSE HOUSES ... MOVE THOSE HOUSES - geez... P.S. Realtor Paul - I agree on most points you make, however, the banks should have the right to an appraiser, however, they can remove their god-like blessings and perhaps respect the people (realtors & buyers) that are actually in the TRENCHES trying to sell this stuff ...
Kris Realtor: (January 08, 2011 5:48pm)
OMG How do I get off this discussion update! Okay guys - I am a 20+ year Realtor veteran - I adjust my comps on my listings based on square footage, improvements, floor plan, etc.... My listings rarely do not appraise because if I have not seen the house, I will go preview (for ACTIVES) so I can see the upgrades, the pink walls, the oddities in the floor plan, which an appraiser usually does NOT take the time to go do ... they usually call the realtors! Appraisers bottom line are not as informed as most Realtors [should ALL be] AND most buyers who purchased in an area & a price range most similar to the subject which appraisers are appraising. And the banker lady that reviews the appraisal has probably NEVER been in a home in that subdivision or townhome complex or KNOW that that subdivision has a huge desirability fact for a 1st flr master vs. non, etc. etc... Talking to buyers on a daily basis we understand the DEMAND factor of properties ----
RealtorPaul: (January 08, 2011 4:22pm)
Well, as you admit not exact science, why is treated as such. If home doesn't appraise seller or buyer or both are damaged by this appraisal, since appraisal are not exact science that's unfair. As I said in previous post the only role I would be comfortable having so much power given to one individual is if underwriting guidles/laws require the appraisal come within 5-10% of sales price. And no my friend did not encourage his appraiser to do fraudulent appraisal he was a SMART appraiser & encouraged them to use their subjectivity to make the sale price the value. A lot of time the problem is EGO with appraiser I truly believe they feel they are god like & their OPINION is market value which it is not. Have they actually gone into all the similar homes that are on the market? Is it there hard earned money going to pay the mortgage? Do they know what about the house a buyer liked & encouraged them to make on offer? No, only the buyer has & therefore his opinion of value should rule!
JoeParsons: (January 08, 2011 3:20pm)
Part of the damage done by HVCC is to the quality of appraisals. We have seen some flagrantly incompetent reports. Recently, we saw an appraiser disregard three comps on the same street as the Subject. Since they had not been on the MLS, he said, they were not arms-length transactions and didn't have to be counted. WTF? Appraisers are working harder for less money because of the AMCs' involvement, and in many cases are taking assignments that are far from their areas of familiarity. This is, quite simply, wrong--and contrary to USPAP guidelines. I have never said that appraisal is "an exact science." It can't be, owing to the disorganized market nature of real estate. So your good buddy was directing the appraisers under his supervision to generate fraudulent appraisals? And now he is a big believer in the free market for real estate? O...kay. But it is, indeed a free market. If you want me to loan MY money for YOUR purchase, though, you'll have to conform to MY guidelines.
RealtorPaul: (January 08, 2011 1:55pm)
Joe, in 21 years I have seen my share of appraisals & I know quite well how they evaluate a property & appraisers are human beings which automatically adds subjectivity to the report and anyone who believes the apppraisal is not highly subjective is living in denial I can state numerous situations that prove my point but space does not allow. One recent (>2 years ago) FHA required 2 appraisals due to flipping rule one came in at sales price $100,000 the other $40,000 exact science, reliable? Absolutely not! As mentioned in a previous post a local bank in my market who at the time was originating 50% of the loans in the my area had a cheif appraiser who is a good buddy of mine and he TOLD his appraiser to do what ever they had to do to justify sale price on contract. He, as I believe the best indication of value is a well informed buyers opinion, PERIOD. There is no reason why real estate can't be a free market like other commodities.
JoeParsons: (January 08, 2011 1:27pm)
@RealtorPaul: with respect, I'd suggest that you learn how appraisals are actually performed. If it happens that you are in my area (San Francisco Bay Area), I'd be happy to show you several appraisals (including some that we disagreed with and successfully challenged). Understanding the process and practice of appraisal has been an essential skill for me as a loan originator, because many of the reports we see are deeply flawed. When we can provide a *knowledgeable* challenge to the report, we have a good chance to get it corrected.
JoeParsons: (January 08, 2011 1:22pm)
@RealtorPaul: Tahnk you for clarifying that you believe appraisals should be done away with. I agree that you will find very few who will agree with that point of view--in fact, some might call it reckless. Setting that aside, however, my point about the strategic default was to show that a "well-qualified buyer" is not by itself adequate security for a mortgage. And the fact that two competent appraisers may hold slightly different Opinions of Value does not invalidate the process. It's analogous to someone's saying, "People sometimes get killed even while wearing a seatblet. Therefore, it's never worthwhile wearing a seatbelt, since they aren't 100% effective, 100% of the time." WRT what you claim is the "subjective" nature of an appraisal: there is a reason that there are many components to the appraisal; some of them involve objective measurement, some involve the judgment of the appraiser. That fact does not make the report invalid, or "subjective." (more)
kim: (January 08, 2011 1:06pm)
I agree one appraiser could give different values to an identical house in the same neighborhood, but when we were allowed to question them, I found out that one kitchen had vinyl flooring and Formica counter tops where the other had wood floors and granite counter tops. The lot sizes were different and one had a view. If everything had been the same, I would have agreed they should be the same, but an appraiser has a list of how much he adds or subtracts for certain items. I learned this the class I took. They not only look at the obvious, but look at the quality of the products that go into a house. You cannot compare just floor plans and sq ft. But again, just like their are lazy Realtors, there are lazy appraisers. So how do you fix it, we need to be allowed to review the appraisals prior to the lender seeing them.HVCC can randomly pick an appraiser, but we should be allowed to question their findings and they need to justify how they came up with what and correct it if needed
RealtorPaul: (January 08, 2011 12:47pm)
Yes Joe that is exactly what I am saying, you make an example of a house being under water by $250,000 and the buyer walks away, we all see it every day. Question to you how did the appraisal on that property help the lender in your example? Well, obviously it didn't help at all and that is my point. Also, you say the appraisal does have some subjective parts well that means the whole report is subjective!! Joe you can't be just a little bit pregnant. I know my opinion is not popular with many, specialy appraisers but, when you look at it with open mind it makes perfect sense!
JoeParsons: (January 08, 2011 12:33pm)
With respect to what you persist in believing is the largely "subjective" nature of an appraiser's Opinion of Value: yes, there are some judgment items, like location, view, condition and upgrades. But there are many aspects of appraising that are completely OBjective, like the specifications of the property and the replacement cost. There is a reason that appraisers must be trained and licensed to be able to issue a report on which a lender will rely. If an appraiser is not performing in an appropriate manner, the lender can do a desk review. The realtor and/or loan officer can challenge the report based on its substance. This is why I believe it is imperative for anyone representing him or herself as a mortgage or real estate professional MUST have a detailed working knowledge of the theory and practice of appraisal. Theoretically, any real estate licensee has had at least one course, but that knowledge often evaporates after the licensee has passed the licensing exam.
JoeParsons: (January 08, 2011 12:25pm)
Paul, you haven't answered the question I asked earlier: are you suggesting that appraisals should be eliminated, and that the banks should accept the contract price as adequate security for their loans? You seem to believe that a "well-qualified buyer" is adequate security, when coupled with "sound underwriting guidelines." Here is a reality: with the virtual collapse of real estate values, there are many highly qualified people (excellent income and high credit scores) who have chosen "strategic default." After all, if I have negative equity of, say, $250,000 and I believe I will never recover it, a good financial decision could be for me walk away from the property and accept the temporary damage to my credit profile. A quarter of a million is a lot of money. Especially with non-recourse financing, lenders MUST have something to go on beyond the contract price and the buyer's word when they extend credit.
RealtorPaul: (January 08, 2011 12:03pm)
Appraiser evaluating a property by finding as close to identical properties to price the subject property and you say in real estate 2 identical properties can sell for different prices doesn't make sense. If appraisal were non subjective and accurate to the point of being construed as scientific then your statement could not happen. I think that proves my point. If the banks want security in the property then adhere to sound underwriting guidelines. Because, truly a qualified borrower is the only way for the banks to be secure. That is one of the many lessons current market has taught us. A 20% down conventional loan in my market place just 2 years ago that loan would now be upside down, there goes equity. Last point, I have had appraisals within $500-$5000 of sales price but, because financial industry believes there appraisers are gods deal dies/somebody has take money out of there pocket. Appraisal if used should have to only come with 5-10% of sales price.
RealtorPaul: (January 08, 2011 11:47am)
Lets just boil this down a bit, the belief that an appraisal will give the lender security in the property they are loaning money in case of default. And most people believe that one persons (the appraiser) opinion of value give that security/equity. That is an ssumption I don't agree with because, Joe no matter what you say, appraisals are extremely subjective. I have seen many an appraisal and their +/- are inconsistant and basically arbitray. One appraiser will make an adjustment of +or- $2500 for an updated kitchen another will +or- $5000 so, how can you say it is not subjective. I have seen appraisal with comps from different cities and school districts so would you feel you have "security" based on an appraisal like that? I thinkk not. Joe your statement regarding a "disorganized market" (which is a whole other argument) if anything proves my point. If 2 identical properties can sell for different prices doesn't that render comps useless for appraisal issues? see next post
kim: (January 08, 2011 11:05am)
You guys just don't get it. The larger the purchase, the more opt the lender is going to want some security. With all of the foreclosures, it is clear that good credit isn't enough. A large amount of the foreclosed houses were that of people with great credit. If I were lending money, I would want something I could take back in the event of a default on payment to get back some of my money. Realtors are too close to the situation to trust. Not everyone out there is honest or educated enough in all areas to make that call for the lenders. I agree, appraisers used should be from the immediate area and the Realtors should have an opportunity to pick the appraisal apart if they don't agree, but the final decision should be left to parties not financially benefiting from the sale. Prior to HVCC, we had that opportunity. Most appraisers will make adjustments if it makes sense. Appraisers should be closely monitored because many of them aren't doing their best job. They have no one to be accountable to under the new guidelines.
JoeParsons: (January 08, 2011 10:36am)
Where appraisers go wrong (apart from gross errors in their adjustments, like reducing a comp for a pool that doesn't exist) is in their selection of comparable sales. Under USPAP guidelines, the sales must be "arms-length transactions." This should eliminate Trustee's Sales, dees-in-lieu and sales to offspring, because they aren't arms-length. If an appraiser uses a foreclosure sale (sold on the courthouse steps), he is making a mistake. If he disregards more suitable comps that might support a higher value, he should be put into the position of defending his selection--and possibly his adjustments. I want to make two points: first, that appraisals are *not* an arbitrary, subjective number pulled out of the appraiser's nether orifice. And second, that any Realtor or loan officer needs to get very familiar with how appraisals are done, so as to be in a position to challenge them whenever necessary.
JoeParsons: (January 08, 2011 10:29am)
@RealtorPaul: It appears to me that you have limited familiarity with the appraisal process. Here, in a nutshell, is how it works: the "Subject Property" is described in a standardized, systematic way: square fottage, room counts, lot size, amenities, condition, etc. then three or more recent sales that have occurred in close proximity to the subject are selected. These are also described in a standardized, sytematic way. The comps are adjusted up or down to be equivalent to the Subject. A comp with 100 square feet more than the Subject would be adjusted downward based on the prevailing costs of construction. A recent appraisal we received used $50/ft, so the comp would be adjusted downward by 100 x $50 = $5,000. Similar standard adjustments are made for room count, lot size, amenities, condition, etc. Yes, there is some judgment involved in the process, but the Opinion of Value is *not* subjective. (more, above)
JoeParsons: (January 08, 2011 10:18am)
@RealtorPaul: It's true that there are many products that are financed without an appraisal, like automobiles. But real estate is what is called a "disorganzed market." This means (among other things) that two identical properties can sell for very different prices. Compare this with automobiles, where there is a well-articulated price for the item, and comparatively little room for different selling prices. With respect to a "well-informed consumer," yes: that would be nice, in a perfect world. But (and I can speak from over three decades in real estate brokerage an dmortgage finance) many consumers are very badly uninformed or misinformed. People *do* sign documents whose meaning is a complete mystery to them. People *do* often enter into deals that are ill-advised. But let me ask you this: are you suggesting that appraisals should be eliminated, and that the banks should accept the contract price as adequate security for their loans?
RealtorPaul: (January 07, 2011 3:17pm)
Joe your scenario doesn't happen a well informed buyer would not pay $50,000 more for a twin property if there realtor did their job and showed them comps. The buyer might pay $5000-$10000 more than a comp which should be allowed. There are many products sold with financing that don't require appraisal why should real estate be different. It is underwriting guidlines that will protect lenders not appraiser who use there subjectivity to determine equity in a property. And after all that is truly what appraisers do is determine equity not market value. Buyers determine market value in ever other purchase made on this planet! Joe your statement manipulation of an appraiser to "hit a target" creates real problems, exactly how does it that create a problem? If you mean appreciation is the problem I can live with that because that is the only ramification that I can see by hitting a target.
JoeParsons: (January 07, 2011 3:03pm)
Real estate does operate in something like a "free market," but you have the added consideration of mortgage financing. As a buyer, I am free to pay whatever I want for a property--but the lender has a right to decide how much money they are willing to risk on that purchase, if I am asking them to assist. The scenario you are talking about is one part of the problem: hitting a "target value." Even today, an appraiser will attempt to show whether the contract price is a fair reflection of the market value. There is a certain amount of wiggle room. But if I have agreed to pay $400,000 for a property with no sales concessions and the twin to that property next door sold last month for $350,000, any appraiser is going to be hard pressed to justify the contract price. Someone who exerts pressure on an appraiser to manipulate numbers to "hit a target" creates real problems in the industry.
RealtorPaul: (January 07, 2011 3:00pm)
And as a follow up the banks should not be worried about the equity in the house as it would only become an issue if for some unexpected reason the recent buyer is forced to sell shortly after purchase. Unless the buyer put at least 20% down their will be shortage regrdless of market conditions and this situation is a low percentage. The banks need to stick to realistic unerwriting guidlines and give loans to people who can truly afford them. I know of a deal pre 2006 sub prime collapse that closed with debt ratios of 125% why would a lender ignore guidlines to such a level. That is what brought on the housing collapse and the depreciating market that we are currently experiencing. And prices keep falling in my area because appraisers keep coming in short. One person should not have that power, appraising is not an exact science nor will it ever be. Either eliminate appraiser completely or underwriting guidlines should state the appraisal only needs to come within 5-10% of SP.
RealtorPaul: (January 07, 2011 2:48pm)
Joe that is my point they are done incompetently and subjectively. Equity in a property therefore becomes subjective. I have appraisers that don't give credit for updates, I have had appraiser that make price adjustment for updates on a comp that exceed the actual cost of the update. I have had an appraiser saying he can't justify the sales price because no home has sold for that price. Well, then explain to me how we have appreciation if an appraiser believes he cannot appraise a home at price unless he has a comp that sold over subject property. Appreciation occurs because a well informed buyer has made the decision to go over the highest comp. A good friend of mine was the cheif apppraiser for a lender who at the time originated 50% of the mortgages in my area, he told his appraisers to justify the sales price on the purchase agreement, period. Real estate like alll good and services should be sold in a free market, having appraisers eliminates the free market system.
JoeParsons: (January 07, 2011 2:25pm)
@RealtorPaul: Do people offer what they believe a property is worth? Of course. Might they overpay (especially in a multiple offer situation)? Sure. The necessary role of the appraiser is to assure the lender--who typically can look *only* to the property as its security--that their position is adequately protected. The job of the appraiser is to present a professional opinion of what that the property will bring if it is sold in an arms-length transaction to a third party if it had to be sold to satisfy the debt. The biggest problem I am seeing as a lender is that many appraisals are incompetently done. We have seen appraisers come from far outside the area, with no local knowledge. We have seen comparable sales disregarded because, in the words of one appraiser, they would "overvalue the subject." With the present system, it is difficult, if not impossible, to challenge those appraisals that are improperly done.
RealtorPaul: (January 07, 2011 1:21pm)
I'll give you another reason why appraisers role in real estate needs to be limited or eliminated: had a property for sale had 5 offers all over list price by a bit, we did not take the highest bid because of terms and the house did not apppraise, so we ignore 5 different people thinking the home was worth list price or more and yet the appraiser rules. If you can't see the problem now with appraisers maybe you should become one, lol.
RealtorPaul: (January 07, 2011 1:19pm)
@brokeraimee first, you don't know somebody that is buying art work is paying cash or if they are using a line of credit so your point is lost. Second, the price of the home should not be an issue with the bank it is the buyers ability to ppay that should be there concern. In my 21 years I have never seen what you obviously believe is a buyer paying too much for a home, they pay what they feel it is worth after seeing mayt other homes on the market and looking at comparable sales and they make a decision on what they think it is worth and since they will be making the payments their opinion is the only one that matters. Again I say why should one person (the appraisers) value be the sole determination of value and rule the transacttion? They are subjective in there analysis.
Kris Realtor: (January 07, 2011 1:13pm)
Banks getting an appraisal to "protect" their collateral is completely understandable but when the banks call for appraisal review and that goes to an appraiser OUT OF THE AREA that NEVER has seen the property, does their review from different school districts, etc., it does all an injustice ... keeps the buyer from getting the home they want; keeps the bank from the business ... Stupid ... AND DirtyGoose - WRONG - contract is typically subject to CLEAR TITLE transferred to buyer so when title pulled, divorce appears, their attorney works with other attorney to "clear" it prior to close - no disclosure required. Period.
RealtorPaul: (January 07, 2011 12:00pm)
@dirtygoose sorry but being on title does not effect whether a divorce should be disclosed, it should not under any circumstances. It does not effect the marketibility or condition of the property those are the items that need to be disclosed. Do you disclose that there is a lien on the property? No, I don't think so because it will all be taking care of at closing. A divorce does not effect marketability because there is a divorce decree that governs the sale of the home.
RealtorPaul: (January 07, 2011 11:28am)
@Kim some buyers may make an emotional decision and if they put a value on the house based on that what is wrong with that. Somebody will pay a price for an item for many reason which are irrelevant, it is all the factors a buyer uses that determines market value. And if I was loaning the buyer money I would not care in the least what an appraiser feels the home is worth, I would concern myself with their ability to pay. So it is underwriting guidelines that are crucial in a real estate transaction or any other loan for that matter. And as far as your car analogy pulling cash out by refinancing your car is a new one to me. And then look at it from this perspective I just bought a new jeep with no money down and the lender new the minute I drove off the lot I was upside down on the loan by about $5000 and driving a depreciating item to boot. So, what was important to them was my ability to pay. The same should to apply to homes, which historically, are an appreciating item.
dirtygreygoose: (January 07, 2011 9:07am)
If husband and wife are on title and they are divorcing,then YES, it should be disclosed. Any condition of title must be disclosed.
kim: (January 07, 2011 8:59am)
In a perfect world, I would agree with you that a buyer should be able to pay what they want for a house if they are paying cash, but most buyers make emotional decisions that have nothing to do with mathematics and accounting. Just qualifying for a loan isn't security enough, the buyer and the house need to qualify. Think about it. What happens when you take your car in as collateral for a cash out loan? The bank looks very closely at the true value and condition of the car to determine how much they will lend. A purchase of a house is not an unsecured loan like a visa, the security is the home. If it was your money being used you would feel differently. Yes, there needs to be consistency between the values the appraisers come up with and before HVCC, we had the opportunity to challenge the findings of an appraiser. Appraisers and Realtors are the two experts in the industry. Working together actually works towards perfecting the true market value. We need to get rid of HVCC.
RealtorPaul: (January 07, 2011 8:43am)
@Broker aimie whether a bank is loaning them money has no effect on the factthat the appraisil is meaningless. The fact that a lender is involved only means buyer needs to be able to qualify for the loan, guidelines are important what an individual appraiser values the home has absolutely no importance. And all this talk about the importance of the size of a home is also irrevalant for the most part, a purchaser is buying the home after viewing it and the home was as big as it was when they were there. As far as an appraiser needing exact measurement implies even if size is of a minor amount is going to effect his evalution is further proof of the flawed appraisal industry. The very belief that any individual can evaluate a property to an exact $$$ value is a comlete an utter joke. If they gave a range of price I would give the industry moore credability. But anyone that believes a house can be professionaly evaluted to a specific dollar amount is not living in the real world.
kim: (January 07, 2011 8:16am)
I believe there is a need for appraisers based on the fact that banks loan on them. It is there butt at stake here. They lend money on homes no where near them and have no ideal what the market is. If a buyer is paying cash, then he can pay whatever he wants. Plus there are too many uninformed buyers. I took an appraiser class to understand how they come up with what they do. Most realtors take the total sq.ft and there is a difference in how to determine sq ft base on the house style. That is why they try to use houses of the same style,age,condition, etc. You cannot compare a ranch style home to a daylight basement. The basement is not calculated the same way the above grade is. I have seen some Realtors include the garage into their sqft! Appraisers are suppose to be consistent. They have very strict guidelines of how to come to the sq ft. Before the HVCC got involved, we had the opportunity to question the appraiser if there was a discrepancy. We need to get rid of HVCC.
Kris Realtor: (January 07, 2011 6:50am)
As to the appraisal issue, appraisers are way off the mark on too many values these days - agree with Paul the value of a property is what an informed & educated buyer is willing to pay - INFORMED being the key ... if they have looked at the majority of comparable properties available to them in the 1st place, choose the subject & negotiate to their satisfaction it should be the value ... or very very close
Kris Realtor: (January 07, 2011 6:45am)
@Broker Aimee - I was not discussing sq. footage issue - the appraiser brought it up - but I will ... our Board (& my BROKER) requires us to portray square footage from an outside source & referred to as Apx Sq Footage in the listing . an actual field has been implemented to inform buyer where that figure is derived from ... I always use the same source (tax assessor) - having worked for lawyers for MANY years prior to my 20 in real estate, this just makes good sense...
BrokerAimee: (January 07, 2011 6:26am)
Oh...and @PAUL..the difference between Art and Real Estate, in your example, is the person that has the money to buy it. In the real estate case, that's usually the BANK. Nuff said.
BrokerAimee: (January 07, 2011 6:23am)
After all, when was the last time you saw the County come in and measure each and every house to determine what kind of living space is there? The bottom line is, it is ALL of our jobs to measure a house. How we've been instructed to do it and record it is where the problem lies. If there is a discrepency, someone should make a phone call. The other someone should actually answer their phone..and the question. I don't think appraisers are going away, as agent aren't. Rather, we should all try to work together on the massive amounts of confusion there is between the way we do things. We also need to be honest and not embellish the facts so it looks good on paper. Knowlege is power folks. Knowledge is power. Stay tuned.
BrokerAimee: (January 07, 2011 6:16am)
@RANDY...Paul and Kris..
I've also been in this business for 20 years and I'm also an instructor for continuing ed here locally and this coming spring BOTH appraisers AND real estate professionals will more than likely be seeing me on their online continuing education videos nationwide. There is a big problem with the way that agents and appraisers measure houses. First, in many markets agents don't use GLA (Gross Living Area). We use AGF and BGF (Above Ground Finished, Below Ground Finished.) This causes a MAJOR problem with consistancy between appraisers and agents. It also causes a MAJOR problem with the underwriters that are reviewing the appraisal. They are two different things. Unfortunately, it may take some time to change the terminology so that it is congruant through the industry. Secondly, I think the tax records should be left out of the equation. I've seen so many tax records that are completely off base. Continued....
RealtorPaul: (January 06, 2011 9:53pm)
Kim no doubt about the venting and getting of the subect but, that's what we call a fluid discussion and what blogging is all about. And I stand by my opinion the real estate industry would be better off without appraisers. After 21 years selling real estate I see no need for appraisers. When selling artwork at an auction and a particular piece sells for twice it's appraised value is there somebody there to say no you can't pay that it's too much, I don't think so. Why is real estate different? What other commodity is sold subject to somebody elses approval of the price? I can't think of any can anyone? Now that's blogging!
kim: (January 06, 2011 9:40pm)
I feel the appraisers are victims of the HVCC as is everyone. They now get paid less for the same work and the homebuyer pays more for their appraisals. The Red Tape they have to go through is ridiculous! However, it is their job to measure the house or take the information the county has. They are required to confirm certain things. As for an addition added to a house, that should be the responsibility of the home owner that added it to provide the permits, then it would be registered with the county. The realtor should be sure the owner provides this information. The problem is that it only takes one person not doing their job and a house is sold and the new buyers won't know the answer when they go to sell it. Their are lazy appraisers, lazy realtors, and dishonest sellers. The rest of us just pay the price for it. But wasn't the original comment about if we should disclose a potential divorce, or death in a house, or possible ghost? I guess we all need somewhere to vent.
RealtorPaul: (January 06, 2011 9:19pm)
Well Randy that explains your attitude, your an appraiser. Between appraisers who think they are gods and banks who think there better than gods you guys will crush the economy. Appraisers need to be removed from the real estate industry or play a greatly reduced role. Big clue to all appraisers the value of a house is what a ready willing and able buyer is willing to pay for the house, not your subjective inconsistent appraisal industry value. I have had 5 of my last 6 deals not appraise do to appraiser subjectivity! And the one that did come in at sales price shouldn't have, the appraiser used comps from a different city and different school system, your industry is a joke! I believe in evolution the appraisal industry needs to go extinct, then we will have a recovery and more solid of a housing market! Banks should be required by law that an appraisal only has to come within 5-10% of sales price, high or low. One person should not be able to determine equity in a home!
W.R.Buchanan: (January 06, 2011 8:54pm)
N0, Randy is the appraiser who has to do your job because you can't measure the house you are selling and confirm the GLA or won't confirm if the room addition is permitted. There is no State that prevents you from doing those things. Lately Corelogic has been using it's network of MLS's to sharpshoot my appraisals, and since a significant portion of the Data On MLS is wrong, it it annoying that I have to rebutt such crap, and It costs me money. However since the banks are taking over the whole business it won't matter much longer as we will all be out of a job. Randy
RealtorPaul: (January 05, 2011 1:38pm)
Kris, your probably right about Randy not being a Realtor but, he has the attitude of the REO agents that work my market, so you never know. have a good one too Kris
Kris Realtor: (January 05, 2011 1:19pm)
LOL - I don't think there should be any worry about Randy being a listing agent as he obviously is not a Realtor .... or if he is, a very uninformed one ... Have a good one Paul!
RealtorPaul: (January 05, 2011 12:52pm)
Kris I agree we need to stop the chatting and sell homes, however today is paper work day so I am multi-tasking. Besides I would be afraid to sell a home today, Randy mught be the listing agent. LOL
RealtorPaul: (January 05, 2011 12:49pm)
@Kris, LMAO yes Randy is a bit odd to say the least!!! @Kim I assume you meant fiduciary and as far as avoiding lawsuites in 21 years I have never been sued. But, the reality is we live in a very litigous society and you can be sued for any reason so, the best way to avoid law suites is obey the laws of your state and treat people fairly and honestly and hope for the best.
Kris Realtor: (January 05, 2011 12:45pm)
Technically I stand corrected ... I guess for a seller it falls more under AGENCY ... so in general it could be unFAIR or prejudicial against your client as a seller's agent to disclose their familial status which may be confidential unless authorized - okie dokie - must get off this topic & go try to sell some of these houses!
Kris Realtor: (January 05, 2011 12:44pm)
Technically I stand corrected ... I guess for a seller it falls more under AGENCY ... so in general it could be unFAIR or prejudicial against your client as a seller's agent to disclose their familial status which may be confidential unless authorized - okie dokie - must get off this topic & go try to sell some of these houses!
kim: (January 05, 2011 12:43pm)
I agree that it is the judiciary responsibility of the listing agent to disclose everything about the property they are allowed to. In our state, certain things are not allowed to be disclosed such as a death in the house, or supposed ghosts, sex offenders in the neighborhood, etc... but if it is public information and you are asked by the prospected buyer, you can direct them to the source. As much as you would like to feel that you should, the law often tie your hands. To prevent law suits, it is better to encourage the home owner to do their job by giving you the measurements or information about the property line or well/septic tank. There is such a fine line when it comes to being sued if the information comes back and bites you, that you just need to be very careful. Property lines - encourage the buyer to get a survey...Well/septic -have a professional to report on it...Room sizes - have the owner measure or a paid appraiser. I have seen Realtors sued over misrepresenting it.
Kris Realtor: (January 05, 2011 12:37pm)
RealtorPaul - you were much kinder than I was about to be to this Randy character ... obviously he is not a Realtor required to LEARN and KNOW the laws put in place to protect & inform all parties to a transaction - A quick read on AGENCY & LICENSE LAW would make his head spin off his neck a little more than it obvsiously is already with all thos WTF comments ... LOL
RealtorPaul: (January 05, 2011 12:35pm)
Kris Fair Housing Laws apply only to discrimination of a buyer of a property, there is nothing in the law stating there is discrimination if a seller does not disclose anything about their familiial status.
RealtorPaul: (January 05, 2011 12:32pm)
@Randy a little hostile today, Santa not goood to you? Your statment is absolutely incorrect, there are laws here in Michigan that absolutely prohibit a Realtor from disclosing things such as, a death or murder or even a suspected haunted house. So, your blanket statement that if you know something disclose it is wrong. As is you statement the buyer should not have to perform due dilligence when buying a home is also wrong. i'll give you an example: schools should the listing Realtor disclose all he knows about the schools? Absolutely not, this is the buyers duty to find out about the schools, if the listing agent (and buyer's agent for that matter) where to do that it would be a violation of the stearing laws. So get a grip, be a good boy and Santa will be better to you in 2011!
Kris Realtor: (January 05, 2011 12:27pm)
Bingo MsMammy ... DISLOSURES pertain to property only .. AGENCY laws prohibit disclosures such as a divorce on behalf of a seller unless authorized in writing by client ... FAIR HOUSING relates mostly to buyers but I do believe it would be prejudicial against a Sellers' right to equitably market a home if their familial status was disclosed ...
W.R.Buchanan: (January 05, 2011 12:18pm)
Anything significant in a RE transaction that is known about by the owner and or RE Agent and not disclosed can and should blow back on the RE Agent. It is the job of the RE Agent to "truthfully represent" the property. If you don't know something or "suspect something" you need to find out. Statement's like "buyer to satisfy self on sq ft of house" or on "permitted additions" is literally committing fraud. It's not the job of the buyer to "satisfy self". It is the job of the agent to tell everybody exactly what is there!!!!!! WTF do you get paid for? You're to lazy or you don't know how to measure a house? Figure it out or hire sombody to do it. You can't go to the recorders office or B&S to check on a suspect addition or permits? WHY? WTF do you get paid for? Your profession is not about a cute head shot! it is about representing a property and actually selling that property! Do your job, You make more than anyone else in the transaction! Earn at least some of it! Randy
msmammypie: (January 05, 2011 12:09pm)
Sorry, fellas - in Idaho, neither the seller (nor the real estate licensee) is required to disclose whether someone died in the house (or if it's haunted, etc.) unless specifically asked by a potential buyer. Likewise, the motivation for the sale of a property (such as a divorce) is considered confidential client information which may not be disclosed by the client seller's listing agent without the express written permission of the client. I think even NAR would have a tough time implementing a divorce disclosure because state laws pertaining to agency representation are so diverse and varied - what might be acceptable in one state would be prohibited in another. BTW, required disclosures and what information is considered an adverse material fact in most states relate only to the property itself, not the neighbors, marital or financial status of the sellers or buyers, etc.
mrtgman: (January 05, 2011 11:44am)
We are hiring loan officers for our Charlotte, NC office. Email me today to discuss the opportunity.
[email protected]
Sandie: (January 05, 2011 10:27am)
The divorce issue is generally handled by what the individual State Laws require. NAR may make recommendations but it is up to State Legislatures and the Real Estate Commissioners to implement law. Every State has different laws. While I agree it can be problematic if one party decides to be difficult, under some State Laws they have no choice but to sign the necessary paperwork because of the Community Property Laws. I don't think it is an issue that NAR should be involved with. Their job is to do things to benefit the Real Estate Community. State Law protects the consumer.
RealtorPaul: (January 05, 2011 8:45am)
Several people have commented that disclosing divorce is a Fair Housing Violation (familial status) and can't be disclosed. I agree it should not disclosed but, not sure if this should be considered a Fair Housing violation, Fair Housing is to protect buyers from discrimination therefore I do not see how this applies to a seller. Interested in others opinions.
Kris Realtor: (January 05, 2011 8:19am)
Definition of Familial Status (Protected Class under Federal Fair Housing Laws):
"Characteristic determined by a person's household type, such as marriage and existing or prospective children. Referred to in the Federal Fair Housing Law and Fair Credit Reporting Act"
Read more: http://www.answers.com/topic/familial-status#ixzz1AB7PuulQ
Kris Realtor: (January 05, 2011 8:05am)
dwrooks - I'm aware of the problems in divorce cases, both having worked for attorneys dealing with it and having closed many many real estate transactions involving divorced couples in my 20 year career ... disclosing a divorce is a prejudice against the parties under Federal Fair House - it is discriminatory against the parties ... MANY MANY real estate transactions are extremely messy ... short sales, estates, etc - disclosing a short sale is required, yes, but you are dealing with a certain contingency in that contract "subject to bank approval of short sale" which is the req'd disclosure ... a divorce may be subject to Court approval, thus the only disclosure req'd ... People can be jerks whether they are going thru a divorce or not so you wouldn't disclose "my seller is a jerk so beware this could be messy" ... Period ....
jaebert: (January 05, 2011 7:51am)
You R asking for "Horse Toys"? Or "Horse Stories?"
"A Horse walks into a bar, with a priest, a rabbi and a nun..."
jaebert: (January 05, 2011 7:50am)
You R asking for "Horse Toys"? Or "Horse Stories?"
"A Horse walks into a bar, with a priest, a rabbi and a nun..."
dwrooks: (January 05, 2011 7:47am)
Realtor, Divorce deals can become problematic and not close for numerous reasons. One party or the other changes their mind out of spite for the other party at the last minute and it does not close. In one deal I saw what happened to another Realtor, the wife got mad and did not want to close the day before closing so she called 911 and claimed the Realtor broke into her home and assaulted her. After 3 months of stress and attorney expense it came out that she did not want to close and used that as a way out. So divorce cases can be very messy and should be disclosed in some form
Kris Realtor: (January 05, 2011 5:48am)
Also 20 years in the business, and also a prior legal secretary for an attorney who specialized in divorce ... Disclosing a divorce relates to familial status of the parties ... violation my opinion ... the burden of investigation of the public record on behalf of the buyer should be a buyer's agent responsibility, not a listing agent as that COULD affect negotiating power on behalf of their client ... NOT required to disclose my opinion. "Subject to Court approval" which is similar to what is required on an Estate where the heirs can fight much more than a divorcing couple!!
RealtorSherry: (January 05, 2011 5:37am)
After 20 years in the biz, I will not accept a listing that involves a divorce. I am not a therapist, nor a lawyer. Inevitably, I end up negotiating the marital assets to close the home. NO THANKS! Although, I do believe that a disclosure is necessary, if the divorce has been filed. It is public records anyway, right? If the delay hurts the buyer, I do not want to be held liable for knowing and not telling. At the last closing that I had involving a divorce, the wife told me that I made more money from the marriage, than she did! LOL!
Kris Realtor: (January 05, 2011 5:34am)
Disclosing a divorce seems to me would be in violation of Federal Fair Housing Laws! Adding to the listing that the contract may be "subject to Court approval" should suffice.
cjohns28: (January 04, 2011 10:05pm)
Fellas, why are you loan guys now consulting on real estate agent issues? Come on, stick to the stuff you know, and us agents will not meddle in the loan details. Love the shows, but todays missed the mark.
Frank, you don't disclose a death in a house, you MAY have to disclose the type of death, DEPENDING on the state one is licensed in. It's not an universal answer, far from it, so hopefully RE agents out there don't take your word on this. They could regret it especially if they practice in Oregon.
Brian, pipe down a tad on divorce issue, again, it'll depend on the title issues, and like the above, depending on what state one practices in, dictates what you should or should not do. A divorce is not material to the other side (assuming I'm the listing agent) as long as title is not impinged. So disclosing would not be advised and would simply empower a smart buyers agent to dig in, and that could cost my client dough.
kim: (January 04, 2011 9:53pm)
In my state, if there is a divorce that has been filed, the lenders will not loan on the house. They always do one last check of the records before funding the loan. In a case of a divorce where a house is involved and neither party wants it or there isn't any money to buy the other person out, the judge will rule for it to be sold. He will assign one of the parties to be in control of the listing and overseeing the sale. The other is not to be involved or to interfere. The other is bound by the courts to sign off on the house when they have a buyer. If they refuse, the judge then signs for that party. In the divorce decree, the judge clearly lays out the schedule and price of how the sale of the house will proceed. He states a sales price based on an appraisal, when it will be reduced if not sold by a certain time, and by how much. They won't allow the house to be listed forever. I don't see where there would be any of the problems I have been reading. At least not in my state.
thequeenbarb: (January 04, 2011 9:12pm)
HEADS up to real estate agents!!! Either party in a divorce has the right to APPEAL any decisions in the divorce, but NOT until the divorce is final! Trying to sell a house before this Appelate period runs out is ludicrous, damaging to all parties, and risky business!
thequeenbarb: (January 04, 2011 9:10pm)
LOL! My "court-appointed" realtor disclosed in the intial listing that there were "divorce proceedings" in CA. He coerced the court to sign Title away from me by signature of the clerk (sept. 09) - I APPEALED that day - I stayed in the house for 10 kore months - the alleged buyer rescinded and un-rescinded - and re- rescinded his offer. The guy STILL has the Title - I am paying THOUSANDS in mortgage every month - but I was VACATED from the house and was homeless for a month. Now living in a warehouse with my dog and daughter. YESTERDAY, the BUYER put up my vacant house (since June,2010) for RENT!! Now the rental management company and any potential renters will have to be joined to my divorce case!! The fact that a court orders a house to be sold PRIOR to division of assets, seems to me to be in direct violation of the Automatic Temporary Restraining Orders imposed upon a couple immediately upon Notice of Dissolution. Any thoughts????
trasbnd: (January 04, 2011 3:29pm)
This seems like a state by state issue. In UT, we as the Title Company, disclose the effect of a pending divorce, and the seller is required to give a copy of the PR to the Buyer as part of the Seller's Disclosures.
Noel Cookman: (January 04, 2011 1:27pm)
GODLIKE...and you must admit - it takes moxy to match wits with GOD or anyone who is GODLIKE - I "dance" around the issue because the very phrase "set a price" is misleading. And many people imagine that a judge really has "set a price" rather than ordered a listing. Moreover and most often the case is "receivership" whereby the order is to sell . . . at any price. The court rarely takes an interest in price or watching out for the seller's best interest. But, if we keep using phrases like "set a price" we perpetuate a most common misunderstading.
RealtorPaul: (January 04, 2011 12:49pm)
MN interesting point but not sure familial status applies to this discussion, have to think on that one.
BrokerAimee: (January 04, 2011 12:48pm)
@GODLIKE...
Point taken. However, how on earth will a divorce disclosure stop a disgruntled husband from loading up the van and heading west? Now..If I could have disclosed that the guy was "nutso" and the buyers would be left out in the cold in this purchase, I would have. Disclosing divorce proceedings wouldn't have changed a thing in this case. While you feel bad for the poor buyers here..I feel worse for many "poor" sellers who are amicable that would have to disclose personal information about their LIFE while selling real property. Is it really a complete stangers business that things haven't worked out as planned and they won't be celebrating the holidays together anymore? Crazy is crazy. Let's talk about disclosing crazy and unreliable before we talk about disclosing divorce. Do you think NAR will buy that?
MNREagent: (January 04, 2011 12:44pm)
It doesn't happen very often that you push one way and your poll results push back. You guys missed the mark on this "familial status" issue. If we started to put everything in a contract that could potentially f-bomb a contract we would have a 30 pager....ohhhh, we already have that.
RealtorPaul: (January 04, 2011 12:42pm)
Joe and Woody are right on! And Joe I think there should be an A$$hole seller disclosure to the Realtor, I have delt with too many and IF I KNEW I would have walked away from the listing. LOL. Life is just too short.
woodyedwards: (January 04, 2011 12:37pm)
The only "Items" that need to be disclosed are items that physically effect the property! Deaths, ghosts and divorces do not effect the property. Divorce could effect the closing, but does not physically effect the property! The listing agent has to keep alot of "things" confidential!
JoeParsons: (January 04, 2011 12:33pm)
Years ago, when I was still listing and selling real estate, I took a listing for a 32 unit apartment building. Another agent brought a buyer and the price was negotiated. Escrow was about a week old when the resident manager, who happened to be a real estate agent, told the seller that he was selling to place too cheaply (his nose was out of joint because he hadn't gotten the listing). The seller called me and said, "I want another hundred thousand on the price." I pointed out to the seller that he was in contract, and didn't have the ability to renegotiate the price. "Well, let him sue me then," he said, and refused to sign Buyer's Instructions. Seller sued for specific performance and costs, I sued for my commission, he sued me for suing him. Buyer and I prevailed, and title was conveyed. So here's my question: Shouldn't I have disclosed in my listing that the seller was an a$$hole?
crealtys: (January 04, 2011 12:27pm)
Of course, anyone can sue anyone with or without grounds; but - - could they win? In Florida it is a violation of trust to disclose personal information about your client without their written consent. The seller in this case, however, could be held responsible for holding up a sale.
As a transaction broker in FL, we have a limited form of representation. Here are our duties:
1. Dealing honestly and fairly
2. Accounting for all funds
3. Using skill care and diligence in the transaction
4. Disclosing ALL known facts that MATERIALLY affect the value of the residential real property not observable to the buyer
5. Presenting all counter offers in a timely manner
6. LIMITED CONFIDENTIALITY, UNLESS WAIVED IN WRITING BY A PARTY (eg. divorce,health,lowest acceptible price)
7. Any additional duties that are entered into by this or a separate written agreement.
As transaction brokers, when working with both parties,we do not represent one party to the detriment of the other party.
RealtorPaul: (January 04, 2011 12:25pm)
Just a statement from a Realtor with 21 years of experience and at least a dozen closed divorce transactions. NO DISCLOSURE PERIOD. A divorce is not a material fact effecting the marketbility/value of a home therefore does not need to be disclosed nor should it. Judges in Michigan DO NOT set prices for homes that iis still left up to the home owners. A judge may enforce a contract if like in a a previous post "the wife went nuts and wouldn't close" which caused the buyers money. In Michigan if one spouse does not agree to performon a contract, the court will order it sold even without the "crazy" spouse being involved. I have been order by the courts to sign for a "crazy" husband who refused to perform. The buyer should never truly be harmed other than a possible delay in closing which can happen in any transaction for a variety of reasons such as, a cloud on title. So, not disclosing a divorce harms nobody and it has NO effect on the marketing or value of the property.
zorro1540: (January 04, 2011 12:07pm)
@GODLIKE: sure, the judge can set a list price, and the agent can state in MLS comments "we won't accept anything less than $X." That don't make it so! one of two things will happen, if the judge has set a list price above market value: a) NO offers are ever received. In fact, probably NO showings. or b) a sharp buyer makes a market-value-based offer and then an HVCC-compliant appraisal is ordered, confirming the lower-than-judge-ordered-mandatory-sales-price. And then it's back to the drawing board with the judge. JUDGES HAVE LOTS OF POWER, but i have yet to see a lender/investor that will cave to a judge-ordered price. Let me know how that works out for you!
louiseowensrealtor: (January 04, 2011 11:57am)
I am in Colorado and we are required to disclose material facts. I sold a house to buyers that after closing the neighbors asked them when were they getting a divorce since everyone who lived there (3) got a divorce. Of course they tried to blame me as if I would know this or be responsible as I was the buyers agent. I suggest to all buyers in writing that they may wish to contact some of the neighbors to see if they know why the seller is moving or what happened in the home or why it is for sale. This is not the Realtor's job it is the buyers job to investigate. Give them a list of things that may be important to know and list just about everything you can think of or have an attorney draw up one. Have the buyer sign and date it before you write the offer. Saved me on a home with termites after closing and buyers wouldn't inspect for that as they didn't want to pay for one.
GODLIKE: (January 04, 2011 11:49am)
PUZZ said "Should a disgruntled spouse decide they don't want to participate in the sale of the home, that is what the attorneys and judge are for so it will eventually get resolved." AT THE EXPENSE OF THE BUYER was obviously wasn't really an informed party to the contract!
GODLIKE: (January 04, 2011 11:48am)
NOEL you keep dancing all around it. They judges and the courts set a price that a property must be listed for based upon an appraisal and instruct the owners & agents they won't accept any offer except $X. Usually this comes about due to one party being unreasonable, which means there are some/many injured buyers in this process prior to the judge making the ruling. Unfortunately I've seen it first hand much more than once. Once with a close friend where I was intimately involved with the transaction having been a Realtor, Appraiser and Lender.
Puzz: (January 04, 2011 11:40am)
I don't thing that there should be a required disclosure notice for a couple going through a divorce. This is a way of tipping the hand of the seller and that the buyer would have a advantage in the negotiation process. If the buyer and the buyer's agent investigates the home and realizes that there are only a limited amount of furniture, only on sex clothes in the master closet, or that the tools are missing from the garage that could be a sign that the married couple that the seller's agent says lives int he home is just not seeing eye to eye. Besides, it does require the signature of both owners of the home to sell the home and to list the home with an agent doesn't it. Should a disgruntled spouse decide they don't want to participate in the sale of the home, that is what the attorneys and judge are for so it will eventually get resolved.
Noel Cookman: (January 04, 2011 11:39am)
GODLIKE: This gets even better. The appraiser states an "opinion of value" without the benefit of a contract offer (because the property has yet to be offered for sale) and in an appraisal not subject to underwriting muster. The judge, who knows absolutely nothing about how to read an appraisal and will have no idea that those 90% adjustments - and yes, it happens - might just mean that the value is mis-stated at best, then "sets the price."
Again, think about what someone is saying/thinking when they imagine that a judge can "set a price." A court can ONLY require that a property be listed. A stupid judge can set a price. Some judges MIGHT order "to be offered for sale at a price not less than $XYZ." But, the judge that thinks he/she can "set a price" merely floats around in his/her own morass of ignorance. But, you knew that. :)
GODLIKE: (January 04, 2011 11:30am)
BROKER AIMEE your story shows EXACTLY why a disclosure would be good. The injured party in your story is the poor buyer who lost out on the house. We don't know what other issues it caused for that poor buyer, but there's telling all their friends, making plans, was the moving van already loaded? Did they have to live in an apartment with all the added expenses? Were they able to find a comparable house? Did it cost marital or job issues?
GODLIKE: (January 04, 2011 11:27am)
NOELCOOKMAN I never said the judge can just make up a price, but he can set the price the house will be sold for. He does it with the help of an appraisal, but you knew that.
jackmaxwellbroker: (January 04, 2011 11:25am)
I think disclosure of a pending divorce is a bad idea. Disclosure would potentially weaken the seller's negotiating position and cost them equity. It's really non of the buyer's business and divorces often don't go through. Once an agreement has been reached to sell, both parties are obligated to follow through. Agents simply need to do more due diligence when taking the listing in the first place to make sure both husband and wife will cooperate with the sale.
zorro1540: (January 04, 2011 11:15am)
tongue-in-cheek: Let's disclose: * buyer or seller is taking vacation during escrow * listing or selling agent has surgery scheduled and will be unavailable for a few days * so-and-so uses such-and-such cell carrier, known for dropping calls * Loan officer's processor is known to call in sick on funding days * Escrow officer has an addiction likely to cause untimely abscences * Buyer's parents (brother/uncle/sister/aunt/adult children may get wind of purchase and have to put in their "two cents worth".
Really? The list is endless and divorce/separation/squabbles will happen and i agree with everyone that said "NO MORE DISCLOSURES. USE LEGAL REMEDIES ALREADY IN PLACE"
James H: (January 04, 2011 11:14am)
I'm a broker, had my sellers in escrow at $1.675K in 2008 ready to close. The ex-wife went nuts in the transaction. Caused the buyer to cancel. Had the sellers $50K of buyers deposit, she still would not settle. Ended up in court for 2 years. Got the sellers $35k of the buyers deposit instead of the $50k. House is now in default. Had to go to court 5 times for one of the sellers. Had to give a contract lesson to the ex-wife's attorney in court. Just got a court order to sell the property, new list price $1.3 and dropping fast!
Atty4Realtors: (January 04, 2011 11:11am)
I agree, figuring out what is material and what is not is difficult. The only way to protect yourself is to step into the shoes of the buyer and honestly ask whether you would want to know the fact if you were the one buying the house. If things go wrong, the agent is going to get sued whether he or she was at fault or not. Then the plaintiff's lawyer is going to get you on the stand or in a deposition and say "You knew about this and you hid it because you wanted to get a commission. You put your own interests ahead of your obligation to disclose material facts." This stuff always looks bad in hindsight. If you already disclosed it in writing, the lawsuit will go away and you won't have to spend the money defending yourself.
donleon: (January 04, 2011 10:50am)
It seems to me there is a difference between material facts ABOUT THE PROPERTY and facts about the sellers. Material facts about the property should be disclosed. Personal circumstances regarding the sellers are not disclosable unless it is KNOWN that it will affect the buyers ability to get clear title or it affects the condition of the property. What might happen doesn't seem to me to fall into this category. Maybe it is just me....
Cleo: (January 04, 2011 10:31am)
Att4Realtors - if you consider divorce a material fact then wouldn't it be a material fact if the seller is mentally ill? depressed? a drug addict? has a child with a terminal illness? Having dealt with all of these I find cooperation and communication between agents is the crucial factor. To disclose peoples personal challenges to the world is just wrong. As others have stated disclosing divorce can hurt the sales price and terms and damage the sellers financially. Wouldn't that be grounds for lawsuit? Most that are divorcing just want it done. The hold out usually just doesn't want to let go. Then it's time for the attorney to deal with it from the legal angle. Not us agents.
cspirrello: (January 04, 2011 10:24am)
In Arizona to disclose an impending divorce would only be done with written permission of the sellers. It can be suggested by the agent to do so to sellers, but personal information not related to the property itself need not be disclosed. It can also be disclosed at the time of an offer should the sellers agree it could impact the outcome of the transaction.
jjeffskie: (January 04, 2011 10:22am)
You should definitely disclose divorce on the seller disclosure. It's actually pending litigation and in Pa you need to disclose it. I know this all too well, as I was involved in a nasty law suite when the wife refused to move out of the home and never signed the the listing contract. My buyer wasn't very happy!
KristiR: (January 04, 2011 10:22am)
DIFFERENT TOPIC: Frank & Brian: many mortgage brokers need to provide Financial Statements to satisfy NMLS requirements by 3/31/2011. The corporations all have firms to prepare theirs, but any thoughts on providing guidance, templates etc for the sole proprietors who are not required to provide an audited statement. Might be a nice thing for brokers who don't really want to spend another $400 or more on a CPA after all the other fees NMLS has gouged us for.
Cleo: (January 04, 2011 10:18am)
If we have to disclose divorce then we'd have to disclose all kinds of personal stuff that can affect the transactions - where would the line be drawn. It is my experience (20 years at this) that once there is an accepted offer most agents let the other agent know that there is a divorce in progress and what the situation is. Sometimes before - which should only be done with the sellers permission. I think disclosures should stay with information affecting the property not the owners.
BrokerAimee: (January 04, 2011 10:11am)
Brian and Frank..
"Lovely", "polite",soon to be"ex", Mr & Mrs Seller list home with Broker Aimee. PA is signed.Buyer is ready to close. 1 week before closing Mr. Seller vanishes off to some remote location in Montana to live off the "fat of the land". He is nowhere to be found. Buyer walks. Mrs. Seller goes to the bar. Her attorney goes to the Judge. Time and dollars passed and we can, once again, sell the house without the Wild Western Cowboy involved. Mrs. Seller ends up getting $8,000 less for the house and had to pay the 1st buyers for the inspection and appraisal costs. It was a drag. BUT..would this have been avoided if we were required to disclose divorce? I don't think so. The question is, will a required disclosure for divorce help anyone avoid potential craziness that comes from it? Each case is so incredibly different. Many are civil and manditory disclosure doesn't seem prudent in those situations. Just my thought. Also, are you sure ghosts REALLY need to be disclosed?
NewParadigm: (January 04, 2011 10:09am)
ps - if divorce is disclosed, wouldn't buyers see this as a bad thing and screen the listings they select for viewing based on this criteria?
NewParadigm: (January 04, 2011 10:07am)
The listing agent works for the sellers ... right? Seller pays commission and supposedly has the agent representing his best interest. So why should a Realtor sabotage the potential for sale by disclosing personal information about the couple that may or may not cause a delay in closing? Too many things can delay or kill closings - like the lender taking forever to close the loan until the rules change or the buyer gets laid off. There could be a hurricane that destroys the house. The house could get seized in police action ... Unless real estate agents want to be like TSA agents, groping and stripping sellers just in case they find a pimple that if squeezed, might stain the carpet, stick to disclosures about the house.
KristiR: (January 04, 2011 9:54am)
A divorce does not necessarily mean that the sellers are unreasonable or unusually motivated. Several of my clients over the last 20 years have been divorced, and like any other seller, the majority still want to receive the highest reasonable price in the shortest amount of time. Bad feelings or not, 50% of a bigger number is better than 50% of a smaller number and most adults understand that.
Atty4Realtors: (January 04, 2011 9:45am)
State laws require that material facts must be disclosed. “Material” facts are facts that could make a difference to the buyer. If a seller is afraid of disclosing something because it might wreck the deal, then it is material. If the agent is aware of a fact that the seller isn’t willing to disclose, many state laws say that the agent has an independent duty to disclose it. The same laws strip away the confidential nature of such facts, so there is no confidentiality problem. Divorce is usually material because the divorce court could delay the closing. It is also not confidential because it is a matter of public record.
Getting clients to disclose material information also protects agents from the lawsuit that will be filed when the buyers decide that they paid too much and need somebody to blame.
Noel Cookman: (January 04, 2011 9:31am)
GODLIKE. I'm so happy that I'm wrong about a judge being able to "set a price." I had already agreed with you that a judge can order a "listing for sale."
But, now that I'm wrong, I know a judge who can ORDER my home's price at $500,000 even though it's only worth $300,00. This is incredible. I think we have just found a way out of the depressed real estate market - judges. I didn't realize they could set prices. I could never be happier to have been wrong.
Gabecaplan: (January 04, 2011 9:25am)
Relax with the views of dress code. There is plenty of time to wear a suit when you’re buried. Time and place for every fashion.
Joebob: (January 04, 2011 9:19am)
Wow a call for ANOTHER disclosure. Nope. No doubt this is a cruel situation for both buyers and sellers agents. However, it can be handled properly ONLY by the sellers agent. Here's where the rubber meets the road in Real Estate. If the sellers agent does not handle this properly, and resolve the often acrimonious transactions with tact and reasonableness....the deal will PROBABLY be sabotaged and fail. Fact of life...that a disclosure really wouldn't help. The reality is that on the one hand this would add to the onerousess of the process, and on the other, it would also make the property less appealing offerwise. Neither benefit the process or the participants.
RealtorPaul: (January 04, 2011 9:16am)
Disclosures are about things that effect marketability/value of a home a divorce does not effect anything. There might be a bit of a delay in closing on SOME divorces but, that has not been my experience. All these statements are subject to the state laws where the home is located. Divorces pending, finalized are all going to show up on title work so, all parties can prepare for the possibility of a delayed closing. No disclosure required!
bainemc: (January 04, 2011 9:14am)
Sorry to say, but I'm a bit mixed on the issue. On one hand, if you have to disclose a divorce, this could give the buyers a bargaining chip.. as the sellers have to sell and make lower offers. It would always be good to have all the facts in the transaction... but the transaction is still governed by the Contract itself, including what happens when the transaction does close as per contract. Maybe after the contract is complete and after any preliminary cancellation period.
AZGirl: (January 04, 2011 9:14am)
Our state (Arizona) doesn't require disclosure regarding deaths of any sort...even murders...in a home for sale. I think the definition of "material facts" needs to be explored more thoroughly. I agree completely that disclosing a divorce will harm the seller(s)'s ability to get the highest price possible and disclosure is not in their best interest...hence definition of "fiduciary" as already mentioned.
GODLIKE: (January 04, 2011 9:09am)
REALTORPAUL I haven't had a husband or wife threaten me with a shotgun (yet) but I have had the husband put his fist thru the wall of the closers office. While I have seen a few divorce deals close in a timely fashion they all have required more work on the lender/title company/Realtor's part to get there. Buyers have all been scared it wouldn't happen on time. Bottom line is the Buyers wouldn't have entered into the contract had they known and that's what disclosures are all about.
GODLIKE: (January 04, 2011 9:06am)
NOEL COOKMAN you are wrong about the court not being able to order a sale or a price during a divorce. My best friend had the judge set the price and require the sale.
GetReal: (January 04, 2011 9:04am)
Only material facts about the property are required in the seller's disclosure statement. Not ghosts or deaths, because such items are not facts (ghosts) or material (deaths) to the condition of the property. Far more important, but currently not required, for disclosure would be something like nearby railroad tracks or high tension power lines or a sex predator neighbor. Some states are "community property" states where both spouses are implicitly titled to the property even when only one spouse is actually on the title. Both spouses must consent to the conveyance...sigh...and if they are in the middle of a divorce... good luck with that!
Terry06877: (January 04, 2011 8:56am)
Pendings are litigation on the public court record as soon as you file for divorce ...the decree is issued after the bloodbath is over - been there. In fact I'm writing another check today !
Love you guys, but if you push for more paperwork, I'll be drinking the Jameson that Brian was dipping into the other day. That was an awesome daily !
Ashtonteam@KW: (January 04, 2011 8:55am)
Ah...gentlemen, there is the issue of "fiduciary" responsibility. If the divorce has no material effect on the value of the home, it should not be disclosed. To do so could possible solicite lower offers from buyers, believing the seller to be in a distressed situation. Thus, the listing agent did not represent their seller properly. If the law does not require disclosure, it is the agents responsibility to do what is in the best interest of the persons represented. As long as it does not adversly effect the value of the property.
Regarding NAR, this will fall on deaf ears. Each state has different laws guiding this issue and NAR isn't going to want to take on 50 different Realtor associations.
Last, there are many divorce situations that sell with proper behavior. Those that don't may be sued for performance.
Noel Cookman: (January 04, 2011 8:45am)
Let's not confuse "pending divorce" with a divorce that has already been granted with a decree (court order). I could be wrong but I think the discussion assumed pending divorces ("separating couples"). Final divorces are obviously governed by the decree but only child possession orders are commonly enforced by police.
Frank and Brian - are referring to pending? or past? or both?
kim: (January 04, 2011 8:42am)
I just finished going through Real Esate classes and disclosing that there was a death, murder, or a number of other events in the house listed or even in the neighborhood is absolutely not allowed in my state. As for disclosing a separation that may or may not lead to a divorce, I would say that only if both parties are going to be on the loan should it be disclosed. If only one party is going to be on the loan and deed, they are qualified for the loan using only the debt they are liable for and their income and resources. Why should the bank be required to know about any of their personal business? I spoke with an attorney and was told that with a house that was acquired prior to a divorce, but in only one of the married couples name, would not affect that purchase. They would not be required to sell it or disturb the financing in place. The only time it would become an issue is if the property has been in place for a time long enough to have acquired significant equity.
c21actgp: (January 04, 2011 8:41am)
Hey Frank, you do not have to disclose a death in a property.
LynnM: (January 04, 2011 8:41am)
Noel:
I like your idea of a buyer's disclosure statements. Nice twist!
Lynnell
LynnM: (January 04, 2011 8:37am)
Frank and Brian love you guys and your show. Though you may be a bit off base on this issue with divorce. Thanks Glenn Roberts who points out that death and ghosts are NOT required material disclosures in WA. And Rob who points that they are not in MOST states. Guys, NAR has nothing to do with this. It is at the state level that disclosures are regulated, NOT at the National level. Many viewer's points are well taken on fiduciary responsibility to the client. Lynnell
Noel Cookman: (January 04, 2011 8:35am)
Sorry for the double post. But, here's another one. Why should the sellers (and agent) not receive disclosures from the buyers about potential life situations that could derail the transaction? All they get is a piece of paper that says they're approved for a loan and an LO who says "Legally, I can't discuss my borrower's particulars with anyone." What about buyers who are getting a divorce? (Don't think it doesn't happen). The possibilities are endless.
We should be encouraging less petty, unhelpful and useless regulations - not more!
RealtorPaul: (January 04, 2011 8:33am)
GODLIKE, I was refering to professional agents that have the knowledge onhow to handle a divorce sale. I was once threatened by a husband with a shotgun blast to the head because the courts ordered the home sold and for me to sign to for the husband. Deal closed in a timely matter, that's what the courts and divorce decrees are for.
RealtorPaul: (January 04, 2011 8:32am)
GODLIKE, I was refering to professional agents that have the knowledge onhow to handle a divorce sale. I was once threatened by a husband with a shotgun blast to the head because the courts ordered the home sold and for me to sign to for the husband. Deal closed in a timely matter, that's what the courts and divorce decrees are for.
Noel Cookman: (January 04, 2011 8:31am)
To GODLIKE's post - the vast majority of sales DURING a divorce (rather than post divorce) are NOT ordered by the court. And a judge can NEVER set a sales price. In the USA it's still against the law to require someone to purchase something (forget Obamacare for the time being). A judge MIGHT (and this is very rare) set an OFFER price. [I realize this sounds like a petty point, but you would be surpised by how many people speak as if a court can "order" a sale rather than order a "listing for sale."] But, the more likely scenario is that if a couple does not agree on terms of sale, a "receiver" is appointed. This is a person who, for all practical purposes, owns the property and can execute any/all documents in the transaction, needing absolutely no sellers' cooperation.
Still cannot see any legal, logical or reasonable purpose in requiring disclosure of a pending divorce.
Noel Cookman: (January 04, 2011 8:30am)
To GODLIKE's post - the vast majority of sales DURING a divorce (rather than post divorce) are NOT ordered by the court. And a judge can NEVER set a sales price. In the USA it's still against the law to require someone to purchase something (forget Obamacare for the time being). A judge MIGHT (and this is very rare) set an OFFER price. [I realize this sounds like a petty point, but you would be surpised by how many people speak as if a court can "order" a sale rather than order a "listing for sale."] But, the more likely scenario is that if a couple does not agree on terms of sale, a "receiver" is appointed. This is a person who, for all practical purposes, owns the property and can execute any/all documents in the transaction, needing absolutely no sellers' cooperation.
Still cannot see any legal, logical or reasonable purpose in requiring disclosure of a pending divorce.
llequire1: (January 04, 2011 8:30am)
After reading all the comments, it is quite apparent that this should not be discussed as a national option (NAR). Maybe state level (but not California...puhleaze not another disclosure)
ruben: (January 04, 2011 8:28am)
I've had this issue come up quite a bit. As a matter of fact, I have one transaction in process right now that is not going to close because the ex-spouse moved to Australia and now can't be found. She is on title. I don't think we necessarily need a "divorce" disclosure. However, EVERYONE on title should be required to sign the sales contract and an additional disclosure should be included naming ANY OTHER PERSON (spouse or not) who has a legal interest in the property and whos cooperation is needed to complete the sale.
RealtorPaul: (January 04, 2011 8:28am)
In the 90's I was known as the divorce "king" had 7 in one year. It is definetly like walking a tight rope. But, if you point out facts, don't take side be professional and things can go much smoother. When yoou have one of the "difficult" divorces you have a court order to have the home sold, working with clients attorneys the deal will close. I have not experienced these long delays readers are reporting.
ghostwriter: (January 04, 2011 8:28am)
In Oregon we legally aren't allowed to disclose when a death has happened in the home we are selling. Many agents are unaware of this and do so, but they are not supposed to.
GODLIKE: (January 04, 2011 8:22am)
REALTOR PAUL you said "Therefore, the unreasonable personalities sometimes involved in a divorce should have little or no effect on getting the home sold and closed, it has been ordered by the courts!" Obviously you have never been involved in, known anyone who was involved in nor ever had a transaction where a divorce was involved in the mix. Cops and courts say you can't speed so no one should have an issue with that either.
GODLIKE: (January 04, 2011 8:20am)
The "slippery slope" argument has been used on every required disclosure ever made law. Yes, obviously it is a slippery slope since we keep adding disclosures. But there's a reason for these disclosure which is because they do affect whether a buyer would have bought a specific home had they known the issue.
GODLIKE: (January 04, 2011 8:19am)
I've had numerous divorce deals. I've only had 1-2 go as smoothly as a non-divorcing couple. Buyers get furious when they finally find out what all the delays and hold ups are! I've had a couple lose earnest money and just back out because they didn't have the luxury of time to deal with the issues. It always affects closing time as paperwork can be much more complicated and then there's the "little" issue of not being able to have both sellers in the same title company office, much less the same closing room at the same time.
RealtorPaul: (January 04, 2011 8:17am)
TOTALLY disagre about divorce disclosure!!! We make it hard enough to by a home in this market place, let's not make it worse. But, more importantly the disclosure law is for items that effect the marketability/value of the home. Divorce can cause problems during the transaction and in reality 90% of divorce decrees addrress what is to be done with the house. Therefore, the unreasonable personalities sometimes involved in a divorce should have little or no effect on getting the home sold and closed, it has been ordered by the courts!
Terry06877: (January 04, 2011 8:15am)
In CT a pending divorce is a litigation in court, so it is a matter of public record. The listing agent has an obligation to protect the seller's interest.
The SELLING agent has the obligation to get the best price and look for issues ...what did the seller pay, mortgages, etc - they have actual notice available online about pending divorces too. If the selling realtor does their job, the information is easily available.
Terry06877: (January 04, 2011 8:14am)
In CT a pending divorce is a litigation in court, so it is a matter of public record. The listing agent has an obligation to protect the seller's interest.
The SELLING agent has the obligation to get the best price and look for issues ...what did the seller pay, mortgages, etc - they have actual notice available online about pending divorces too. If the selling realtor does their job, the information is easily available.
GODLIKE: (January 04, 2011 8:13am)
As far as divorce weakening the Sellers marketing position, many people (and all agents should know) realize that in a divorce many times the judge determines the sales price not the other 2 parties. They are usually fueding and can't decide upon anything. How did a judge get involved? They messed up some other buyer(s?) life with previous contracts that didn't close. Both parties need to enter the contract with both eyes wide open. They can't if info is hidden from one party.
GODLIKE: (January 04, 2011 8:10am)
SELLAHOME123 a murder most definitely has something to do with value! Most people don't want to live in a home where someone has died, much less one where someone's been murdered -especially a grizzly one!
Noel Cookman: (January 04, 2011 8:05am)
...moreover...the more I think about this and the responses, the more worked up I get. By what principle does a seller's divorce affect the (intrinsic, actual) VALUE, CONDITION OR TITLE of a property? Perhaps a case could be made for disclosing "receivership." But, in that case, disagreement between spouses is a non-factor. This is not only a "slippery slope" it's an entirely different mountain.
JoeParsons: (January 04, 2011 7:56am)
I think for NAR to even *consider* discussing this issue is silly. A "slippery slope" argument could say that an agent must disclose whether the spouses have had an argument within the last three months, or whether they are in relationship counseling. If the two parties have entered into contract, they are bound by it, even if they are not speaking to each other. It is the job of the listing agent to make sure that the two spouses understand the ramifications of not performing--the buyer's remedy of filing a specific performance lawsuit. There are no good reasons to have to disclose pending divorce, and plenty of reasons not to--privacy being one of them. WRT your opening: I like it (and the vintage look) better than the earlier, frenetic version. It does the intro job nicely and doesn't chew up valuable time. Brian, your grunge look is okay, but when is your actual beard coming in?
GODLIKE: (January 04, 2011 7:33am)
I definitely feel a divorce should be disclosed. The buyer has the right to know what they are stepping into. If they go into the transaction they need this info to be able to make their own plans and decide if they want to get into this mess.
Mandy: (January 04, 2011 7:31am)
Buyer's love any reason to offer less money for a property and to open that can of worms would just be a start. What if someone has had cancer, or what if they have some other terminal disease like Aids. Then should we disclose that a same sex couple lived here. The list could just get crazy.
PensacolaBill: (January 04, 2011 7:30am)
I have had sales fall apart because either the wife or husband (whichever one is the maddest) not sign sales aggreements. I have also had one party or another not close. It is very important to my buyers to know this up front and should be disclosed.
Koolaidspitter: (January 04, 2011 7:18am)
Talk about not being able to see the forest for the trees....BEARD COMMENTS????? Seriously???? Maybe the critics can post links to their video blogs so you can see how to properly "be professional". Give me a break. You guys are fine.
Noel Cookman: (January 04, 2011 7:14am)
If you "lose the new beard" and the "stupid opening" - in other words if you are no longer unique and interesting - it would be less likely that I would tune in often. I might not do it the way you do it - but, you have a few more viewers than I have.
mountains: (January 04, 2011 7:14am)
In NC as with other states, you have a fiduciary responsibility to your seller. The only way you can disclose, is if the sellers allows you to. Perhaps years ago sellers would not want this, but today sellers are just glad to get a buyer, so I would say most would not care as long as they sold the house. It is not as if sellers are walking away with a lot of money these days. We have more problems with sellers not being honest about late mortgage payments and possible foreclosure proceedings. NCAR just changed our listing contracts requiring sellers to disclose any possible foreclosures or late payments because of this problem. Do not waist your time with NAR, they will not do it!
sgkeath: (January 04, 2011 7:11am)
An agent cannot disclose anthing detrimental to their client without their express permission. They can refuse the listing, but they can't hurt their client. Besides, what if the buyer passes because of the agent telling about the sellers getting a divorce and the sellers get back to gether. Have the buyers been hurt?
Noel Cookman: (January 04, 2011 7:00am)
I work with divorce situations quite a bit. Your reasoning - that one party in a divorce could sabatoge the transaction - is a stretch. Should a contract (disclosure) anticipate every conceivable situation that only MIGHT be present? That's a never-ending quest. What if the parent or child of one of the sellers is very sick and nigh unto death? What if one of the sellers has cancer? What if one of the sellers takes Rx for depression, anxiety, bi-polar, et al? There are hundreds of situations that could sabatoge a transaction! There is only one reason that a divorcing couple should disclose their pending action - to invite a 20% or greater reduction in offer price.
Moreover, the actual rule could be very prejudicial for reconciled couples. For example, would the state that sellers had to disclose IF they had filed for divorce in the past 3 months, 6 months, 12 months, 24 months? If not, what would keep couples from withdrawing their divorce filing for the house sale?
Slims: (January 04, 2011 6:52am)
Invasion of privacy, who cares & what's the difference between married couples fighting & causing buyer delays? There are enough people already on the hook to blame the delays - LO's for example LOL. Just more intrusion into our personal lives.
CharlesinMD: (January 04, 2011 6:34am)
Disclose divorce? - Sticky wicket for the listing agent who owes their fiduciary duty to the seller to get them the best price and terms on the sale of their house. I know that in the past as a buyer's agent, we have seen cases where the buyer was able to hammer out a better deal when a seller's separation or divorce was inadvertently discovered. What's next? Disclose uncooperative selling spouses? If a party to a contract fails to live up to the agreement there are legal remedies.
Ezradams: (January 04, 2011 6:24am)
Deaths by natural cause do not have to be disclosed. But, a murder is another story. If a death by murder stigmatizes the property it needs to be disclosed. I had one of these cases as an appraiser and was surprised when the listing agent did not disclose it. (There was a significant affect on value.) I was fortunate to find 3 comparables in the area and at the time and found a 20% negative affect on value.
GlennRoberts: (January 04, 2011 6:18am)
Ghosts and deaths in the home are not a disclosure item in Washington state. If the agent or seller believes that the divorce may cause a problem with the closing of the transaction it should be noted. I've seen many cases where it is not an issue and the sales close. It's not necessary for the buyer to know.
dsharp: (January 04, 2011 6:18am)
Yes, a "pending" divorce should be disclosed to all parties and service providers. If known, there's real estate proceedures to minimize a shipwreck at closing. In fact, I recall a spouse going to jail for refusing to execute closing documents.
lisajonz: (January 04, 2011 6:15am)
BTW, I think you guys look great. Don't change a thing. The best dressed person could be the biggest oaf and most unprofessional. Appearance isn't everything folks.
lisajonz: (January 04, 2011 6:13am)
In today's market, buyer;s think everyone is in a tough situation and they can get something for nothing. I don;t think disclosing a divorce would affect the sale's price either way; if the house is priced right and you have an agent who knows how to counsel their clients on negotiations. One party to the divorce is likely to be more motivated to get out than another and that will play a part in it all as well. I have seen divorce sales run smooth and I have seen divorce sales where it was like pulling teeth to get anything done. Each situation is different. Also, FL does not require death/murder to be disclosed unless you are asked specifically.
rob: (January 04, 2011 6:13am)
First it is NOT mandatory to disclose a death or ghost in all states. Those are subjective issues and not scientific facts, maybe in the broke I mean great state of CA it may be a fact.
However I agree with the reasons a divorce need to be disclosed, I also would like to point out that disclosing something that could weaken the negotiation power of your client is a violation of the agent's fiduciary.
I don't think NAR will fight that fight at this time, there are other issues to fight right now.
sellahome123: (January 04, 2011 6:10am)
You are not required to disclose if there was a murder or ghost in a home. Has nothing to do with the value.
TomD: (January 04, 2011 5:55am)
As someone else said, lose the new beard and cut out the stupid opening. Not real professional.
I'm in NY and as I understand the laws here, as a listing agent I would have a fiduciary duty to the seller not to disclose the potential divorce because it can obviously have an adverse effect on the sales price.
Ezradams: (January 04, 2011 5:45am)
If a divorce property is properly priced for the market, and available for showings (in good condition), I don't know how the situation would affect the eventual selling price. This is where a good Realtor can handle a potentially messy situation and make a divorce proceeding invisible to the market. If, on the other hand, the house is a mess, and the partner living there doesn't allow showings, the selling price will probably suffer (not typical motivation). Good question!
donleon: (January 04, 2011 5:40am)
No, divorce should not be disclosed. If both parties have signed the listing agreement, then both have agreed to sell. It is in the sellers' best interest to listen to their listing agent and put the feelings toward each other aside and cooperate and the listing agent just needs to make them understand that. To Gary, who responded down below: your issue wasn't the divorce. Your issue was the house payment hadn't been made for several months and the house was about to be foreclosed on. You don't have to have a divorce going on to have that as an issue. Fiduciary duty to the seller here says no, you do not disclose a divorce. Do you feel like a buyer or buyer's agent should have to disclose that the reason a couple is buying a house is because they are contemplating divorce and they feel like they must make one last attempt at making it by "starting fresh"? Well, there is just as much chance of that transaction not making it to the closing table as one of them snaps to their senses.
TC: (January 04, 2011 5:39am)
No one should be required to air their dirty laundry. Certainly if there is a lein filed on the property it should be disclosed. Personally more owners and buyers should ask their attorneys to do the Title Search earlier in the process rather than later to find many potential issues. BUT, lets not make the sellers have to air that little nugget. Lets remember they are just begining the negotiation process.
1toppro: (January 04, 2011 5:19am)
In Virginia disclosure of a divorce is not required - quite the opposite actually - it's generally considered UNethical (unless required by law) to disclosure such matters to the buyer or any other agent UNLESS seller instructs you to do so (not happening) - but sharp agents and most buyers can tell - "her" clothes are missing from the closet, furniture is missing (w/indents in the carpet), bachelor pad "itus", nothing but beer in the refrigerator, etc. The point is, it's no one's business and IF the listing agent has done their job (copy of separation agreement, both parties have signed listing agreement and any unique or special terms of the divorce are disclosed in order to clarify the financial terms, etc.
I have handled hundreds of divorce cases and the first thing I do is tell them that I don't take sides, I won't play games and neither will they when it comes to settlement and disbursement of any equity funds. Stuff happens but it's a simple matter of "doing your job".
llequire1: (January 04, 2011 5:12am)
In California, you do have to disclose the death of someone in/on the property within the last 2 years. But disclosing divorce is just silly.
Real Estate Nate: (January 04, 2011 5:09am)
Divorce shows motivation and revealing a seller's motivation can result in a lower sales price. The job of the listing agent is to ask questions before listing the home: Are you current? Do you both want to sell? How fast do you need to sell? Can I call your divorce attorneys to discuss how the proceeds (if any) will impact the settlement? If the listing agent does their job, many potential problems can be avoided.
Patriot Games: (January 04, 2011 5:00am)
Stick to mortgages guys. You don't have a clue about real estate disclosures. People die in houses all the time. Death does not necessarily become a material fact which effects the value of a home. Ghosts are another story. (No pun intended.) Talking to NAR? You'd be wasting your time.
KKS: (January 04, 2011 4:57am)
Re BOAHL and FNMA and Freddie - you miss an important issue. When BOA "agreed" to take CWC the government "agreed" to give BOAHL 4 bil over then next 10 yrs. Also with that is estimated at least 4 bill in tax breaks due to "losses" and "write offs". So 8 billion. Also BOA "only agreed" because they could with such cash infusion hide how truly insolvent they are and be able to bump up their stock prices. Note yesterdays frenzy stock increase due to the "announcement." Hmmmm....and FNMA and Freddie are asking for about 7.7 bill in total. See, thanks to "stimulus" we the tax payer are truly paying for these bad loans and BOA loses Nothing! Nothing at all thanks to "agreements". So of course, BOAHL will pay FNMA and Freddie as they are not paying with their moneys and thus not losing a dime. How cool is that!....NOT!
Divedude: (January 04, 2011 4:53am)
Jersy Girl: This is in West Springfield, MA. The attorney could'nt stop laughing either!
Jersey Girl: (January 04, 2011 4:40am)
Divedude: LOL what state and county is this in?
GaryTheRealtor: (January 04, 2011 4:32am)
YES it should be disclosed. My last closing of 2010 was just this situation. Sellers were getting a divorce and no one had made the the house payment for over 5 months and we didn't know that the house was about to be forclosed on. My buyers needed in the home by the end of the year. They were living in a hotel because they were RELO. We did close just in time before the bank took the next step. However the listing agent cut her commision because the sellers would not bring any money to the table. And oh by the why. The sellers recieved insurance moeny to put a new roof on the home after Ike and guess what didn't do it. So the listing agent got a roofer to put a new roof on so we could close and wait to get pai paid out of closing. Don' you know he might have needed to know as well.
Double T: (January 04, 2011 4:28am)
Guys, lose the new facial hair. You look shabby. You talk about professionalism in the mortgage industry but you look like two homeless guys on tv. Clean up and you'll make a better presentation.
Divedude: (January 04, 2011 4:19am)
Absolutely disclose any hostile situation. I'm doing an appraisal right now for a family estate where the sister tried to have the brother whacked. She paid a homeless person $10,000 cash and showed him where to put the body. The homeless guy went to the brother and told him, "Your sister really hates you!". He gave the money to the brother and left. The brother want's him for a witness to prosecute the sister but they can't find him now. I hope they like my appraisal!!
AS a fiduciary advocate of the seller, the listing agent should not disclose a divorce situation unless the divorce publicly stigmatized the property. Perhaps they should be required to obtain certification from the divorce attorneys that their fees or the courts will not interfere with the sale. The listing agent should make sure the listing agreement is bonafide. The agent should check for any court ordered equitable distribution agreement, bankruptcy filings, and/or potential short sale circumstance. The listing agent should make sure beforehand all owners and interested parties agree to sell including the courts and lawyers involved.
debtdoctor: (January 04, 2011 3:19am)
um, no guys. are buyers ever going through a divorce? How about a job loss, or any other traumatic event? according to this logic, sellers and buyers should disclose anything in their lives (a parent who may be giving money, a child with cancer, etc.) that may cause distress to a transaction. One of the main functions of an agent is confidentiality. One of the main benefits to have a negotiator on your behalf is to minimize, diminish, and even conceal these types of things from negatively impacting negotiations. If this argument were accepted for divorce, then it could be argued for any medical, financial, or relational upheaval. It punishes people who go through reasonable divorce. Not eveyone is like Frank.