Racheli: (February 09, 2011 8:02am)
VA Loans Rock
But, If the Fed’s Rule on Originator Compensation goes through who will pay the costs that cannot be paid by a VA borrower?
We will not be allowed...
Chuck@HRC: (February 08, 2011 8:22am)
Joephoto5: Slight correction to your post- the FHA 235 program was a subsidized-payment program were the total housing expense was means-tested (for low-income borrowers) with te FHA remitting the difference between the total payment and the maximum means-tested payment to the servicer. The program you described was the FHA 245 (Graduated-Payment) Program. Your point on POA's payment shock is generally correct, although I cannot agree that "they (borrowers) didn't know".
JoeParsons: (February 08, 2011 7:49am)
Here is how "pay option" or "pick-a-pay" loans *actually* worked, contrary to what some seem to believe: A loan of $155,000 whose actual (indexed) rate was, say, 7.5% could have a "pay rate" of 1%. This meant that instead of paying the amortized payment of $1,084, the borrower could pay $500 instead, deferring the interest. The monthly payment would increase 7.5% per year--$536, then $576, and so on, until the balance grew to a level where it would "recast." That amount would be anywhere between 110% and 125% of the original balance. When that happened, the borrower could no longer make the minimum payment, but would have to pay an amount that would amortize the loan over its remaining term. The example $155,000 loan would hit 115% at about year 5, depending on what happened to the index. At that point, the payment would increase to $1,316. These loans were certainly toxic at times, but not quite as horrible as has been represented here.
Chuck@HRC: (February 08, 2011 6:54am)
5pence: Check out the Fed's February 1st announcement on their "forced" TILA reform: http://www.federalreserve.gov/newsevents/press/bcreg/20110201a.htm. This is definitive, regardless of Mr. Mondor's response!
iam 2520: (February 07, 2011 10:48pm)
Late entry but after reading most of the posts it comes down to character, residual $ underwriting, strict property standards (roofs,paint,systems ect)and cost controls towards the Vet. Ass on the line = Skin in the game in my books. Besides unless you are closing with 8-10% in E Q U I T Y...your upside~down. VA loans have a qualified assumption pervision with MAY prevent some foreclosures as well. LASTLY... remember the $8,000.00 for QUALIFIED VA BUYERS...still here til June. Help a Vet Buy a home ... and a bank sell a unperforming asset... Make'm pay as well, get some of the T.A.R.P. $ back !
joephoto5: (February 07, 2011 6:39pm)
The 235 was another form of "neg-am" when some interest was defered back when the rates were approaching 18% in the late '70's - early '80's.
I am also not in favor of SEM (Equity Share), but they can be a viable option in some cases. They are certainly not as bad as the the "pay-option" when they could only afford their initial payment of $500/mo, (cause min-wage, SSI or SS), and thus could NEVER-EVER have any chance of keeping that home when their payment was automatically scheduled to increase to $2000+ after the first year. ESPECIALLY when many were NEVER TOLD their $500/mo would ever increase. Most/Many that got those loans really thought that $500/mo was their permanent payment. (Some, that were aware their payment would increase, but that they could simply "refi" and start over again with $500/mo. in 1-3 years. That worked until the values/equity collapsed. Some people refi'ed 3 - 4 times for more money each time, with new $500/mo payments, but higher principles. )
5pence: (February 07, 2011 5:57pm)
Bush Cancels Visit To Switzerland Due To Threat Of Torture Prosecution, Rights Groups Say. GENEVA, Feb 5 (Reuters) - Former U.S. President George W. Bush has cancelled a visit to Switzerland, where he was to address a Jewish charity gala, due to the risk of legal action against him for alleged torture, rights groups said on Saturday. Bush was to be the keynote speaker at Keren Hayesod's annual dinner on Feb. 12 in Geneva. But pressure has been building on the Swiss government to arrest him and open a criminal investigation if he enters the Alpine country. Criminal complaints against Bush alleging torture have been lodged in Geneva, court officials say.
Human rights groups said they had intended to submit a 2,500-page case against Bush in the Swiss city on Monday for alleged mistreatment of suspected militants at Guantanamo Bay, the U.S. naval base in Cuba where captives from Afghanistan, Iraq and other fronts in the so-called War on Terror were interned.
USA Realty, LLC: (February 07, 2011 5:38pm)
Joe, now that I have your attention .. I do have many misconceptions by todays new financing programs and I have no intent selling a home to a Vet and VA loan any time soon. Thanks for looking out for me. The point is, what your thoughts on S.E.M.
joephoto5: Have you or any body out there know what an old FHA 235 program was all about?
joephoto5: (February 07, 2011 4:44pm)
USDAman ... you don't seem to know what I meant by the "PAY-Option" loans. (There also ARM but that was not the killer factor) BUT with a "pay" option, instead of making a normal PI payment of maybe $2500/mo or Interest-only of $2000/mo, you could do a NEGATIVE AMORTIZATION option of only $500 or $600/mo. (Resulting in their loan-balance increasing $1500-$2000/mo.) AND, as mentioned loan-originators often falsified loan-aps to show an income of up to $6000/mo when their actual income was min-wage, or SSI, or SS of maybe less than $1000/mo. SO, they could indeed pay the $500 for the first-year, but soon found the BOMB exploding the second-third year when it started escalating to its eventual $2500/mo after about 5 years. I still maintain that 99% of those loans have collapsed. (and many were seniors, I know because I did Reverse Mortgages and got the emergency calls when they realized they had been scammed); I was able to "resuce" many until the prices fell to where they are now.
JoeParsons: (February 07, 2011 4:15pm)
@USA Realty: I was not responding to your question about shared appreciation mortgages. I (and at least one other person) were responding to your incorrect statements that "VA has an ownership interest in each property," that "A VA loan is a type of Shared Equity Mortgage" and that "originality [sic] - the Vet was a tenant with equitable interest." I don't think I'm splitting hairs here; if you are a real estate broker, your misconceptions about the two kinds of financing for veterans could cost you deals, hurt your clients--or both.
jpim: (February 07, 2011 4:06pm)
Shared Equity Mortgage sounds like a program you would find under the Islamic Banking system where it is prohibited to charge interest. Instead lenders and borrowers enter into essentially a profit sharing agreement.
USA Realty, LLC: (February 07, 2011 4:00pm)
My question was not VA today or fifty years ago. My question was what do you think of 'Shared Equity Mortgage/Loans' now and for the future? Extrapolate the three words, S E M and apply to this market. Please think about it and then email your thoughts to: old broker dude -
[email protected]
.
JoeParsons: (February 07, 2011 3:44pm)
@USA Realty: You really DO need to do some homework. You seem to be confusing the VA Home Loan program, which has been around since before the end of WWII, with Cal-Vet, a California-only program in existence since the 1920s. That program (also 100% financing) uses a Land Contract for the security, where the state is the Vendor and the vet is the Vendee. He holds "equitable title," even though he doesn't receive legal title until the land contract is paid off through sale or refinance. I am not aware of any time where either of these loan programs has involved any sort of shared appreciation. I can speak from my personal experience as a veteran borrower, going back to 1973. I would be more than happy to admit my error if you can provide some documentation to substantiate your statements.
USA Realty, LLC: (February 07, 2011 3:24pm)
jpim, you sound like a robo-signer.
The #'s, %'s and $'s loan programs have changed but originality - the Vet was a tenant with equitable interest.
JoeParsons: (February 07, 2011 3:20pm)
@USA Realty: I highly recommend that you do some research about the VA home loan. It is in NO way a shared appreciation mortgage or equity share. The loan is guaranteed by VA (25% coverage) based on the Notice Of Value (NOV, formerly Certificate of Reasonable Value, CRV). Where did you get the idea that VA is anything other than what I've just described?
GODLIKE: (February 07, 2011 2:45pm)
Did we ever discover where the VA graph came from? I ran multiple searches on the mba national delinquency survey that was printed at the bottom and came up with nothing that resembled it.
USA Realty, LLC: (February 07, 2011 2:38pm)
A VA loan is a type of Shared Equity Mortgage.
Old Broker Dude
jpim: (February 07, 2011 2:36pm)
The VA guarantees the lender for the first 25% of their loss. Essentially they are insuring the lender. They do not have an ownership position? Unless of course they take over the asset from the lender and foreclose out the note themselves. I think that you might want to do a little more research on how the VA works.
USA Realty, LLC: (February 07, 2011 2:27pm)
VA has an ownership interest in each property and doesn't insure the loans like FHA, FANNIE and FREDDIE.
Guys come-on, Think Big, Think - Shared Equity Mortgage! Please blogger's - reply on what you think of S.E.M's????????? could be the answer to mortg/loan re-writes too...? What do you think?
Old Broker Dude,
USA REALTY
5pence: (February 07, 2011 1:24pm)
Confuse our electorate with the facts, I mean
5pence: (February 07, 2011 1:24pm)
Godlike makes a good point. You guys should enable sending the video without the blog. There's just too many smart people posting here and we don't want to confuse our electorate.
5pence: (February 07, 2011 1:19pm)
Thinking about that Fed response to you guys last week, saying it was a "form letter" was not appreciating us letting them not have to read thousands of protesting responses and was a very stupid way to dis-credit the messages that we all agreed on. I mean, wtf. Ron Paul, please slap some sense into these stupid mofo's at the Fed. We were TRYING to do them a favor!
Valuequestor: (February 07, 2011 12:35pm)
VA Loans perform better beacause of the over all calibre of the borrower, quality of the appraisal panel and underwriting. It all works together pretty well. That's why the banksters don't want a similar no nonsense program adopted. It would interfere with all of their income streams.
GODLIKE: (February 07, 2011 11:51am)
Since you guys are redoing the video anyway I think I'd vote for doing away with the blog. It appears you'd raise the IQ level quite a bit AND ALLOW PEOPLE TO LINK TO OR SEND YOUR BLOG TO OTHER PEOPLE. Now you can't because you never know what's going to show up in the blog portion.
JoeParsons: (February 07, 2011 11:11am)
@jpim: A very good point! That Certificate of Eligibility is like gold.
doitright: (February 07, 2011 11:08am)
jpim you have a great point about the COE but also think of this they sign a disclosure on a VA that the US Government will find them when they file and it will garnish the taxes and wages .It states walking is not a good option . Now that does make the VA a safer bet .
doitright: (February 07, 2011 11:04am)
5pence: That is a shame they made that slight mistake on a few cases at JP.... but come on it was a dozen cases , that did not throw those numbers off by that much . Point being said VA is not better then any other 100 % financing out there , it has to do with job stabilty . Loan to valuse is loan to value and risk is risk . All mortgage products blow now that there are no real jobs in the USA
jpim: (February 07, 2011 11:03am)
I have done a lot of VA loans and have come up with my own theory. Even though this is a 100% program the veteran still has "skin" in the game. Most veterans view their Certificate Of Eligibility as something that they earned and it is a sense of pride. The thought of letting the house go to foreclosure and loosing that COE is a hard thing for a veteran to face. That COE represents the time that they served and that portion of their life, to fail and loose that COE is a representation of their status as a veteran. While it isn't a cash position they still believe that they have something to loose if they walk on the house. Where a typical sub-prime borrower with 100% really has nothing more than their credit to risk. Just my thought......
5pence: (February 07, 2011 10:57am)
doitright : JP Morgan Chase Admits it Overcharged Families of Troops Fighting in Afghanistan For Their Mortgages, Foreclosed on Homes…
JP Morgan Chase — admits it has overcharged several thousand military families for their mortgages, including families of troops fighting in Afghanistan. The bank also tells NBC News that it improperly foreclosed on more than a dozen military families. http://weaselzippers.us/2011/01/17/jp-morgan-chase-admits-it-overcharged-families-of-troops-fighting-in-afghanistan-for-their-mortgages-foreclosed-on-homes/ .Kind of like AIG taking out their own policies on soldiers. Disgraceful. Fallen Soldiers’ Families Denied Cash as Insurers Profit. “It’s a betrayal. It saddens me as an American that a company would stoop so low as to make a profit on the death of a soldier. Is there anything lower than that?” AIG, CNA, ACE, Zurich and more are also War Profiteers and should be prosecuted as such.
JoeParsons: (February 07, 2011 10:49am)
@lowlyprocessor: Speaking as somene who has spent a fair amount of time in the military, I can tell you that veterans do not necessarily have more integrity than non-vets. The bar for entry in the military is not particularly high, and until 1973, many entered the military not of their own volition (they were drafted). I have nothing but admiration for my fellow veterans, but that group has its warts just as others do. I think the major factors in the good performance of 100% VA loans are that the loans are actually underwritten to determine whether that person can afford the home, and the payment is lower, because there is no mortgage insurance (the loan is guaranteed, not insured).
doitright: (February 07, 2011 10:37am)
More than 20,000 veterans, active-duty troops and reservists who took out special government-backed mortgages lost their homes last year, the highest number since 2003. The rate of foreclosure filings in 2010 among 163 ZIP codes near military bases rose 32 percent over 2008, according to RealtyTrac, a foreclosure research firm. This compares with a 2010 increase in foreclosure filings nationally of 23 percent over 2008.
doitright: (February 07, 2011 10:36am)
As far a more ingetrity have you ever seen a miltiary court? The same people that get VA loans beat up their wifes, cheat on them, get DWI's , steal etc, that was a predjudice remark to say because someone was in the military they have more integrity. Hell go ask your recruitment offcier on commission , if they have a pluse ( much like the old NINA days) they are in ! Please see the facts todays show is wrong in the past the VA has had a very high forclosure rate, why no jobs!
W.R.Buchanan: (February 07, 2011 10:25am)
Doitright: No that wouldn't fix anything. Here's the reason why.The Banks are making a killing right now with the FED deals and bailout money. If everybody could pay their bills they wouldn't make as much, so what they will do is derail any attempt to create jobs by stifleing lending.Oh, they are already doing that. No indictments for any wrong doing in this crisis? Somebody is screwed into the head guys pretty tight. No,,, until heads roll, and I mean the biggest heads, nothing will change.The biggest threat to our nation is the Wall Street banks plain and simple. It doesn't matter what kind of BS they come up with it is all distraction. Nothing will change until 2012 when a different outfit is in charge, but by then it might be too late. There needs to be a total, and complete removal of all bank connected people from our government, and a ban on all financial institution's lobbyists. Only then can this country rebuild it's financial system. But that ain't gonna happen soon.Randy
5pence: (February 07, 2011 10:07am)
It has everything to do with the appraisal. The loan isn't done without the appraisal. Appraisal and underwriting standards are what makes VA loans stand out above the rest. Funny thing is, the GSE's and FHA don't seem to want to follow the VA's success record - no money in it I'd guess.
doitright: (February 07, 2011 10:01am)
Everyone on here is missing the boat
JObs equal pay checks
pay checks equal money to pay the bills
A mortgage payment is a bill so with a job
the mortgage gets paid .
If someone has 105 % financing or 75 % financing it is the job that pays the mortgage .
The USA needs more jobs and the whole mess
is solved. Oh it also helps lower unemployment !
lowlyprocessor: (February 07, 2011 10:01am)
I've always thought that VA loans default less because most veterans have more integrity; am I the only one who thinks this way?
Fl Mortg Lady : (February 07, 2011 9:53am)
Joe;
I totally agree with you! This has nothing to do with the quality of the appraiser, and VA appraisers I have dealt with also do FHA and conventional, including USDA appraisals.
The FNMA Homepath difference for homebuyers is that repair work needed is commonly done upfront, not at an additional cost to buyers. FNMA seems to be doing it right… firming up the value with a decent, repaired home.
ALL LOANS are first about qualifying the borrower and then secondly, qualifying the property needs for rehab or escrow needs to match the borrowers’ financial ability to cover costs. Today’s market challenge is about finding repair loans and then making sure the repair cost fits the market value.
If we are lucky enough to find a VA borrower, these are gold, as most VA applicants don’t seem to buy to the maximum of their qualifying ratios.
Fl Mortg Lady : (February 07, 2011 9:52am)
Joe;
I totally agree with you! This has nothing to do with the quality of the appraiser, and VA appraisers I have dealt with also do FHA and conventional, including USDA appraisals.
The FNMA Homepath difference for homebuyers is that repair work needed is commonly done upfront, not at an additional cost to buyers. FNMA seems to be doing it right… firming up the value with a decent, repaired home.
ALL LOANS are first about qualifying the borrower and then secondly, qualifying the property needs for rehab or escrow needs to match the borrowers’ financial ability to cover costs. Today’s market challenge is about finding repair loans and then making sure the repair cost fits the market value.
If we are lucky enough to find a VA borrower, these are gold, as most VA applicants don’t seem to buy to the maximum of their qualifying ratios.
dstocker: (February 07, 2011 9:46am)
"skin in the game" is important. I think the VA program by the very nature of its participant’s, screens out more buyers that don’t have the integrity or the motivation to stick with it when things get tough. Vets generally have traits and resources that non Vets may not have due to their training, experience and the benefits they get. Seller assisted, non-profit, down payment assistance programs violate FHA's charter. That’s why FHA tried for years to shut them down, couldn’t and eventually gave up and put the responsibility on the lender to determine if the program is compliant. FHA was never allowed by congress to provide 100% financing which is pretty much what they do on DPA’s. We all know it’s a shell game. The property price is jacked up to accommodate the down. Do this on more than one property in a neighborhood and it starts abnormally increasing the property values which is exactly the reasoning for why it was not allowed in the first place.
5pence: (February 07, 2011 9:38am)
Yes, could not be foreseen in that the banks fraudulently loaned money on homes to people that didn't fit any underwriting standards because of greed for quick profits. No one could foresee that the banks had implanted time bombs into the mortgage market that would destroy home values all across the country, and then, when bailed out, would not help heal the economy they destroyed. No one would have thought the banks could be so reckless, and yet they were.
GetReal: (February 07, 2011 9:34am)
Here are some reasons why VA loans have a lower default rate: (1) The Down Payment does NOT make the monthly payment. (2) VA loans are assumable through an Installment Land Contract (ILC), also called a Contract for Deed (CFD), without triggering the STUPID due on transfer clause. If lenders would remove the due on transfer clause to allow more financially capable folks to takeover loans from distressed borrowers, there would be far fewer defaults. If lenders would qualify the property according to its income potential (i.e., how much debt it can support from market rents), then lenders could lend based on that valuation and the borrower would only make a down payment when the purchase price is higher than the income valuation. However, the STUPID Frank-n-Dodd financial reform law has essentially outlawed seller financing, which is contributing heavily to the REO and distressed property inventory. The stupid "foreclosure protection" laws are far too onerous to allow investors to buy.
JoeParsons: (February 07, 2011 9:18am)
@Rob in Az: Protective equity is certainly one loan factor that can reduce risk to the investor; but, speaking as someone who served in the U.S. Navy for eight years, my motivation to make the payment on my 100% VA loan had nothing to do with the fact that I had served. It was that I could afford the payment from day one, and that I didn't want to lose my home--equity or no. If, on the other hand, I had been able to inflate my income on the application, then ran into financial difficulty, I'd be a lot less likely to do whatever was necessary to keep my loan current. Many people today bought their homes with a down payment and documented their income but are now losing their homes because their incomes are gone or scaled down. That whole situation is exacerbated by the "strategic default" scenario, where a borrower is so far in the red that they decide to walk away, rather than continuing to live in "rental with debt." Neither of those cases could be foreseen by proper underwriting.
5pence: (February 07, 2011 9:06am)
But it's still far below his first 5 months in office, when Geithner met with chief executives from firms like Citigroup, JPMorgan Chase, Morgan Stanley & BlackRock at least 76 times. Hmm, 5 months and 76 times. That's about 110 business days and little Timmy met with banksters 76 times or about 70% of the time or 3.5 days per week. He obvioulsy wasn't there to regulate or he'd be talking to the Federal Reserve. Want to bet his future is secure with GS or any other bank after his treasury stint? He might as well be a GS man imo.
5pence: (February 07, 2011 8:54am)
Treas Secretary Tim Geithner has met more often with Goldman Sachs CEO Blankfein than Congressional leaders, including the House Speaker & the Senate Majority Leader, according to his official calendar. All told, Geithner met with, spoke to, or attempted to secure conversations with Wall St chieftains at least 49 times during the 5 month period ending in March 2010, a slight increase from the 37 entries on his calendar during the previous five-month period. But it's still far below his first 5 months in office, when Geithner met with chief executives from firms like Citigroup, JPMorgan Chase, Morgan Stanley & BlackRock at least 76 times-more calendar entries than for the heads of the regional Federal Reserve banks, who are the top overseers of systemically-important banks like JPMorgan, Citi, B of A & Wells F - or for top members of Congress like Reid, Pelosi, their Republican counterparts & the heads of the Senate & House committees overseeing financial institutions & economic policy.
Appraiser Micro: (February 07, 2011 8:46am)
Good call 5pence - I call in every 6 months and refresh my VA application. That's the "end game". One of the last quality appraisal management clients left - the VA panel.
Rob in AZ: (February 07, 2011 8:42am)
Sorry, guys, one of the deciding factors on loan performance is still "skin in the game". VA borrowers risked their literal skins to protect us all--that's their "skin in the game". Seller-financed DPA is just a paperwork "sleight-of-hand" making it appear ON PAPER that borrowers have put some "skin in the game" when they actually haven't. It creates a new moral hazard around the idea of down payment. If you want 100% financing, do it honestly & above-board with stricter guidelines & higher MIP premiums to compensate for the significantly higher risk. But let's not try to sidestep the guidelines by using a loophole like this. Cheers.
5pence: (February 07, 2011 8:33am)
Oh, and another thing, VA actually does quality underwriting on their loans. So, good appraisers in a closed fair fee system with quality underwriting = low foreclosure rate. Nope, DPA will not work outside of VA without causing huge problems, bubbles. VA makes it work because they control who does the appraisals and they only choose those appraisers (for their panel) with experience, ethics and competence. That's not the SOP of todays amc and their appraisers.
GODLIKE: (February 07, 2011 8:27am)
USDA is also proof 100% financing can work. But in both the case of VA and USDA you have a special set of circumstances to qualify for the loan types and if you crap in your nest you don't get one of those loans again. Unlike getting a 100% LTV just cause you're ENTITLED to.
5pence: (February 07, 2011 8:26am)
The only way they could have ran 60 to 1 leverage and run the total CDO market to hundreds of trillions of dollars is if they got paid for the mortgages upfront. It's the only way. They got paid off for the mortgages they are now foreclosing on, double dipping on the same house. I hope the AG's stick it to them good. As far as VA, my opinion is that the appraisers they pick are the best. It's a very hard panel to get on - the VA. That's the only reason why they have such a low foreclosure rate. In the present environment with AMC's, DPA would just create more bubbles since they use any hack with an appraisers license. It won't work in the retail market like it does for VA unless the retail market adopts VA appraisal standards. That won't happen any time soon.
Fl Mortg Lady : (February 07, 2011 8:25am)
In Florida, I am having GREAT SUCCESS with USDA 100% loans that have 3.5% financed MI and will allow seller to pay 6% of sales price in closing costs, with appraisal needed. Also, closing FNMA Homepath 97% loans requiring NO MI but interest rate is higher, and no appraisal needed… and FNMA Homepath allowed sales price to be increased to cover more closing costs! These are two borrower qualified high LTV mortgage products doing very well in spite of higher MI or higher rate!
In both cases FNMA and USDA acknowledge increased sales price to cover costs needed, as long as the market can bear it, versus foreclosure banks that refuse to go up on sales price to cover needed repairs or closing costs, even if the market value is there to do so.
Appraiser Micro: (February 07, 2011 8:23am)
Additionally, the homes would not "need to appraise", if the buyers had enough down to cover the spread difference in yesterdays prices, and todays prices. There is no reason for an appraiser to "bring in" a high value opinion that's not aligned with average pricing. "From the shoes of a buyer." Not "From the shoes of an owner." / The appraiser works with "other peoples numbers". If "Other People" knew what they were doing, the homes "would appraise." If you're having a repeated problem with appraised value, you must bend like the reed in the wind. The appraiser is not killing your deals, the buyers in the market that appraiser is working are the real culprits. Don't blame the appraiser - reconsider your approach instead.
ilendem: (February 07, 2011 8:19am)
Why bother with seller assisted downpayment programs. They raise the selling price which creates a higher LTV than 100%. Allow 100% FHA loans without boosting the MIP.
JoeParsons: (February 07, 2011 8:16am)
@USofD...: Bernanke never worked for GS. He came from academia. He was a tenured professor of Economics at Princeton University. Geithner has never worked at Goldman Sachs, either. Only Hank Paulson, who was its COO and CEO.
Appraiser Micro: (February 07, 2011 8:16am)
commonsense - Price does not equal value. Market value relationships vs cost to build are tentative in the resale market at best. Value is driven by BUYER AFFORDABILITY, and what buyers accept in sale situations. "The home needs to appraise" is a non-appraiser term. The appraiser did appraise that home, unfortunately for you, the buyers in that area did not "prove the value" in price. If buyers were affording those price tags, the homes "would appraise". Don't blame the appraiser for telling you something you're not ready to accept - buyers are driving home prices down in relationship to their struggling and reducing affordability factors.
rob: (February 07, 2011 8:12am)
I agree that the seller wants to increase the price, but in today's market they really can't.
I would like to see the DPA but they cannot pay for the down AND the closing cost.
Sellers pay for closing cost all the time. So use what would be a closing cost and then bump the rate to cover the closing cost. That solves the seller raising the price debate.
I always tell buyers to look at raising the rate and lower the price by what the seller was willing to pay or a combination. I believe that a buyer is better off with a bump in the rate and owing less money.
The rate argument is for loans that go out 10-15 years and we all know that rarely happens.
But if a buyer has to sell the property in 3-4 years they will be in a better position to do so because they owe less money.
5pence: (February 07, 2011 8:12am)
RACKETEERING ACTIVITY: any act which is indictable under the following [sections] of 18, U.S.C.: 201 (bribery) (rating agencies), 1029 (fraud with access devices), 1341 (mail fraud), 1343 (wire fraud), 1344 (financial institution fraud), 1503 (obstruction of justice), 1510 (obstruction of criminal investigations), 1952 (racketeering), 1956 (laundering of monetary instruments), 1957 (monetary transactions derived from specified unlawful activity). indictable under 29 U.S.C: fraud in sale of securities,
☆ rack·et·eer (rak′ə tir′)a person who obtains money illegally, as by bootlegging, FRAUD, or, esp., extortion. **The banks got paid off for these loans as soon as they were made through slicing and dicing. The taxpayer, through government, makes sure they get made whole again, but what does that mean? It means paying off their investors. So the banks get to keep the money they made on mortgages being paid in full by trading & they also now get the home in foreclosure to sell again.
llequire1: (February 07, 2011 8:06am)
I was following up with a pre-approval letter from a commercial broker the other day and was told that Commercial lenders don't need the NMLS number?
JDrobeck: (February 07, 2011 7:49am)
I would imagine that a VA loan preforms better because overall the buyer is of a "higher caliber". The military instills a level of discipline & honor in people that many civilians just dont have. This carries with many people for the rest of their lives. If the guidelines for VA & FHA were the exact same, I guarantee the VA would have lower default rates.
USofDumbamerica: (February 07, 2011 7:44am)
A few posts have commented about the possible relationship between the Fed and the big banks. This is NOT a 'possible' but FACTUAL relationship.
Bernake, Geithner, and Paulson were ALL GOLDMAN SACHS employees prior to their Fed/Treasury positions. Goldman/Lehman/Bear are all the primary mechanisms that took all the garbage loans, packed them into MBS (mortgage backed securities) and sold the disease everywhere. The banks made billions underwriting the crap, Goldman (and the rating agencies) made billions selling them off, and the fed backstopped everything because of the incestuous relationship.
Let there be NO CONFUSION about this...the Fed IS the banking industry..Goldman..IS the banking industry..and the top fed/treasury officials ARE Goldman....see how FXX'd up it is?
Daggone: (February 07, 2011 7:36am)
joephoto - substitute "loan originator" for broker please in your comment and you will be accurate.
doitright: (February 07, 2011 7:30am)
How to solve the housing crisis ? Very simple we become a strong nation agai n and manufacture our own products or at least 70 % of them , that creates jobs , and that creates home ownership. Even at 10 % loan to value if there is no income there is no payment made . The government has twisted ( and shows like this have fallen for it ) what they messed up to push the blame on loan officers and our lending terms . The truth is they designed deals to take everyones jobs away. We can not pay our bills with a service econony alone. If you ask someone why they are forclosing they will tell you , I lost my job and can not replace it unless I move to India . I would hope this show can shed some light on the true reason we are failing on home loans, very simple you need a job to make money to pay the mortgage . Thank you
USDAman: (February 07, 2011 7:29am)
I am so sick of people in this industry blaming the Option ARM loans for the downfall of the industry. That is the biggest display of ignorance that one can possible display. Yes, it is true that there were alot of the loans sold by scumbag originators, but no more so than any other loan that required no income verification. Blame Countrywide's Fast & Easy program...These loans were sold to the brokers as being available with no income verification if a borrower had a 720 credit score and 10% down. Then they were sold to FNMA as full doc loans. Option ARM loans are exceelent products if sold to a resonsible person. I have an Option ARM on my own house and am enjoying a 2.60% interest rate without any threat at all of the rate going up any time soon. Even someone making the minimum payment would be paying off principal and interest. Blaming Option ARMs for the downfall is ridiculous.
Psn8ldy: (February 07, 2011 7:23am)
100% loan to value? Great in appreciating markets, but if I'm not mistaken, there are not too many of those. You want to sell homes? How about 60% LTV with no qualifying? How about equity sharing 80% LTV with easier qualifying? The solution is not about less down payment, it's about getting loans to people who can't qualify with todays rediculous underwriting standards.
DCinFL: (February 07, 2011 7:16am)
I was never a fan of seller paid down payment assistance because sellers always raised the sales price of the home to cover the "assistance". 100% LTV loans make more sense for the buyer, seller, and the lender. As others have already stated high LTV loans were not the problem. No income verification, no asset verification, no rent history, no credit history, and negative amortization were the problems. A 100% LTV loan program based on todays stricter underwriting guidelines would perform just as well as FHA loans.
marshakirven: (February 07, 2011 7:05am)
Think 100% loans are great, but don't think the DAP was a good idea. By making the seller pay for the down payment, you created a situation where the housing prices were manipulated. Also, you created all these "supposedly" nonprofit organizations that charged extra fees. Just do a 100% loan for regular buyers. There are some banks doing these locally with no mortgage insurance, but the buyers have to make less than $49,000 a year.
Also, would like to mention to the person who says there shouldn't be no doc loans or stated income loans. I'm glad he has a job where he doesn't work on commission only, like most of us in real estate. We are the very ones who need these types of loans.
davidrider: (February 07, 2011 6:57am)
When you look at both VA and USDA loans, the distinct difference is the DTI ratio vs "Traditional" Loans. VA and USDA normally limit you to a max 45% dti and sometimes even that is too high for an approval. Both FHA and Conventional will still let you go to 50-57% DTI! This is unsustainable for most borrowers.
huberlaw: (February 07, 2011 6:56am)
While it would be nice to give the industry "a shot in the arm", the correlation between the VA loan record and subprime viability is a bit to simple to be accurate. I suspect that a large contributing factor could be the discipline and mind-set of those with a military background....
rob: (February 07, 2011 6:42am)
@doitright I agree that it is income. I never considered a vet coming home from a war and out of work. Most of my va loans are post service, so their job is in place. (I am a Realtor)
Tough call on not giving someone a loan while they are VOLUNTEERING. I am veteran and believe strongly that if you volunteer, you should very easily be able to buy house when you get out.
As you mentioned it was about the income not that it was 100%
I think if people CAN pay they will. As long as they are in a house they can afford. Back to that income thing again.
Paulsmoney: (February 07, 2011 6:27am)
In the Army we were taught responsibility and accountability both as it related to matters at hand and when we interacted in the 'civilian world'
CREDIT was to be honored and not abused.
That is why VA loans work better IMHO. The alternative 100% programs were fueled by fraud and feverishly promoted by greedy __________ .
As for a return to seller assisted down payment programs, the banks have sucked up vast quantities of inventory and control deflated values in the neighborhoods. I couldn't help a prospective buyer because I have no equity.
It's all crap
Spaghetti60: (February 07, 2011 6:22am)
You are forgetting one very important thing about VA loans. These GI's lived a very strict life with 2+++ years and are a very responsible group. Maybe there should be a boot camp for all borrowers. Then you might have something..
Take it from me a Viet Nam Era Vet
DanSchweihs: (February 07, 2011 6:18am)
Fannie and Freddie’s underwriting model is flawed. Years ago, they allowed 50% housing ratio loans. Check out USDA’s loan performance. They also have a 100% LTV loan. Both VA and USDA have little or no monthly mortgage insurance so the borrower has a lower monthly payment. That is really the key to this. The solution: fix the underwriting models and spend the time to work through the arithmetic on: http://www.hard-loans.com/Solution.htm. This solution would increase the pool of available buyers; eliminate the housing glut: end the recession. But it does require a few minutes of time to understand the arithmetic.
doitright: (February 07, 2011 5:59am)
Rob think about this you come home from a war , and you get out of the military . Guess what no jobs out there waiting for you , so you default on that 100 % deal you wrote . Why are we all thinking it it this program or that program that caused the defaults? It is real simple it is lack of income no matter what the program. The prople that can not pay are jobless and on all types of programs , the facts prove that , the USA has no jobs , the Politians screwed that up a long time ago .
commonsense: (February 07, 2011 5:59am)
You almost have no "industry". my point is even the 2 or 3% of the cases that close now, because of the rules imposed on the appraisal industry you would will not be able to rewrite the loan if the rates went to say 1.5%. 800 credit score,23% ltv-IF IT DON'T APPRAISE IT DON'T CLOSE!!
rob: (February 07, 2011 5:54am)
@doitright, the chart says MBA National Delinquency Survey.
I am not validating their info.
I searched and could find anything on it other than a blurb about a Q4 '09
Nothing says that the va loans are not defaulting, they are defaulting less than the other types, ACCORDING to the chart.
doitright: (February 07, 2011 5:46am)
I dont know where this show gets its information ??? Here is the truth once the Veterans comes home and the pay from the miltiary stops , so does making the mortgage payment! More than 20,000 veterans, active-duty troops and reservists who took out special government-backed mortgages lost their homes last year, the highest number since 2003.
The rate of foreclosure filings in 2010 among 163 ZIP codes near military bases rose 32 percent over 2008, according to RealtyTrac, a foreclosure research firm. This compares with a 2010 increase in foreclosure filings nationally of 23 percent over 2008.
John's Texas: (February 07, 2011 5:37am)
Didn't DPAs have a 30%+ failure rate?? Hmm no skin in the deal. I'm just saying.
cediii: (February 07, 2011 5:32am)
VA works because income is verifed and there is a residual income requirement as well. Also, only 30% of those between 17 & 24 qualify for admission into the service. The 3 criteria are high school diploma; physically fit; and background check (drugs and criminal behavoir). 70% can't get in so VA borrowers are PRESCREENED!
barbara: (February 07, 2011 5:30am)
Don't draw too much attention to the VA, or the idiots who are playing Twister with our industry will step in to "fix" VA too!
rob: (February 07, 2011 5:21am)
hey can you guys share that chart? The more people that know about that the better.
rob: (February 07, 2011 4:54am)
I've never thought 100% was the problem. It was the verifying of income that was the issue.
There were loans where the borrower couldn't afford the payment at 50% LTV
You graph on VA proves it it.
RealtyCaffeine: (February 07, 2011 4:49am)
I suspect the success of the VA program has a lot more to do with the quality of the buyer than the loan product. I can't think of a more disciplined group of borrowers than those that have served our country by putting their lives on the line. Maybe the FHA and seller paid programs would be just as successful with 100% ltv if the borrowers had to go to boot camp first. 'DROP AND GIVE ME 50!!'
doitright: (February 07, 2011 4:41am)
The real facts before you vote above
More than 20,000 veterans, active-duty troops and reservists who took out special government-backed mortgages lost their homes last year, the highest number since 2003.
The rate of foreclosure filings in 2010 among 163 ZIP codes near military bases rose 32 percent over 2008, according to RealtyTrac, a foreclosure research firm. This compares with a 2010 increase in foreclosure filings nationally of 23 percent over 2008.
Again it is the econony not the industry ,if people can work and get paid we can do 150% LTV . Why did we ever allow the mortgage business to take the blame for us allowing our jobs to leave the USA. We do not make anything in the USA anymore , it is not the loan type , it is not the bank, it is the fact the customer had no income to pay the mortgage yet they need a place to live . That creates a thing valled foreclosure
hummingbird858: (February 07, 2011 4:35am)
WTF that depository institutions do NOT need the NMLS system. I am working a full time job WHILE testing and studying. It stressed me out so much that I am on medication, for Petes sake. Why not "the other guys"
I can't wait until they have to do it too. Meanwhile, I can cash in while they stress those tests and studying.
commonsense: (February 07, 2011 4:29am)
APPRAISALS GUYS!!!!! READ THIS "IF IT DOES NOT APPRAISE IT DOES NOT CLOSE!!!!!!!!! 8 TRILLION DOLLARS IN LOST EQUITY.(AND COUNTING) NONE OF THESE OTHER CHICKEN@#$#@ RULES MATTER IT IT DON'T
APPRAISE. IT IS JUST NONSENSE TO TALK ABOUT ANY THING ELSE!!!!!! BUBBLE PEOPLE- IT IS NOT A BUBBLE WHEN THE MATERIALS,JUST THE MATERIALS TO BUILD FOR A HOME ,(FRAMING,ROOFING,BRICKS,CONCRETE ETC SITTING IN THE SUPPLY HOUSE WITH NO LABOR COST FIGURED) COST MORE THAN THE SAME BRAND NEW BUILT HOME APPRAISES FOR! I GUARANTEE---NOTHING WILL CHANGE UNTIL THIS CHANGES.
deblakeley: (February 07, 2011 4:08am)
In my humble opinion, I'd like to see 100% loans come back as soon as possible. Now before you bust my chops, I would also advise that stiff underwriting be utilized....no more 580 scores, but upwards of 720+, no liar loans, full doc, 15-20-30 year fixed only....is that too much to ask? Seriously!
I totally agree that pay option loans promulgated a lot of the downfall in our industry, I hated the loan presentations by A.E.s coming into our offices and telling us that 75% of their business was pay option. Even then, I thought what a dumba$$ idea that was...trusting the borrower to choose a payment they like.....CW et al were asking for trouble. If this program made up 75% of their originations, then they deserved to die on the vine.
As for $700b being spent on a GOVERNMENT program, would not the money have been better spent elsewhere? I mean really..."I am here from the government to help you!" All I can say is "run Forrest, run!" Thppppppppp!
USofDumbamerica: (February 07, 2011 4:01am)
Paul "Yes Man" Mondor and the rest of the bobblehead bureaucrats have only ONE focus in mind. Funnel as much of YOUR earned income to the fail banks and their incompetent management.
Socialization of this entire industry is but a few more pen strokes away. In the very near future, we will all be issued red/white/blue BankofFailmerica or Blue/white Shittybank shirts and given marching orders. You will be assimilated. Comply or die.
Of course the failbanks can have staff appraisers to do THEIR valuations. They have FIREWALLS to prevent pressure. HAR HAR HAR....then how come every single senior executive claimed they had ABSOLUTELY NO KNOWLEDGE that their loan origination departments were not reviewing, properly underwriting or even LOOKING AT all those toxic loans?
Why I ask? Because the mgt team was too busy counting their gigantic bonus checks.
Origination fees out of your pocket into theirs.
Appraisal fees out of our pocket into theirs
We must keep fighting
doitright: (February 07, 2011 3:11am)
You guys need handcuffs when you talk , WTF is with all the hand and arm movements , it is like you dancing ans inlove with your voices
Swarm The Banks: (February 07, 2011 2:43am)
Why did the no deposit down loans work? It seems with the bankster and government intent to steal built up home equity and down payments from homeowners who have been in their homes for years but may be out of work, that buying with no money down means there is less to lose if one can't make their payments, although its not the best thing for one's credit rating.
joephoto5: (February 07, 2011 2:05am)
I have always felt that low-down and "sub-prime" got excessively blamed for the current crisis.
I feel 99% of the blame goes to the "Pay-Option" loans where buyers could start with $500-$600 /month for the first year.
Buyers with insufficient income were LIED to by brokers and told $500/$600 payments would be permanent.
I cannot count the number of clients I have had call me and tell me they are only on SSI or SS ($800 - $1500/mo), yet SURPRISED to find their eventual payments would exceed $2000/mo.
In many cases, the broker's falsified their application and put down they were making over $6000/mo.
I know this happened because I personally had many-many (telemarketer) calls (at home) myself where the caller insisted he could get me a "1%" loan and would NOT tell me it would ever go "up". (I kept one on the phone for over an hour, trying to get him to admit the 1% was not permanent, he never did.)
EVERYONE with insufficient income was DOOMED with those loans.